Strategic Development Nov 10 2026
Ep. 70

Strategic Development Nov 10 2026

•

Episode description

Strategic Development Committee meeting, held November 10, 2026 at 05:56 PM

Download transcript (.vtt)
0:00

Unknown: gives a regress to the

5:16

Unknown: Good evening and welcome to the Strategic Development Committee and Special Board Meeting

5:24

SPEAKER_00: of November 10, 2026.

5:28

SPEAKER_00: This room is equipped with a safety alarm.

5:31

SPEAKER_00: If the alarm sounds, please leave in an orderly manner via the exits to the lobby or behind

5:38

SPEAKER_00: the dais.

5:40

SPEAKER_00: Assemble in front of the building and wait to hear the all clear announcement from security

5:46

SPEAKER_00: before re-entering.

5:48

SPEAKER_00: This meeting is being recorded and can be accessed on SMUD's website.

5:53

SPEAKER_00: Please remember to unmute your microphone when speaking in order that our virtual attendees

5:59

SPEAKER_00: may hear.

6:01

SPEAKER_00: The microphone will display a green indicator light when the microphone is on.

6:07

SPEAKER_00: For members of the public attending in person that wish to speak at this meeting, please

6:13

SPEAKER_00: fill out a speaker's request form located on the table outside this room and hand it

6:20

SPEAKER_00: to SMUD's security.

6:22

SPEAKER_00: Members of the public attending this meeting virtually that wish to provide verbal comments

6:28

SPEAKER_00: during the committee meeting may do so by using the raise hand feature in Zoom or pressing

6:36

SPEAKER_00: star 9 when dialed into the telephone toll-free number at the time public comment is called.

6:44

SPEAKER_00: Technical support staff will enable the audio for you when your name is announced during

6:49

SPEAKER_00: the public comment period.

6:52

SPEAKER_00: You may also submit written comments by emailing them to publiccommentatsmud.org.

7:01

SPEAKER_00: Written comments will not be read into the record but will be provided to the board electronically

7:07

SPEAKER_00: and placed into the record of the meeting if the comments are received within two hours

7:13

SPEAKER_00: after the meeting ends.

7:16

SPEAKER_00: Deputy General Counsel, please conduct the roll call.

7:20

SPEAKER_04: Director Fishman.

7:21

Unknown: Here.

7:22

Unknown: Vice Chair Herber.

7:23

Unknown: Here.

7:24

SPEAKER_04: Chair Samborn.

7:27

SPEAKER_04: Directors Herber and Fishman are present.

7:29

SPEAKER_04: So present are Directors Rose and Demayo.

7:33

SPEAKER_00: Wonderful and I just want to say that board member Heidi Sanborn usually chairs this committee

7:40

SPEAKER_00: but she is traveling and so is not available to be here but she did tell me that she will

7:47

SPEAKER_00: be listening in.

7:50

SPEAKER_00: So item number one on tonight's agenda is to discuss authorizing the CEO to negotiate

7:58

SPEAKER_00: an award and award a contract to KPMG LLP to provide project assurance, quality assurance

8:08

SPEAKER_00: services for SAP S4HANA implementation for the period of December 1, 2026 through May

8:20

SPEAKER_00: 31, 2028.

8:23

SPEAKER_00: In an amount not to exceed $4,465,000.

8:34

SPEAKER_00: And so we would like to welcome up Linda Wong, the director of internal audit services.

8:49

SPEAKER_12: Thank you for the introduction.

8:51

SPEAKER_12: And good evening.

8:53

SPEAKER_12: Director Herber, vice chair of the strategic development committee, members of the SMUD

8:59

SPEAKER_12: board of directors and all attendees.

9:01

SPEAKER_12: My name is Linda Wong.

9:03

SPEAKER_12: I am the director of audit services.

9:05

SPEAKER_12: And tonight I'm bringing forward recommendation for the board to authorize the CEO and general

9:13

SPEAKER_12: manager to negotiate an award and award a contract to KPMG for independent project assurance

9:21

SPEAKER_12: and quality assurance services over the S4HANA implementation.

9:27

SPEAKER_12: I will go ahead and walk through why this oversight function matters, how the vendor

9:32

SPEAKER_12: selection was selected and the specific action we're asking for tonight.

9:40

SPEAKER_12: Let me start with why the role exists.

9:43

SPEAKER_12: As you know, S4HANA is one of the largest ERP and SAP technology undertaking in over

9:50

SPEAKER_12: 25 years.

9:53

SPEAKER_12: And it touches every part of the business.

9:56

SPEAKER_12: From supply chain, finance, maintenance, customer engagement and enterprise reporting.

10:03

Unknown: Consequently, a program of this size and risk profile deserves and needs a dedicated independent

10:12

SPEAKER_12: eyes on it.

10:14

SPEAKER_12: And that is a team that is separate from that building, the system itself.

10:20

SPEAKER_12: And that is exactly what project assurance and quality assurance, also known as PAQA,

10:25

SPEAKER_12: provides.

10:28

SPEAKER_12: So what are the objectives and scope of the project assurance and quality assurance services?

10:37

SPEAKER_12: It basically provides independent oversight and assurance across every phase of the project,

10:43

SPEAKER_12: not just at a point in time, but in a continuous coverage all the way from the design to go

10:50

SPEAKER_12: live.

10:52

Unknown: PAQA also helps identify risk issues and gaps early.

10:59

SPEAKER_12: And if problems arise throughout the project, they can be addressed sooner than later when

11:05

SPEAKER_12: things are cheap and fast to fix.

11:10

SPEAKER_12: So how is this done?

11:12

SPEAKER_12: What PAQA provides is a review and evaluation of the technical and functional work itself.

11:20

SPEAKER_12: So that means the requirements, the test plans and the results, the operation on go live

11:26

SPEAKER_12: readiness, as well as cut over planning.

11:30

SPEAKER_12: All of this is done to ensure and confirm that it is complete, accurate and meets the

11:35

SPEAKER_12: business needs.

11:38

SPEAKER_12: In addition, what PAQA provides is to verify that the fit to standard guiding principle

11:45

SPEAKER_12: is adhered to.

11:47

SPEAKER_12: And if there is any customization, that it is approved and properly documented.

11:55

SPEAKER_12: We know that a technically successful go live may still fail if the organization isn't

12:03

SPEAKER_12: ready to use the system.

12:07

SPEAKER_12: So what PAQA will do is to evaluate the people side of this transformation.

12:12

SPEAKER_12: That would be reviewing stakeholder engagement, training, as well as change management, and

12:20

SPEAKER_12: of course user adoption.

12:23

SPEAKER_12: And lastly, PAQA provides an objective and transparent executive level reporting.

12:29

SPEAKER_12: And this will enable to have informed decision making.

12:37

SPEAKER_12: What this slide here shows is where the PAQA vendor that is in that yellow box sits relative

12:45

SPEAKER_12: to the other vendors working on this project.

12:48

SPEAKER_12: As you can see, it reports directly to internal audit, which is not obviously the delivery

13:01

SPEAKER_12: team.

13:02

SPEAKER_12: And what it does is that it preserves its independence.

13:06

SPEAKER_12: And because of its reporting structure, it allows direct communication with the executive

13:11

SPEAKER_12: steering committee if any issues, any significant issues or risks are identified and not mitigated.

13:26

SPEAKER_12: So in terms of the vendor selection process, let me begin by saying that after a very deliberate

13:33

SPEAKER_12: and multi-step procurement process, we did end up with one vendor that met the pass fail

13:40

SPEAKER_12: requirement as well as the minimum score threshold, which was set at 80%.

13:49

Unknown: I do want to take the time here to acknowledge that the board had some concerns regarding

13:54

SPEAKER_12: setting a minimum score threshold that could be more limiting than necessary and that could

14:00

SPEAKER_12: have excluded qualified competitors.

14:04

SPEAKER_12: Let me address this concern in my next slide.

14:07

SPEAKER_12: But let me start here by just going at a high level, the steps that we took to inform

14:12

SPEAKER_12: our RFP.

14:16

SPEAKER_12: We started with a market scan.

14:20

SPEAKER_12: The market scan entailed the staff meeting with other peer public utilities that ran

14:26

SPEAKER_12: similar assurance work in their own ERP system.

14:30

SPEAKER_12: So we met with New York Power Authority, Salt River Project, Nebraska Public Power, and

14:37

SPEAKER_12: Southern Gas.

14:39

SPEAKER_12: We also met with Wood McKenzie, which is a global consulting firm that had specific experience

14:46

SPEAKER_12: supporting PAQA procurement for utilities.

14:51

SPEAKER_12: After the market research, we also issued a request for information where we got seven

14:57

SPEAKER_12: respondents.

15:00

SPEAKER_12: Both the market scan and the RFI provided us with very valuable information.

15:07

SPEAKER_12: For example, it confirmed the value of independent oversight.

15:13

SPEAKER_12: It informed us how to best structure the PAQA role to protect its independence, as well

15:19

SPEAKER_12: as informing us on team structure, key pricing models, working on site versus remote.

15:28

SPEAKER_12: But the biggest key takeaway was the importance of choosing a vendor with experience specifically

15:36

Unknown: in the utility industry with S4HANA experience and in project assurance.

15:44

SPEAKER_12: So all this information fed directly into what became our formal RFP.

15:52

SPEAKER_12: The RFP was issued in May of 2026.

15:55

SPEAKER_12: We received 11 respondents.

15:58

SPEAKER_12: Four did not meet the pass-fail requirements.

16:04

SPEAKER_12: Two of them were shortlisted and were brought in for oral interviews.

16:09

SPEAKER_12: And as I mentioned earlier, only one KPMG met both the pass-fail requirements as well

16:15

SPEAKER_12: as the minimum technical score threshold.

16:20

Unknown: I would like to point out that we established this minimal technical threshold before the

16:25

SPEAKER_12: RFP was issued.

16:27

SPEAKER_12: It was, like I said, set at 80 percent and purposely aligned with the SIRFP.

16:35

SPEAKER_12: And this was done to ensure that the vendor that was selected met, not met, but had the

16:42

SPEAKER_12: necessary experience and also had a solid methodology.

16:52

SPEAKER_12: So to address a previous concern that was brought up with the minimum score threshold

16:57

SPEAKER_12: not potentially limiting competition, we went ahead and there is a question.

17:11

SPEAKER_03: You can continue.

17:12

SPEAKER_03: You can finish.

17:13

SPEAKER_03: I'll ask my question at the end of your slide.

17:16

SPEAKER_12: So to address the previous concern, we show here a table with all the results without

17:22

SPEAKER_12: using the minimum score threshold.

17:28

SPEAKER_12: So as you can see, the total score of 100 shows C points, technical points, and price

17:35

SPEAKER_12: points.

17:38

SPEAKER_12: Without the minimum score threshold, KPMG still far outscored all proposers with a

17:44

SPEAKER_12: total score of 77.3 points out of 100 and with its second ranking vendor right after

17:52

SPEAKER_12: TMG with 61.85 points.

17:58

SPEAKER_12: So with or without the minimum score threshold, KPMG still came at the top.

18:08

Unknown: In this next slide, the top.

18:14

SPEAKER_03: So I wanted you to be done with that slide because you go back, please.

18:19

SPEAKER_03: So this is, again, a significant issue, right?

18:24

SPEAKER_03: So either we have a team that harshly scores that people are not minute.

18:30

SPEAKER_03: So the minimum threshold was 80%.

18:32

SPEAKER_03: Correct?

18:33

Unknown: Correct.

18:34

SPEAKER_03: So even our winning company, which KPMG is top four in the world, one of the best consulting

18:40

SPEAKER_03: companies, right?

18:41

Unknown: Been around for 150 years and they didn't meet it, right?

18:47

SPEAKER_03: If we held to the minimum threshold.

18:50

SPEAKER_03: So again, I need to go back to, I guess this is under Laura Lewis.

18:55

SPEAKER_03: I get confused as to where it is.

18:57

SPEAKER_03: This is a problem that when you look at KPMG and Gartner, Infotech, I don't know these

19:05

SPEAKER_03: other companies.

19:09

SPEAKER_03: There is something, there's a fallacy in our process that when the world's leading audit

19:17

SPEAKER_03: and consulting companies cannot meet and who are not making the cut, there's a problem.

19:25

SPEAKER_03: So I'm glad KPMG made it.

19:27

SPEAKER_03: I have, I've worked with them for 25 years.

19:30

SPEAKER_03: They are the most expensive.

19:31

SPEAKER_03: You get what you pay for.

19:32

SPEAKER_03: They're very good, but there is a wholesale issue.

19:37

SPEAKER_03: We need to go back.

19:38

SPEAKER_03: We can't change anything now, but this is like the fifth RFP that there's, there's a

19:45

SPEAKER_03: problem when we smud think we're so unique and have so many purple squirrel requirements

19:54

SPEAKER_03: that some of the best companies in the world can't make the cut.

19:58

SPEAKER_03: Like I'm sorry.

19:59

SPEAKER_03: I'm again, it's too late to do anything now, but we as an organization need to look hard

20:06

SPEAKER_03: and deep.

20:07

SPEAKER_03: We are not that special.

20:09

SPEAKER_03: We are not that unique that we are continually having issues with the world's best companies

20:15

SPEAKER_03: not meeting our needs.

20:18

SPEAKER_03: So again, we can't do anything now.

20:20

SPEAKER_03: Thank goodness.

20:21

SPEAKER_03: You know, out of this group, I would have, you know, blindshotted KPMG is the best.

20:27

SPEAKER_03: So thank, thank goodness that we didn't say you needed to meet 80% because we wouldn't

20:32

SPEAKER_03: have gotten anybody.

20:33

SPEAKER_03: So again, somebody needs to take a hard look because this is a problem.

20:40

SPEAKER_03: They're significantly higher than the best.

20:42

SPEAKER_03: They are the best out of the group, but to say that the one, you know, the top five in

20:47

SPEAKER_03: the world didn't make our minimum threshold is a problem.

20:52

SPEAKER_03: So I'm glad someone made it to the top.

20:57

SPEAKER_12: I would like to actually make some clarifications here.

21:01

SPEAKER_12: Actually KPMG scored 90% in the technical minimum score threshold.

21:09

SPEAKER_03: You look at it like, you know, let's go back to school, right?

21:13

SPEAKER_03: Like 77% is a C. Let's just be real, right?

21:19

SPEAKER_03: Like when we all went to grade school, like that's not like, yay, we hit like the best

21:26

SPEAKER_03: company, right?

21:29

SPEAKER_03: Like that's a concern, right?

21:32

SPEAKER_03: That there's something with the scoring.

21:34

SPEAKER_03: There's something that we are pushing so hard on these vendors that someone like Gartner,

21:40

SPEAKER_03: Infotech and KPMG are coming out.

21:43

SPEAKER_03: 49 is like F scoring.

21:46

SPEAKER_03: Gartner is not an F company.

21:50

SPEAKER_03: So I'm glad KPMG made it, but we need to take a hard look at how, because 77 out of 100

22:00

SPEAKER_03: does make me feel good.

22:06

SPEAKER_03: It shouldn't make anybody feel good.

22:08

SPEAKER_02: And all of these vendors are 43 to 77.

22:12

SPEAKER_03: I mean, let's again, bring it back to school.

22:15

SPEAKER_03: When we all went to school, would we like to get an FD and a C?

22:21

SPEAKER_02: Director Bowie-Thompson's Laura Ingway, CEO, wanted to thank you for your comments.

22:26

SPEAKER_02: We'll definitely look into this and take that feedback.

22:29

SPEAKER_02: I wanted to clarify the technical scoring, the total score includes the price points

22:34

SPEAKER_02: as well.

22:35

SPEAKER_02: The technical scoring that they were evaluated on is that 70 points of technical points and

22:40

SPEAKER_02: KPMG got 63 out of it.

22:41

SPEAKER_02: So they got a pretty good score there on the technical side as well.

22:45

SPEAKER_02: But I definitely hear you and we will take that back.

22:47

Unknown: Like you said, you value for repay.

22:50

SPEAKER_03: They are the best, right?

22:52

SPEAKER_03: But they're also very expensive.

22:55

SPEAKER_03: And so there's something happening here, right?

22:59

Unknown: Again, if I were to blind shot it, I would have hoped KPMG made it.

23:04

SPEAKER_03: But they are 2 million above, right?

23:07

SPEAKER_03: And it's auditing and what they do compared to InfoTech or Gartner, $2 million worth more,

23:16

SPEAKER_03: right?

23:17

SPEAKER_03: That we're harshly scoring these other vendors who are very good, right?

23:22

Unknown: You know, again, glad they made it because they have a strong technical score.

23:28

SPEAKER_03: They're just very expensive.

23:31

Unknown: I'm going to jump in and pallet on a little bit more.

23:38

SPEAKER_15: We just had the discussion with the main contract and we went to IBM and they were by far the

23:44

SPEAKER_15: most expensive and everybody assures they're the very, very best.

23:47

SPEAKER_15: So what do we need an audit contract for if you've already paid the top dollar to get

23:54

SPEAKER_15: the very, very best?

23:56

SPEAKER_15: I guess would be one of my questions.

23:58

SPEAKER_15: Do we need this contract at all?

24:02

SPEAKER_15: I'm going to save the $4 million.

24:10

SPEAKER_02: Yeah, for a project, so Laura Angway, CEO, for a project this size, we definitely do want

24:15

SPEAKER_02: a PAP or QA consultant on this as well to make sure that we're raising issues.

24:21

SPEAKER_02: It's a huge project that has huge implications on the organization.

24:24

SPEAKER_02: So, yeah, definitely support having a contract.

24:28

SPEAKER_02: To do this work.

24:35

Unknown: No, and I fully support audit.

24:37

SPEAKER_03: I think it's extremely important, but we are paying a $2 million premium.

24:45

Unknown: Right.

24:49

SPEAKER_15: One of the things I noticed you want to fit, I think we have to resist the final slide.

24:53

SPEAKER_15: This is the final.

24:53

SPEAKER_15: Let me finish and I'll become more comments.

24:55

Unknown: Okay.

24:58

Unknown: So actually, it kind of all ties in.

25:03

SPEAKER_12: So since we received the first original proposal amount of $5.825 million, we have been working

25:12

SPEAKER_12: with KPMG to clarify and right size the scope to align with the project risk.

25:20

SPEAKER_12: And as a result, we actually the total proposal amount was reduced by $1.3 million, which

25:27

SPEAKER_12: is a 23% reduction.

25:31

Unknown: So it's not quite 2 million.

25:34

SPEAKER_12: It's still a million over the other scores.

25:37

SPEAKER_12: But I do want to point out that the difference between the services that KPMG will be providing

25:44

SPEAKER_12: and the next vendor is that they will be providing an embedded engagement model.

25:51

SPEAKER_12: And what that means is that they will have a lean core team that will be 100%

25:56

SPEAKER_12: dedicated to SMUD, to the PAQ at work here, and it will be on site.

26:01

SPEAKER_12: So is that worth an extra million dollars?

26:07

SPEAKER_12: You know, that is, I guess, a question.

26:11

SPEAKER_12: But that is an engagement model that was not proposed by the second vendor.

26:17

SPEAKER_12: So there is definitely a cost difference there.

26:19

SPEAKER_12: And that cost includes not only the professional services, but the travel and lodging for the

26:25

SPEAKER_12: entire 18 months.

26:26

SPEAKER_12: So right now, 15 months, they will be here.

26:36

SPEAKER_12: And Per diem for somebody to live in Sacramento for over a year, it's going to cost a lot of money.

26:41

SPEAKER_12: It could be actually a couple of people working with just one.

26:45

SPEAKER_15: Hopefully they're actually doing our work and they're not sitting here and then doing their other projects work.

26:55

SPEAKER_12: So with that information, in terms of the potential concerns of, you know, not having, I guess,

27:05

SPEAKER_12: cost competition, we only have one vendor.

27:09

SPEAKER_12: I mean, I will say that we still continue to work with them to refine.

27:13

SPEAKER_12: In fact, there's a couple of meetings this week with them may or may not change the price, but there was still ongoing.

27:20

SPEAKER_12: That is why the request is for negotiate an award.

27:26

Unknown: The bottom of this slide actually provides what the final score is, including the minimal threshold and the updated bid amount.

27:40

Unknown: So K-PINKIE scores is actually 93 out of 100.

27:47

Unknown: And the proposed award again is $4,465,000.

27:55

Unknown: Do we have more questions from board members?

28:01

Unknown: Director Rose.

28:02

SPEAKER_00: I do. I think Director Fishman asked a thought.

28:05

SPEAKER_15: Some of the questions I wrote down.

28:09

SPEAKER_15: The high level question is why is there so much cost variability?

28:14

SPEAKER_15: And I do wonder, like, did these vendors all bid on the same thing?

28:21

SPEAKER_15: When you start seeing so much scoring variability and so much cost variability, it's a bit of a head scratcher to me.

28:32

Unknown: I would say that the two top vendors definitely have a lot more experience in PAQA work.

28:41

SPEAKER_12: The other vendors have a lot of IV and V, which is somewhat similar to quality assurance.

28:49

SPEAKER_12: But in the scoring and the reason why we did this market scan is to really understand what was necessary,

28:57

SPEAKER_12: which is the experience and knowledge on the project assurance part, which is the governance and risk management piece.

29:06

SPEAKER_12: So and the other thing that I had mentioned during the presentation that we got from the market scan is the importance to have not only PAQA experience,

29:19

SPEAKER_12: but for them to have utility and SAP S4HANA experience.

29:24

SPEAKER_12: And the top two vendors did have those.

29:28

SPEAKER_12: I also want to take a moment here to also share that our technical scores emphasize both the firm experience as well as the team that was proposed.

29:39

SPEAKER_12: So some of these vendors came that have experience, but they did not provide a team that provided the confidence that we needed

29:47

SPEAKER_12: to effectively perform the work.

29:50

Unknown: So I noticed in the board memo there was the second place team when they got disqualified was in the oral score.

30:01

SPEAKER_15: I guess Mike, were they really as bad as their score represented?

30:08

SPEAKER_12: I would say that they are very knowledgeable and it actually niche in the utility industry.

30:14

SPEAKER_12: Unfortunately, their team did not have the experience that we thought was adequate.

30:21

SPEAKER_12: In fact, the lead did not have any PAQA experience.

30:26

SPEAKER_12: They did have SMEs.

30:29

SPEAKER_12: Right.

30:30

SPEAKER_12: Right.

30:32

SPEAKER_12: And that is the reason why their score was much lower.

30:34

SPEAKER_12: We did end up doing a debrief with TMG and specifically share that.

30:40

SPEAKER_12: And we're very thankful that this mud has the debrief process and took that, I guess, feedback and had wished that they had known because they would provide it a different team.

30:55

SPEAKER_12: But again, part of the process is...

30:59

SPEAKER_15: That's their own fault.

31:00

SPEAKER_15: Right.

31:01

SPEAKER_15: To not send staff who worked on these areas before.

31:06

SPEAKER_15: Correct.

31:06

SPEAKER_15: Goodness knows why.

31:09

SPEAKER_15: All right.

31:09

SPEAKER_15: Those are my main questions.

31:11

SPEAKER_15: Our echo director, Bowie Thompson.

31:15

SPEAKER_15: I'll approve this, but I want to stop seeing these.

31:20

SPEAKER_15: I'm going to start putting them on discussion calendar and voting no.

31:23

SPEAKER_15: But we've had a lot of discussion about this already, so I think it's okay.

31:30

SPEAKER_00: Thank you, Director Rose.

31:32

SPEAKER_00: Are there other questions or comments from board members?

31:35

SPEAKER_00: Yes, sir.

31:36

Unknown: I want to start by acknowledging, especially Director Bowie Thompson's expertise in these matters and my lack thereof.

31:44

SPEAKER_11: But I guess my question is, if having the people on site was kind of the deciding factor and also adding to the cost, maybe that...

31:58

SPEAKER_11: Should that have been part of the parameters of the RFP and saying we want dedicated people on site so the other firms could bid that as well?

32:05

SPEAKER_11: And then having said that, it also seems like we're buying an insurance policy.

32:17

SPEAKER_11: It's an expensive insurance policy, but we're spending a lot of money on the S-4HANA project.

32:22

SPEAKER_11: We need somebody to kind of be there constantly watching what's happening with the implementation of that project.

32:31

Unknown: And it's not an insignificant amount of money, but it seems like it's a decent insurance policy.

32:37

SPEAKER_11: So I'm happy to support it, but I do think we ought to take Director Bowie Thompson's advice into mind and say, okay, what are we doing that is excluding some really good companies from even making the technical cut?

32:53

SPEAKER_11: And should we be more explicit about what we're looking for in the RFPs?

32:58

SPEAKER_11: Leave it at that.

33:01

Unknown: Thank you.

33:02

SPEAKER_00: Are there any other comments?

33:05

SPEAKER_00: I just want to say that I too have no experience in this area and would defer to Director Bowie Thompson's evaluation of things.

33:19

SPEAKER_00: I do think it is too late for this contract, but I do want to say I know how important this S-IHANA project is.

33:34

SPEAKER_00: It's so key and so critical.

33:38

SPEAKER_00: And I think that we do need the extra insurance, but I do hope that folks will take a look at the next contract that we have and make sure that it's written in a way that folks can qualify for it.

33:59

SPEAKER_00: But we are where we are.

34:03

SPEAKER_00: Let me ask if we have any requests to speak on item number one from folks here or virtual attendees.

34:12

SPEAKER_00: We do not.

34:13

SPEAKER_00: Okay.

34:15

Unknown: All right.

34:15

SPEAKER_00: Well, thank you very much.

34:17

SPEAKER_00: And this will go on the consent calendar.

34:21

SPEAKER_00: Is that correct?

34:23

Unknown: Thank you.

34:24

SPEAKER_00: Item number two is to provide the board external presentations on nature-based carbon solutions and biodiversity and update the board on SMUD's related efforts.

34:41

SPEAKER_00: And it looks like we have several presenters.

34:46

SPEAKER_00: Kathleen Ave is first, the senior strategic business planner, and then we'll welcome Jennifer Burt, the senior restoration ecologist at GEI Consultants.

35:00

SPEAKER_00: Following Jennifer will be Hannah Kornfield, the climate practice leader at Ascent Environmental.

35:08

SPEAKER_00: And last but certainly not least is Brenda Holm, the senior climate action and specialist at Access Environmental.

35:18

SPEAKER_00: She is attending and presenting virtually.

35:22

SPEAKER_00: So let's go forward with Kathleen Ave.

35:27

SPEAKER_00: Welcome.

35:28

Unknown: Thank you very much.

35:29

SPEAKER_01: Vice Chair Herber, members of the board.

35:32

SPEAKER_01: My name is Kathleen Ave.

35:33

SPEAKER_01: I'm going to start our work tonight with an overview, a quick one, of the state of California's policy history that is supporting this work throughout the state and then talk briefly about the work that we've been doing at SMUD to keep pace with that policy over the last nine years or so.

35:55

SPEAKER_01: And then I'll turn it over, as you said, to Jennifer and Hannah to go through the detailed results of this of this inventory.

36:04

Unknown: So starting back in 2015, the second Brown administration, when they released their climate strategy, carbon sequestration in the land base was its own pillar in that strategy, in addition to the more traditional utility, renewable energy, energy efficiency, EV work.

36:22

SPEAKER_01: And so that gave it a place in policy work going forward.

36:27

SPEAKER_01: That was followed in 2020 by Governor Newsom's executive order and 8220, which established California's 30 by 30 plan that will conserve 30% of the state's lands and coastal waters by 2030.

36:42

SPEAKER_01: And it also required that the state develop a plan for natural and working lands.

36:48

SPEAKER_01: In 2022, Christina Garcia brought us AB1727.

36:52

SPEAKER_01: That set out a plan to establish nature-based carbon solution targets in 2030, 2038 and 2045.

37:00

SPEAKER_01: And then that year, the California Air Resources Board also updated the scoping plan to integrate natural and working lands.

37:10

SPEAKER_01: In 2024, those nature-based carbon solution targets were published for every major land cover type in the state and a special category for wildfire risk reduction.

37:22

SPEAKER_01: In 2025, CARB updated their methodology for natural and working lands, and some of that work has been incorporated into our new study.

37:30

Unknown: And then in 2026, they published an update of the actual inventory.

37:35

SPEAKER_01: And one interesting finding from that work was that California's natural and working lands actually absorbed more carbon than they released since 2001, which helps to counterbalance all the emissions that come from catastrophic wildfire really underscores the value of nature-based solutions.

37:53

SPEAKER_01: So here at SMUD, we...

37:54

SPEAKER_01: I have no clue what the inventory work is. I know who works on it.

38:00

SPEAKER_15: I find that premise to be crazy, a crazy thought.

38:05

SPEAKER_15: Especially thinking back to some of my coursework in school 25 years ago.

38:09

SPEAKER_15: Yeah.

38:10

SPEAKER_15: So anyway, I just digress.

38:11

SPEAKER_15: Well, it's in the report.

38:15

Unknown: All right.

38:15

SPEAKER_01: So, and you may remember, Director Rose, back in 2017, we actually created a Sacramento County version of an inventory.

38:26

SPEAKER_01: I think I presented it to the Land Use Committee at ECOS in 2019 or 18.

38:31

SPEAKER_01: Anyway, that work was actually an interesting utility first and a collaborative effort.

38:37

SPEAKER_01: We had ECOS involved in that, SACOG, the Nature Conservancy, CALCAN, Sacramento County, and CARB, and not really establish the importance of protecting existing carbon stocks, which you'll hear more about later tonight.

38:55

SPEAKER_01: Then in 2020, working with supportive Amanda Beck, who was developing the Rancho Seiko Solar II project at the time, I worked with Jennifer to develop a carbon farming and pollinator habitat.

39:07

SPEAKER_01: Research proposal, you'll remember the pandemic.

39:11

SPEAKER_01: That work was delayed slightly, but it did get off the ground in 2021.

39:16

SPEAKER_01: And then the picture up here in the top left in the center is a picture of one aspect of that work at Rancho Seiko.

39:23

SPEAKER_01: It's the hedge road that was built alongside our gas pipeline on Clay East Road.

39:27

SPEAKER_01: That picture was taken a couple of months after the plants went in with the very thick mulch technique used to test out

39:37

SPEAKER_01: ways to establish this kind of habitat with minimal additional supplemental irrigation.

39:43

SPEAKER_01: And the picture on the right to that was taken this year.

39:46

SPEAKER_01: Some of those shrubs are six feet tall now.

39:49

SPEAKER_01: So it's been a big success.

39:51

SPEAKER_01: That's a partnership with Epri and Xerces.

39:53

SPEAKER_01: And we took some of those methods that we were testing at Rancho Seiko up to our Orangevale substation in a project that was a collaboration with the city of Citrus Heights and the Native Plant Society, which donated plants.

40:06

SPEAKER_01: This is also a GEI project.

40:07

SPEAKER_01: They designed the garden on that slope, which does it's quite steep.

40:12

SPEAKER_01: It's steeper than it looks in these pictures.

40:14

SPEAKER_01: But you can see on the left the picture when we started a lot of non-native and pretty sparky fuel out there.

40:21

SPEAKER_01: Now it is green year round and there's a lot of woody biomass there that's absorbing carbon.

40:26

SPEAKER_01: So that's been a big success.

40:30

SPEAKER_15: I went out with the team earlier this year and it is gorgeous to see.

40:36

SPEAKER_15: And I certainly commend the staff going out there periodically and cleaning it and maintaining it.

40:41

SPEAKER_01: Vegetation management team has adopted it.

40:43

SPEAKER_01: They use it for engagement and quarterly meetings.

40:47

SPEAKER_01: So yeah, they take really good care of it.

40:49

SPEAKER_01: And we started doing some baseline testing out there and Rancho Seiko and had an interesting finding this year.

40:57

SPEAKER_01: After only two years out at Rancho Seiko, a 9% increase in soil organic carbon.

41:02

SPEAKER_01: That's way more than we expected in two years.

41:05

SPEAKER_01: Honestly, it could be an anomaly.

41:06

SPEAKER_01: We'll test again, but it's very encouraging.

41:09

SPEAKER_01: And that brings me to tonight's topic, the current inventory work that's part of our feasibility study.

41:16

SPEAKER_01: So you heard a little bit about this last fall when we were here.

41:21

SPEAKER_01: And Jennifer's going to come up now and give you a refresh.

41:25

SPEAKER_01: And we'll go from there.

41:30

Unknown: Thanks.

41:32

SPEAKER_00: If you could just introduce yourself again with your name and for the people on the virtual.

41:40

SPEAKER_13: Yeah, so I'm Jennifer Burt.

41:42

SPEAKER_13: I'm a senior restoration ecologist at GEI Consultants.

41:45

SPEAKER_13: And I'm leading the preparation of this feasibility study for the nature-based carbon solutions and biodiversity program first month.

41:55

SPEAKER_13: I will be handing off for a little bit to Hannah, Cornfield from Ascent, to talk about that carbon inventory analysis results.

42:01

SPEAKER_13: Then I'll be coming back to talk more about opportunities and analyses for this project.

42:08

SPEAKER_13: So, so far since we last presented to this board about last fall, we have defined the study area for the project,

42:19

SPEAKER_13: separated it into three ecoregions that identify how we will look at opportunities assessments.

42:26

SPEAKER_13: Ascent has compiled a substantial amount of GIS data on land cover and soils and completed the estimating the carbon carbon stocks on natural and working lands in the study area.

42:37

SPEAKER_13: And some scenarios for those carbon stocks based on the scoping plan scenarios that CARB analyzed in 2022.

42:47

SPEAKER_13: Underway, we are evaluating potential priority practices by these three regions and assessing opportunities for carbon preservation and sequestration and developing a project development framework for assessing or pursuing potential opportunities.

43:04

Unknown: So the carbon inventory that Hannah is going to present on is really like about describing where is carbon currently stored on the natural and working lands within the study area.

43:14

SPEAKER_13: So this is primarily in biomass, above ground biomass of vegetation and also in the soil of the of the lands.

43:21

SPEAKER_13: And this varies by region. It varies by land cover type. It has she will describe all of that from there.

43:27

SPEAKER_13: We're looking at the practices that can potentially help preserve those carbon stocks and or enhance them and also increase biodiversity or protect biodiversity.

43:38

SPEAKER_13: And then we'll be looking at opportunities assessment on where could help implement potential practices for these purposes.

43:46

SPEAKER_13: So I'm going to I think it's right.

43:49

SPEAKER_13: Hand over to Hannah to talk about the carbon inventory.

43:54

Unknown: The vice chair, Herbert, members of the board, my name is Hannah Kornfeld.

44:00

Unknown: I think I'd press something accidentally. OK, I serve as the climate practice leader for a set environmental.

44:07

SPEAKER_09: We're a consulting firm. We've supported smart on a variety of projects.

44:12

SPEAKER_09: I help a lot of local governments and special districts and utility providers think about climate planning and the role of natural and working lands in doing so.

44:24

Unknown: Before we get into the kind of results of what we've found so far in our study, I did want to just clarify a few of the key terms here.

44:33

SPEAKER_09: So we often hear of carbon sequestration. The primary term that we're going to be talking about here this evening is carbon stock,

44:41

Unknown: which is really referring to the total amount of carbon that's stored in natural and working lands at a specific point in time.

44:48

SPEAKER_09: So that's a mass amount. It's not a gas. And then carbon sequestration is really the rate at which carbon is being removed from the atmosphere stored in these various systems.

45:01

SPEAKER_09: And so a little bit more akin to emissions where you're thinking about tons of carbon per year.

45:07

SPEAKER_09: So the study will incorporate both of these ways of looking at carbon.

45:12

SPEAKER_09: But today's presentation will focus primarily on the carbon stock component of that.

45:19

Unknown: And when we talk about a carbon stock inventory, this is a simplified kind of way to break it down.

45:25

SPEAKER_09: We're really looking at how much carbon is stored through biologic sequestration.

45:31

SPEAKER_09: We're not talking about mechanical and really assessing both above ground and below ground carbon pools.

45:38

SPEAKER_09: So as shown in this graphic, these are examples of above ground and below ground carbon sources.

45:45

SPEAKER_09: Above ground carbon is found in vegetation, it's trees, branches, leaves, grasses, dead plant materials that are absorbing CO2 through photosynthesis.

45:58

Unknown: Below ground carbon is really talking about the roots and soils, mainly stored as soil organic matter.

46:04

SPEAKER_09: And it makes up about 75% of terrestrial carbon and can remain stored for millennia or be released through decomposition.

46:17

Unknown: Diving into what this study actually covers.

46:22

SPEAKER_09: So it's really we're trying to understand the scale and the distribution of carbon stocks within SMUD's area of influence,

46:29

SPEAKER_09: including within its service territory, transmission corridors and additional neighboring areas.

46:35

SPEAKER_09: And then as Jen will speak about a little while later is identifying opportunities to support large scale natural carbon sequestration as well as preserving those existing carbon stock stocks that we already have.

46:49

SPEAKER_09: And so to calculate that carbon stock inventory, we combined a variety of geospatial land cover data sets with carbon stock densities from peer reviewed studies and sources.

47:01

SPEAKER_09: We were not out in the field collecting these samples ourselves for each of these land cover types.

47:07

SPEAKER_09: We tried to find the closest matching studies and their carbon densities, which were often reported as metric tons of carbon per acre,

47:17

SPEAKER_09: which were then simply multiplied by the number of acres of that type.

47:21

SPEAKER_09: What is not shown in this summary is that there are 88 distinct land cover types and these are aggregated at a much higher level so that you can start to understand trends and patterns.

47:36

Unknown: All the results that we're presenting tonight are for the calendar year 2022 that represents the most spatial data set information that we could gather.

47:49

SPEAKER_09: This is really challenging work.

47:51

SPEAKER_09: It's not it's not done very often at this scale, this finite scale, because there is not a singular data source that's available that has this information.

48:00

SPEAKER_09: So we have to match a lot of different sources together.

48:04

SPEAKER_09: And 2022 was the most representative of the sources that we were able to use.

48:10

Unknown: Can I ask a quick question?

48:12

SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.

48:14

SPEAKER_00: I look up there, the general land cover categories, cropland is 26, grassland 18, urban is 26.

48:26

SPEAKER_00: When you look at those three numbers, what do they tell you?

48:30

Unknown: That's a great question.

48:31

SPEAKER_09: And if I might be able to move that to our next results slides, because that's really what we're going to get into.

48:37

SPEAKER_09: We first want to just make sure we're all understanding where these different land covers are.

48:41

SPEAKER_09: And yes, you can very clearly see kind of the Sacramento city and surrounding cities represented in urban.

48:48

SPEAKER_09: But yes, that's a great question.

48:49

SPEAKER_09: Well, let's come back to that.

48:54

SPEAKER_09: So, yes, I think you're you're noting some of the trends here.

48:57

SPEAKER_09: You can see in the east where the Sierras are that that's mostly forest.

49:03

SPEAKER_09: It's the green color.

49:05

SPEAKER_09: The southern kind of chin part of the study is where you see more orange representing cropland.

49:11

SPEAKER_09: And that's and wetlands, which is kind of that very bright green color that's mostly in the Delta region.

49:19

SPEAKER_09: So the two biggest land cover types are urban and croplands, both at 26 percent each.

49:27

SPEAKER_09: Grasslands at 18 percent and wetlands at 11 percent.

49:35

Unknown: So when we look at how much carbon is actually held in the study area, the map on the left indicates a heat map of biomass carbon.

49:46

SPEAKER_09: And the right is that same distribution of land covers that I presented on the previous slide.

49:51

SPEAKER_09: Again, biomass carbon is that above ground carbon that's held in vegetation.

49:57

SPEAKER_09: Most of the study area looks like it holds relatively minimal biomass.

50:02

SPEAKER_09: And it's really just due to the fact that it's being compared with the Sierra forests, which are holding so much more carbon that it looks disproportional.

50:14

SPEAKER_09: All of the data that is provided in this we have at a very fine scale.

50:18

SPEAKER_09: It's very hard to summarize this magnitude and this area in a singular map.

50:24

SPEAKER_09: So one of the things that we'll be doing is providing a more spatial data set that SMUD staff and others can really dig into and understand at a much finer scale.

50:39

SPEAKER_09: When we look at soil carbon, similarly, here is the heat map on the left and the land covers again on the right.

50:47

SPEAKER_09: Most of the soil carbon is held in croplands that are within the Delta region.

50:53

SPEAKER_09: The Delta is comprised primarily of cropland and wetland land cover types.

50:58

SPEAKER_09: And you can see that on the dark red on the screen here.

51:04

Unknown: So make sure I have it clear, right?

51:07

SPEAKER_15: So biomass is the key term to realize this is above ground and then the soil is what we know is underground.

51:16

SPEAKER_15: Correct.

51:18

Unknown: Yeah, great clarification.

51:18

SPEAKER_09: But what you said previously, right?

51:20

SPEAKER_15: The soil roughly has like 75% of the carbon.

51:23

Unknown: Exactly.

51:24

SPEAKER_09: Yeah.

51:29

Unknown: So the next two slides here, I'm going to focus specifically on the Delta region because these are such different sources of carbon and kind of warrant separation.

51:41

SPEAKER_09: So for the total amount of carbon that's currently being held in the Sacramento San Joaquin Delta, this is kind of what you start to get when you look at things

51:52

SPEAKER_09: proportionally.

51:53

Unknown: So all the land covers are represented.

51:57

SPEAKER_09: You'll see that the there's a call out box here that represents forest, barren and others.

52:03

SPEAKER_09: It's a relatively very small part of the Delta and the below ground is represented in the bluish green color above ground or the biomass carbon is represented in the yellow color.

52:16

Unknown: Obviously there is significant amount of carbon held in the soils of the wetland and the cropland land cover types in particular, which matches that dark red that you saw on the map before.

52:26

SPEAKER_09: There's relatively limited biomass in the Delta region when you compare that with the soil carbon.

52:32

SPEAKER_09: So sticking with the Delta area only 86% of the study area that we looked at, including Sacramento County, the transmission quarters, etc. 86% of the carbon is in the Delta.

52:48

SPEAKER_09: So it represents a significant amount of the carbon stock that this study is evaluating.

52:54

SPEAKER_09: It's equivalent to about 120 million metric tons of carbon and almost all of it is held in the soil.

53:00

SPEAKER_09: So 99% of that is held in the soil for the wetland parts of the Delta.

53:06

SPEAKER_09: The soil carbon estimates were obtained from soil samples that were analyzed by the San Francisco Estuary Institute.

53:13

SPEAKER_09: And what really makes the Delta unique is the peat soil that was formed over thousands of years ago.

53:19

SPEAKER_09: That has really high soil organic carbon content as deep as the peat layer goes, which can be up to 30 feet in some locations.

53:28

SPEAKER_09: This is a very different evaluation when the rest of the study area is only looking at soil at about a depth of 50 centimeters.

53:36

SPEAKER_09: That's just due to data availability.

53:39

SPEAKER_09: Most soil sampling does not go to significant depths like has been done.

53:44

SPEAKER_09: In the Delta, given its unique ecosystem.

53:46

SPEAKER_09: So to put these numbers in perspective, I know we don't often talk about tons of carbon.

53:52

SPEAKER_09: We usually think about emissions.

53:54

SPEAKER_09: The amount of carbon that's held in those peat soils is equivalent to sequestering about 440 million metric tons of carbon dioxide.

54:04

SPEAKER_09: To put that number in perspective, the entire state of California emitted 360 million metric tons of carbon dioxide in the year 2023.

54:19

SPEAKER_09: So this is really intended to highlight that there's a lot of opportunities in the Delta to support and maintain that carbon stock and even build back what's been lost over time.

54:29

SPEAKER_09: And Jen can talk about that in a little while.

54:33

SPEAKER_09: So moving on to the non-Delta area of the study.

54:39

SPEAKER_09: This is mostly Sacramento County plus those transmission corridors and renewable generation facilities.

54:45

SPEAKER_09: The picture starts to look very different.

54:48

SPEAKER_09: Both the biomass and soil carbon are represented proportionally by land cover type.

54:54

SPEAKER_09: The distribution is looking a little bit different.

54:58

SPEAKER_09: Forest biomass is higher than any of the other above ground biomasses.

55:06

SPEAKER_09: You still see a large portion of soil carbon held in croplands.

55:13

SPEAKER_09: And again, note that that's a call out box for the oak wood lens, shrub lens, etc.

55:19

SPEAKER_09: They are relatively small.

55:21

SPEAKER_09: Sections of the land cover represented in the study area.

55:29

Unknown: And then summarizing this as well, the study area that excludes the Delta represents about a tenth of the carbon stock, but it covers about 77% of the study areas acreage.

55:43

SPEAKER_09: This area is storing about 19 million metric tons of carbon, which is equivalent to preventing the release of about 70 million metric tons of carbon.

55:55

SPEAKER_09: And again, these are a lot of big numbers we're throwing at you.

55:59

SPEAKER_09: Trying to put this in context, the 2025 greenhouse gas emissions from SMUD's net generation and power purchases was 2.4 million metric tons of carbon dioxide.

56:10

Unknown: It's about 29 years worth of SMUD emissions that's in the study area without the Delta.

56:21

Unknown: So I know Kathleen walked through a few of the key documents and supporting plans and analyses that have been done by various state agencies.

56:32

SPEAKER_09: The scoping plan from 2022 has been a really foundational piece of this study because it was the first time the California Air Resources Board modeled carbon held in natural and working lands and included it and folded it into the analysis of the scoping plan scenario and the business as usual scenario.

56:50

SPEAKER_09: We prepared a forecast as part of this study to understand how carbon stocks are expected to change over time that's consistent with carbs modeling.

57:00

SPEAKER_09: So the scoping plan just to refresh is the state's climate action plan intended to achieve carbon neutrality by 2045.

57:11

SPEAKER_09: The two main scenarios that we've looked at, the business as usual, which when we're thinking about natural and working lands is essentially today's land management practices continuing through the year 2045.

57:24

Unknown: Today is relative, it's really looking at the trends between 2001 and 2014.

57:30

SPEAKER_09: But taking into account the effects of climate change that we know are going to likely result in significant losses in our carbon stock due to wildfire, due to drought, things like that.

57:42

Unknown: The scoping plan scenario is the selected scenario to get the state to this pathway of carbon neutrality by 2045.

57:50

Unknown: What that looks like for natural and working lands is it does include that climate impact lens to it, but there's a lot more investment going into protecting, enhancing, maintaining a variety of land cover types.

58:10

SPEAKER_09: And specifically the statewide actions that have been modeled are listed on the bottom of this slide.

58:16

SPEAKER_09: So it's a significant investment. These numbers are not specific to SMUD. These are statewide annual targets that the state is intending to achieve.

58:26

SPEAKER_09: They continue to do a lot of work to advance some of these goals through additional studies and plans that they have been coming out with over the past number of years.

58:42

SPEAKER_15: Is there a GHG number associated with the strategies outlined?

58:50

SPEAKER_09: Yes. So it is included kind of all together. The natural and working lands component has been made equivalent in terms of sequestration over time so that you can compare emissions and sequestration on that rate by rate basis.

59:11

SPEAKER_09: Unfortunately, what CARB found in every model, every scenario that they modeled was that the state will lose carbon no matter if we invest billions upon billions of dollars in protecting these lands.

59:26

Unknown: So the goal is actually to not lose more than 4% of the carbon stocks statewide by 2045.

59:34

Unknown: Of course, that's a statewide number. When we start to look at that at the SMUD study area, the picture actually does look a bit different.

59:42

SPEAKER_09: So what our modeling showed was in that business as usual scenario, which is the blue line that you're seeing, there would be losses in carbon that's held in the land covers represented in the study area.

59:58

SPEAKER_09: The losses would be equivalent to about 2.3 million metric tons of carbon between the years 2022 and 2045.

1:00:07

SPEAKER_09: So it's about a 2% loss. But when we look at the scoping plan scenario, which is that statewide carbon neutrality scenario that has a lot of investment,

1:00:19

SPEAKER_09: SMUD's projected study area forecast would actually see an increase in carbon stock of about a half percent over that same time period of 2022 to 2045.

1:00:33

SPEAKER_09: Part of that is due to what land cover types are represented most in the study.

1:00:40

SPEAKER_09: There is not significant amount of forest in Sacramento County in the Delta.

1:00:44

Unknown: Those are the forest types or the mainland cover type that are anticipated to lose significant amounts of carbon, of course, associated with catastrophic wildfires.

1:00:54

SPEAKER_09: So really what this tells the story of is that this future scenario, this yellow scoping plan scenario is possible, but it requires significant amount of investment and action to be taken so that SMUD can play an important role in achieving these statewide objectives.

1:01:12

SPEAKER_09: And I'm going to hand it back to Jen to talk a little bit more about what strategies SMUD could take and where we are in the study.

1:01:19

SPEAKER_09: But I'm happy to come back and answer any other questions.

1:01:23

Unknown: Thanks.

1:01:29

Unknown: Thank you, Hannah.

1:01:31

Unknown: So as you saw in those various maps that you see why we've broken this into three eco regions for analysis, the Sierra Nevada portion of the study area where the Upper American River Project, Hydroelectric Project are located as heavily forest dominated.

1:01:47

SPEAKER_13: You have a lot of biomass carbon.

1:01:49

SPEAKER_13: The Delta has those peat soils that are a significant carbon resource in the soils themselves.

1:01:54

SPEAKER_13: And then we've identified the Central Valley non-Delta as sort of the rest of the study area, which is SMUD service territory, the gas pipeline that goes to the west there, some solar facilities and associated transmission easements and the Solano wind farm area.

1:02:12

SPEAKER_13: And I'm going to glide through these quickly.

1:02:16

SPEAKER_13: You see that the land cover patterns are different between these three regions.

1:02:19

SPEAKER_13: The biomass carbon is different and the soil carbon is distinctly different in the Delta.

1:02:25

SPEAKER_13: And this similar thing here that basically in the Delta we have cropland, wetland, orchinevinions being the predominant land cover types.

1:02:33

SPEAKER_13: Central Valley urban is the predominant land cover type followed by grassland and cropland.

1:02:38

Unknown: And in the Sierra Nevada part of the eco region of the study area, forest is dominant with urban being a lesser category and everything else kind of pretty insignificant.

1:02:51

Unknown: So I want to address biodiversity as well.

1:02:53

SPEAKER_13: It's in the program name.

1:02:55

SPEAKER_13: So it's carbon, nature-based carbon solutions and biodiversity program.

1:02:58

SPEAKER_13: And there's a couple of different ways that we are integrating the consideration of biodiversity.

1:03:03

SPEAKER_13: One is that we want to do no harm with these practices, right?

1:03:06

SPEAKER_13: So the practice selection that we're considering, we're looking for practices that can have strong carbon benefits but also strong habitat benefits.

1:03:14

SPEAKER_13: And we're also, as we're analyzing the ability to look at different practices, we're potentially retaining some practices that may have certain carbon benefits when we know they have positive biodiversity benefits and our kind of win-win land management practices.

1:03:33

Unknown: And then when we're doing site opportunity screening, we'll be looking for the right practice in the right place.

1:03:37

SPEAKER_13: So we areas that have high existing biodiversity value, we don't want to look at implementing land management practices that would threaten that biodiversity value or lower it.

1:03:49

SPEAKER_13: And we want to identify and avoid significant ecological trade-offs with any land management practices for carbon enhancement.

1:03:57

Unknown: I'm not going to spend a lot of time on the slide.

1:03:59

SPEAKER_13: I don't want you to either, but just this is sort of an initial screening table to look at like the land cover types that have sufficient prevalence in each eco region.

1:04:08

SPEAKER_13: These are land cover types that have at least a thousand acres represented in each eco region and some practice types or practice categories that are potentially applicable in those land cover types by eco region.

1:04:20

Unknown: And I'm going to go, in this presentation, I'll go through a few examples of these for each or by eco region, a few examples of some different practices.

1:04:32

Unknown: So as has been described in the Delta, the primary carbon storage in natural working lands is in those peat soils and those formed over 7000 plus years of tidal marsh existence in the Delta.

1:04:47

SPEAKER_13: And the peat has been oxidizing as it's been exposed to air with the Delta being reclaimed for agriculture and farmed in drained roots own crops.

1:04:58

SPEAKER_13: And so the due to microbial decomposition, basically, of that really high carbon soil as it's exposed to oxygen.

1:05:08

SPEAKER_13: And so the primary goal for preserving that carbon stock in the Delta is to re-wet those peat soils, create an anoxic anaerobic condition that that halts that microbial decomposition of that soil carbon and restores essentially wetland habitat types back into that region.

1:05:26

SPEAKER_13: And this is done worldwide and a priority worldwide for carbon, nature-based carbon solutions on natural lands.

1:05:36

SPEAKER_13: So the Delta was included in the study area for this reason, because this is a really promising approach and it is the emissions from peat soils being oxidized in the Delta is a significant portion of the agricultural emissions for the whole state.

1:05:50

SPEAKER_13: And the carbon stocks in the soils are very significant. So there are a lot of practices that can apply. I'm going to describe wetland restoration and rice farming.

1:06:03

Unknown: So non-tidal wetland restoration is probably the most promising practice that we have available in the study area, particularly for carbon preservation and sequestration benefits.

1:06:15

Unknown: And that is because of the high baseline emissions associated with the farming of peat soils and the draining and farming of peat soils.

1:06:22

SPEAKER_13: And so when you re-wet those peat soils, you halt that oxidation, you halt the land subsidence that's associated with that.

1:06:28

Unknown: When you restore marsh or wetlands on those peat soils, you start to rebuild that peat. So you're sequestering new carbon in the soil and biomass of vegetation.

1:06:37

Unknown: And this can have, like all these values that I'm going to show on these slides, these are screening values. They're from the literature.

1:06:43

Unknown: They can be pretty variable based on the site and the practice. But like on average, CARB estimates this is an 8 megaton per acre per year of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions reduction benefit of restoring wetlands.

1:06:58

SPEAKER_13: And this is the best way to do this. So you can actually do this on peat soil.

1:07:03

SPEAKER_13: So actually a pretty low cost, or can be. These costs again are screening costs. It depends on the scale and access and a lot of other aspects.

1:07:14

SPEAKER_13: It also has a lot of strong co-benefits. So it provides habitat that has been largely eliminated from the Delta.

1:07:22

SPEAKER_13: So for wildlife and biodiversity benefits, subsidence reversal benefits, levees stability benefits, protects the state water supply in a number of locations.

1:07:34

SPEAKER_13: So that is one practice that we will be evaluating and describing in the feasibility study and looking at opportunities for some potentially supporting actions that could further this action, which is a major goal for the scoping plan scenario.

1:07:51

SPEAKER_13: Inverting drained root zone crops like corn and weed and other crops that are currently farmed in the Delta to rice farming has a significant peat conservation benefit because the soils are maintained shallowly inundated for most of the year.

1:08:05

SPEAKER_13: It has a lesser carbon benefit because they are not always wet and they are harvested and sometimes tilling occurs.

1:08:12

SPEAKER_13: But depending on how high the baseline emissions are at that particular site, it can still be quite a significant carbon benefit of this average value provided of 2.6.

1:08:23

SPEAKER_13: But that can be higher or lower depending on the baseline emissions of the site, which is determined with like flux tower analyses and everything.

1:08:32

SPEAKER_13: People have been measuring these at sites that have been converted to rice.

1:08:37

SPEAKER_13: So that has co-benefits of wildlife habitat is provided by rice fields as well.

1:08:44

SPEAKER_13: Like water birds and giant garter snake can be supported by rice.

1:08:50

Unknown: OK, and then moving on to the Sierra Nevada, where we've established that forests hold most of the carbon and above ground biomass vegetation.

1:08:58

SPEAKER_13: So the trees basically the strategy is very different, right?

1:09:03

SPEAKER_13: So we're trying to present prevent catastrophic wildfire, which causes a total loss of that carbon and is the reason that the business as usual scenario for the state shows a net loss of carbon and the natural working lands of the state.

1:09:16

SPEAKER_13: We know wildfires are increasingly severe, catastrophic, widespread with climate change and with forest management practices that have led to fuels, high fuels that are not really natural on the landscape.

1:09:31

Unknown: And so the primary the primary strategy in these kinds of lands that we have in the Sierra Nevada region is reducing that risk of severe and catastrophic wildfire that would result in near total loss of those carbon stocks.

1:09:50

Unknown: And so there are a lot of methods that can be used for fuels reduction thinning forest to get to a more natural state combined with or followed by prescribed fire to maintain a natural forest density that is resilient to ongoing wildfires and does not do not experience dam replacing wildfire damages is the sort of gold standard for this.

1:10:17

SPEAKER_13: And that can cost anywhere between 800 and 2500 acre from screening value.

1:10:22

Unknown: The carbon dioxide value, though, is difficult to assess, right? Because the risk is still there. The risk of burning or potentially like climate, extreme climate driven fires or wind driven events, whatever.

1:10:36

SPEAKER_13: You can still have wildfires that are more damaging than expected.

1:10:40

Unknown: And yeah, it's just very complicated.

1:10:44

SPEAKER_13: Also, when you do forest thinning and prescribed fire, there's some short term carbon costs to that, too, right?

1:10:49

SPEAKER_13: So prescribed fire does have some emissions.

1:10:52

SPEAKER_13: Thinning can you can have biomass products that result from that, that it can be used in a productive way.

1:10:58

Unknown: But, you know, it's a complicated thing to try to analyze.

1:11:01

SPEAKER_13: And carbon has done their very best.

1:11:04

SPEAKER_13: They've really tried to figure out how to model this.

1:11:06

SPEAKER_13: And there's a lot of data out there, but coming up with like a specific value for this becomes difficult.

1:11:11

Unknown: However, the benefits are high for this, right?

1:11:14

SPEAKER_13: So it has high biodiversity code benefit because it's protecting forest health and ecosystems and supporting the species that depend on these forests.

1:11:23

Unknown: It protects infrastructure associated with transmission lines, hydroelectric project facilities, human life and property.

1:11:32

SPEAKER_13: So and additionally, reducing forest density can increase base stream flows for hydropower generation because the forests, when they're very thick, have really high evapotranspiration rates.

1:11:44

SPEAKER_13: And the snow oftentimes doesn't reach the ground.

1:11:47

SPEAKER_13: So it sublimates off the canopy and you just have like a it's important that having a thinner, more natural forest structure can increase summer stream flows for hydroelectric power generation.

1:11:59

SPEAKER_13: And so I did look into funding some research on that that UC Merced and the Forest Service have done on that as well.

1:12:07

SPEAKER_13: So it's been documented by many researchers.

1:12:12

Unknown: OK, so in the Central Valley region, the non-delta region of the study area, we have this kind of mosaic of urban areas, grasslands and croplands and on mineral soils.

1:12:28

SPEAKER_13: And so in these areas, we're looking to maintain stable land uses.

1:12:33

SPEAKER_13: So preserve these high value land cover types that support biodiversity and have carbon stock in them that we want to preserve.

1:12:41

SPEAKER_13: And building and retaining soil and biomass carbon is a goal.

1:12:44

SPEAKER_13: And there are a whole variety of like practices that can be implemented, including a whole variety of climate smart agricultural practices, like reducing tillage, organic farming, things like that.

1:12:54

SPEAKER_13: I'm going to talk about a few of them here.

1:12:57

SPEAKER_13: Urban tree plantings. I'm not also talking about here, but that's also something that, as you saw in the scoping plants area, they want to increase investment in urban tree plantings.

1:13:05

SPEAKER_13: And that does have a is an important thing that SMUD can and does support.

1:13:11

Unknown: So in grasslands, one practice that has been evaluated and has some enduring carbon benefits or has been found to have some enduring carbon benefits is applying compost to degraded range lands.

1:13:24

SPEAKER_13: Where the soil carbon is like below its carrying capacity and due to maybe overgrazing or other land degradation that's occurred.

1:13:32

Unknown: So this can increase soil carbon.

1:13:34

SPEAKER_13: It can increase plant growth and productivity for productivity for grazing.

1:13:39

Unknown: It has some potential potential benefits like water, increasing water holding capacity and water infiltration, soil health aspects.

1:13:49

SPEAKER_13: However, it's not really appropriate for high biodiversity grasslands, like where if you have like a native ecosystem with high native biodiversity, compost addition can potentially be counter be counterproductive for biodiversity in that kind of situation because fertilizing soils can favor weeds in particular situations.

1:14:12

SPEAKER_13: So this is really for like a non-native grassland that has degraded soil function.

1:14:17

SPEAKER_13: One time or several time compost application can be beneficial for carbon and for general soil function.

1:14:26

Unknown: Avoiding grassland conversion is another practice that the scoping plan describes avoiding converting it to either like till that, you know, farmed agriculture or developed land.

1:14:38

SPEAKER_13: And so this protects those existing land based carbon stocks on grasslands, which are primarily in the soils.

1:14:46

Unknown: And so the best fit for that is grasslands where you have a credible risk of land conversion, particularly grasslands that provide habitat and biodiversity benefits.

1:14:53

SPEAKER_13: And you have sort of a win-win scenario as well.

1:14:57

SPEAKER_13: Yeah, and then hedgerow planting.

1:15:01

SPEAKER_13: This is that orange veil substation site that Kathleen showed earlier in the deck where this isn't exactly a hedgerow.

1:15:08

SPEAKER_13: It's really like a pollinator garden dominated by shrubs, native shrubs.

1:15:12

Unknown: But this was taking out sort of a low value habitat area with low carbon value kind of degraded soils and planting native shrubs, applying this deep mulching like wood mulch from smud tree shimmings that were harvested, you know, collected.

1:15:30

SPEAKER_13: And so that it would not require irrigation.

1:15:33

SPEAKER_13: And that this benefit here, this is a screening benefit as well.

1:15:36

SPEAKER_13: This is for putting in hedgerows on agricultural lands.

1:15:40

SPEAKER_13: The benefit is like a little bit less clear for converting grasslands, for example, to hedgerow or shrub plantings.

1:15:47

SPEAKER_13: But there's this again, this strong biodiversity benefit.

1:15:50

SPEAKER_13: These are great pollinator plants.

1:15:52

SPEAKER_13: They provide wildlife habitat for birds and other species aesthetic benefits.

1:15:58

SPEAKER_13: So these are things that you would do on a small area.

1:16:02

SPEAKER_13: They're suitable for the perimeters of large scale solar facilities like these little edge areas where you have, you know, land edges that aren't being used for other things.

1:16:14

SPEAKER_13: Pipeline areas that smud manages or easements as much manages where low growing shrubby vegetation is acceptable can be restored into this kind of land cover and habitat type.

1:16:28

SPEAKER_13: And have both carbon benefits and biodiversity benefits.

1:16:33

Unknown: And so just this is pretty much one of my last slides here.

1:16:39

SPEAKER_13: This is a prior project, an example that Kathleen mentioned earlier at Rancho Seco Solar, where we looked at stacking a number of like land improvement and management activities for both carbon and biodiversity benefits within this large scale solar facility.

1:16:56

SPEAKER_13: That included native pollinator, native grassland seeding within the arrays or that was that was a potential plan.

1:17:03

SPEAKER_13: It was done in a smaller area of the facility.

1:17:07

SPEAKER_13: Targeted sheep grazing for fuels management, but also for has potential carbon benefits.

1:17:12

SPEAKER_13: Grazing of grassland is one of those things that's not fully the carbon benefits are like a little bit understudied, but their potential there.

1:17:23

Unknown: And then doing native hedgerows both with soil rehabilitation where the soil was degraded by compaction with equipment or other other for other reasons.

1:17:35

SPEAKER_13: That's well rehabilitation has good carbon benefits because when the soil is compacted or degraded, that soil carbon can't even like really persist because nothing can live in it.

1:17:43

SPEAKER_13: So, so rehabilitation treatments was one aspect and then this hedgerow restoration with or without soil rehabilitation was were treatments that were a plan was put in a place for the site and a plan like this could be put into place for other solar facilities for SMUD like Country Acres or others.

1:18:04

SPEAKER_13: So with that, my last slide, we are we've developed a study area and done the mapping and the inventory and forecast for the natural working lands.

1:18:15

SPEAKER_13: We're identifying these practice opportunities and SMUD site specific opportunities and starting to assess those.

1:18:23

SPEAKER_13: We're going to prepare kind of a framework of how SMUD might approach evaluating different opportunities for future implementation or consideration.

1:18:32

SPEAKER_13: And we'll be reviewing that with SMUD's integrated resource planning team and completing the draft of this feasibility study of this winter.

1:18:40

SPEAKER_13: And then I've included. Oh, there's a reference slide in the in the agenda notes, but that's with that.

1:18:47

SPEAKER_13: I think it's discussion time. Yeah. So thank you.

1:18:51

SPEAKER_00: Wonderful. Well, if it's all right with board members, I'd like to go ahead and have folks speak and then we can have a discussion. Great.

1:19:00

SPEAKER_00: Well, we have three speakers tonight in person and the first one will be Sophia Markowska with Defenders of Wildlife.

1:19:14

SPEAKER_00: Welcome. Thank you and good evening.

1:19:19

SPEAKER_14: My name is Sophia Markowska and I'm a senior California representative for Defenders of Wildlife based here in Sacramento.

1:19:26

SPEAKER_14: Defenders strongly supports SMUD, SMUD's nature based carbon solutions and biodiversity feasibility study.

1:19:32

SPEAKER_14: And we thank SMUD for their work. We especially commend SMUD for building biodiversity into the study from the start.

1:19:38

Unknown: Choosing the right practice in the right place, protecting high value habitat and avoiding ecological tradeoffs is exactly the right framework.

1:19:46

Unknown: The findings show what is at stake. The Delta alone holds 120 million metric tons of carbon.

1:19:52

SPEAKER_14: Restoring wetlands there halts ongoing emissions and creates habitat for native species.

1:19:57

SPEAKER_14: Protecting grasslands from conversion keeps carbon in the ground and keeps habitat connected for species such as Burrowing Owl and Swainson Hawk.

1:20:04

SPEAKER_14: These investments complement SMUD's 2030 zero carbon plan.

1:20:09

SPEAKER_14: As SMUD assesses practices and opportunities, Defenders of SMUD to keep four priorities in mind.

1:20:14

SPEAKER_14: Number one, lead with habitat first practices. Prioritize Delta wetland restoration, riparian and floodplain restoration and avoid conversion of high value grasslands and vernal pools.

1:20:27

Unknown: Two, build on existing conservation frameworks. Coordinate with local habitat conservation plans, land trust and resource agencies.

1:20:34

SPEAKER_14: So SMUD investments strengthen regional conservation.

1:20:38

SPEAKER_14: Number three, make benefits durable, additional and transparent. Use permanent protection such as conservation easements.

1:20:45

SPEAKER_14: Monitor both carbon and biodiversity outcomes and continue to open stakeholder process, including tribal consultation.

1:20:54

Unknown: And number four, apply the same standards to energy procurement. The power SMUD buys is part of the solution too.

1:21:00

Unknown: Clarin Oak wetlands, grasslands and vernal pool habitats for large solar projects releases storage carbon.

1:21:06

SPEAKER_14: Screening power purchase agreements for habitat and carbon impacts and favoring projects on already disturbed lands will ensure SMUD's procurement and its nature based carbon work moves in the same direction.

1:21:17

Unknown: Defenders has valued working with SMUD staff on renewable energy siting and we look forward to working with you as this program takes shape. Thank you.

1:21:25

Unknown: Thank you very much. Next up is Tim Washburn from Third Act. Welcome Tim.

1:21:39

Unknown: Yes, I'm Tim Washburn, Third Act also part of the Coyote Creek Coalition.

1:21:45

SPEAKER_06: I would like to endorse my colleague Sophia's comments to you fully. I think this should be

1:21:52

SPEAKER_06: an important part of SMUD's portfolio here. It's management of emissions. As you know, I used to

1:22:00

SPEAKER_06: work for SAFE guy. I tend to have kind of an orientation toward reservoir operators and so

1:22:06

SPEAKER_06: I wonder to some extent why forest management might not be a bit more of a priority here. It

1:22:11

SPEAKER_06: seemed like you limited your study area to the power line corridors, which perhaps I understand.

1:22:18

SPEAKER_06: I've also been impressed over the years with the work that Placer County Water Agency has done in

1:22:25

SPEAKER_06: their portion of the American River Watershed. They've had a very successful effort in building

1:22:33

SPEAKER_06: partnerships with the National Forest Service, CALFIRE, local conservancies and done a tremendous amount

1:22:41

SPEAKER_06: of good forest thinning and forest management. It seems like SMUD could learn from what PCWA has done

1:22:47

SPEAKER_06: in their part of the American River Watershed. I urge you, I mean we already have a study area,

1:22:53

SPEAKER_06: you're not going to go back and start over, but as time goes by you might consider what SMUD could do

1:23:00

SPEAKER_06: in this area of forest management. I was also site to the Yuba County Water Agency, which has done

1:23:07

SPEAKER_06: a really great job up in the upper part of the Yuba Watershed. They managed the Bullards Bar

1:23:14

SPEAKER_06: Reservoir that controls the middle and north fork of the Yuba River and they have been very

1:23:19

SPEAKER_06: active. These reservoir operators like you link this work to operation and maintenance, managing

1:23:27

SPEAKER_06: sediment, managing the runoff that comes from fires and connect with others who have the broader

1:23:33

SPEAKER_06: interests of climate, of restoration, etc., and undertaking. So they're never alone in implementing

1:23:41

SPEAKER_06: their forest management efforts. They're usually the spark that brings other collaborators to the

1:23:46

SPEAKER_06: table and they're able to add the organizational capability and experience to kind of keep the

1:23:51

SPEAKER_06: ball rolling. So I've hardly supported the program that's presented here with a caveat that it would

1:23:59

SPEAKER_06: be nice to see SMUD look at the watersheds that drain into your reservoirs as part potentially,

1:24:07

SPEAKER_06: at least in the future maybe, of your study area and opportunity for nature-based carbon

1:24:14

SPEAKER_06: management. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Washburn. Sure, I wanted to ask

1:24:20

SPEAKER_05: Tim a question. So, and I was going to ask this about anyway, but I was wondering if you had

1:24:27

SPEAKER_05: any knowledge of studies that have been done about

1:24:32

Unknown: sediment management, the relationship of this to sediment management and preserving reservoir

1:24:39

SPEAKER_05: space. I guess I can't tell you specifically, but I did attend a program recently

1:24:46

SPEAKER_06: and heard a presentation by Yuba County Water Agency and they were very high on the investment

1:24:54

SPEAKER_06: return in forest management in terms of preserving their, not only their reservoir storage space,

1:25:01

SPEAKER_06: but also the maintenance of their operation. So I would encourage your staff at some point

1:25:08

SPEAKER_06: when those two are remarkable. Yuba County Water Agency and Placer County Water Agency are the

1:25:14

SPEAKER_06: leaders in this field of reservoir operators who've embraced the kind of a watershed approach

1:25:22

SPEAKER_06: to their operations. So I was going to ask staff to maybe follow up with contacting those agencies

1:25:30

SPEAKER_05: and looking into the types of benefits that Mr. Washburn has talked about. I would ask the staff

1:25:41

SPEAKER_15: and Kathleen probably to respond. I know that SMUD has spent a lot of money in our watersheds

1:25:47

SPEAKER_15: since I've been on the board. So I think it's more of something to report back because we're

1:25:53

SPEAKER_15: doing a lot of work already. I didn't, the corridors were rather narrow, so I didn't get

1:25:58

SPEAKER_06: the sense of, you know, kind of, but maybe I don't understand it. Oh, go ahead. Yeah.

1:26:05

Unknown: Identify yourself, please. This is Kathleen Ave from SMUD. Thanks, Tim, for your comments. I do

1:26:11

SPEAKER_01: want to say we did extend our corridor by a half a mile on each side, right, to account for the

1:26:18

SPEAKER_01: potential for partnerships. That's not far enough to do what you were talking about, but I think we

1:26:24

SPEAKER_01: can definitely consider that for future work. But also our vegetation management team already

1:26:30

SPEAKER_01: does partnership work with different agencies up in the UARP, and we're looking at how that work

1:26:36

SPEAKER_01: contributes to protection of the carbon stock now, and that could, you know, potentially be expanded

1:26:42

SPEAKER_01: to other areas. I always come back to mention that. You're just so good. Thanks. Yeah, Joelle

1:26:48

SPEAKER_10: Ledesma, zero carbon officer. I think, to your point on watershed management, and we do believe

1:26:54

SPEAKER_10: that's, you know, that's the infrastructure we got to be looking at. And with Kathleen's help and

1:27:00

SPEAKER_10: Josh, we have been looking at it holistically as a watershed, because as you know, it really takes

1:27:06

SPEAKER_10: that whole system to work, you know, together. So we have been looking at that and trying to look at

1:27:12

SPEAKER_10: the long-term plan for climate change, which is a lot of the things you're talking about. Thank you.

1:27:19

Unknown: Thank you. And then next we have Ralph Propper from ECOS. Welcome.

1:27:27

Unknown: Yeah, thank you. Well, by way of background, I'm retired from the Air Resources Board,

1:27:35

SPEAKER_07: where I was in the Climate Science Research section, and I now coach our ECOS's Climate Change

1:27:41

SPEAKER_07: Committee. So I'm very glad that's what is an interest in these, in these issues here. I think

1:27:50

SPEAKER_07: it's very impressive, of course, how much we need to deal with the delta and the fact that there's

1:27:56

SPEAKER_07: so much peat and carbon that's going into the air from over the years with the cropland there,

1:28:03

SPEAKER_07: the land is subsiding, and we need to protect that, not just to reduce the amount of, you know,

1:28:12

SPEAKER_07: I think we should consider a cap and invest to get rice and other crops that will keep it

1:28:20

SPEAKER_07: wet so that it doesn't decompose. But there's the additional factor of the arc storm scenario, which

1:28:26

SPEAKER_07: according to Daniel Swain, a recent article, a chance of maybe every 25 years with the Super

1:28:34

SPEAKER_07: O'Neill perhaps greater, where this gets an atmospheric river situation that we're going to

1:28:40

SPEAKER_07: get this weekend, especially repeated that this could flood this area and send a wave right to

1:28:48

SPEAKER_07: downtown Sacramento and flood downtown Sacramento. It's a real possibility. So that's another reason

1:28:54

SPEAKER_07: we should be concerned about protecting the peat soils in the delta. Otherwise, it's important

1:29:02

SPEAKER_07: for the forest land to make sure that we've controlled burns and a way to deal with the

1:29:07

SPEAKER_07: forest waste that we get. Unfortunately, the Trump administration vetoed the, we were supposed to be

1:29:16

SPEAKER_07: getting a project to show how you can take the wood and convert it into biochar, which is a great way

1:29:24

SPEAKER_07: to store in the soil and help with fertility and methane that can be used as a fuel.

1:29:31

SPEAKER_07: And then of course, in the metropolitan area of Sacramento, ECOS is working very hard to

1:29:40

SPEAKER_07: get more transit oriented affordable housing that is infill development rather than

1:29:47

SPEAKER_07: taking more green fields to that would otherwise be converted into

1:29:55

SPEAKER_07: residences and increased the amount of emissions, but also as we see destroy the soil and the habitat

1:30:05

SPEAKER_07: with the grasslands or whatever crop lands that are as conserving the soil. So those are just

1:30:11

SPEAKER_07: some thoughts. I'm very glad that that's what is taking interest in this. Thank you very much.

1:30:20

SPEAKER_00: Do we have any virtual comments?

1:30:25

Unknown: Okay. Board members, do you have any comments or questions?

1:30:33

SPEAKER_00: Let's start with you, Director Rose, unless President Tumayo is ready.

1:30:39

Unknown: Okay. Yeah, I think I've commented in the past that, you know, I think looking at the opportunities

1:30:49

SPEAKER_05: in the Delta of converting crop land to either wetlands or rice is something I'm really

1:30:56

SPEAKER_05: interested in moving forward. And one of the advantages is that the carbon benefits have been

1:31:04

SPEAKER_05: very well established. And I believe that they're in some sort of carbon registry already.

1:31:13

SPEAKER_05: They already have, they've already subscribed or been brought into that. So it's very local. It's

1:31:24

SPEAKER_05: has many benefits, and it's a lot easier to keep an eye on. And there's a lot fewer.

1:31:32

Unknown: Well, maybe there's not a lot fewer stakeholders, but it seems like it's a simpler model than some

1:31:39

SPEAKER_05: of the others as far as being able to demonstrate the carbon benefits. So the other thing is,

1:31:49

SPEAKER_05: I'm hoping that as we're looking at the project development framework, we also look at other

1:31:55

SPEAKER_05: stakeholders that have an interest. I know Metropolitan Water District was one of the

1:32:00

SPEAKER_05: funders of the studies that did that. And they're looking at that from more of a water supply

1:32:08

SPEAKER_05: protection framework. But it strikes me that there are other stakeholders that can help

1:32:15

SPEAKER_05: share the costs. And I'm actually really interested in seeing if there's something that we can offer

1:32:24

SPEAKER_05: up to our customers or even just the broader community of, hey, we're investing in this.

1:32:31

SPEAKER_05: This is something that you could help move forward on your own as well. And instead of us,

1:32:37

SPEAKER_05: okay, it's just our project. The other actors in the community could add into that and make for

1:32:46

SPEAKER_05: even larger conversions that would provide those benefits. I'm really glad that we're at the stage

1:32:54

SPEAKER_05: now where there's a project development framework that hopefully that will be in time to really

1:33:06

SPEAKER_05: consider as part of our IRP. I know it's mentioned in here. So I'm looking forward to that being

1:33:13

SPEAKER_05: part of what we show going forward. And I guess even if the report or the framework isn't quite

1:33:21

SPEAKER_05: done, it doesn't mean we can't work on it once it is done. So anyway, thank you very much. This is

1:33:29

SPEAKER_05: a very nice body of work and gives us a lot of options to think about. Thank you.

1:33:35

SPEAKER_00: Thank you. Other board members, Director Fishman?

1:33:40

SPEAKER_00: Just real quickly, I did kind of add on to what President Tamayo was talking about. I think we

1:33:46

SPEAKER_11: work with so many nonprofits, some of which are working in this space already. The one that comes

1:33:51

SPEAKER_11: to mind is Splash, which manages vernal pools out in the southeast part of the county. I'm sure

1:33:57

SPEAKER_11: there's other conservancies and things. So, I mean, yes, it's great to do some of this work

1:34:02

SPEAKER_11: ourselves, if possible, and on land that we control directly. But to work with partners that

1:34:07

SPEAKER_11: are already doing the work in other locations might just throw it out there as something to

1:34:11

SPEAKER_11: think about as well. I mean, this almost fits into with our sustainable communities efforts,

1:34:17

SPEAKER_11: which have been focused, I think, kind of on our customers and the urban core. But if we're really

1:34:24

SPEAKER_11: interested in enhancing this work, maybe it's something to throw into that bucket too.

1:34:30

SPEAKER_11: Thank you. Director Rose?

1:34:33

SPEAKER_00: Yeah. I want to, of course, thank Kathleen and Hannah and Jennifer. Thank you for coming out

1:34:39

SPEAKER_15: and spending your evening with us. And I apologize for the delay in getting to your item tonight.

1:34:48

SPEAKER_15: I think one of my key takeaways from this discussion, and this is the third or fourth time

1:34:53

SPEAKER_15: over the last maybe six or seven years, we've talked about nature-based solutions

1:34:58

SPEAKER_15: I think one of the keys is not emitting carbon. And you see, I was just playing with the math,

1:35:05

SPEAKER_15: even if we could under an IRP scenario, get our carbon down to say 100,000 tons of carbon,

1:35:11

SPEAKER_15: you start doing the math, eight tons per acre in the delta, that's probably half a thousand acres.

1:35:20

SPEAKER_15: And that would be like, so you start seeing like there's not that enough light in the

1:35:27

SPEAKER_15: land around everywhere to start really making up for these really high emission rates. And you can

1:35:32

SPEAKER_15: think new part of it, but that's one of my takeaways. I'm curious, as President Twi-O said,

1:35:38

SPEAKER_15: can I continue to think about how this fits into our IRP process? In 2018, we did look at some of

1:35:43

SPEAKER_15: these scenarios where we got down to a 90 different decarbonized scenario. And then we were talking

1:35:49

SPEAKER_15: about trying to do offsets or carbon sequestration, which is part of when this discussion got started

1:35:55

SPEAKER_15: in that, I want to say 2018, 2019 timeframe. So that was only, and then I had just one question,

1:36:04

SPEAKER_15: just to make sure I'm understanding this math, the math, right in terms of the cost per ton.

1:36:08

SPEAKER_15: So we say, if we say for the rice conversion, rice farming conversion, we said it was 2.6 tons

1:36:16

SPEAKER_15: per acre at a cost of about $1,000. So are we basically saying 2.7, 1,000 divided by the 2.6?

1:36:26

SPEAKER_15: So whatever, I can't do that on top of my head, somewhere around like $400 per ton to sequester

1:36:33

SPEAKER_15: through that. Am I? You need to come to that microphone and my memory. And I've been thinking

1:36:42

SPEAKER_15: about this because my memory says we saw some sequestration numbers from one of the Delta

1:36:47

SPEAKER_15: nonprofit groups that came in here years ago. And it was like 10 to $20 a ton for sequestration.

1:36:53

SPEAKER_15: It was very affordable. So what am I screwing up with the math? Yeah. So I didn't put cost per ton

1:36:59

SPEAKER_13: because it does get a little bit complicated, but within the case of rice conversion, that's

1:37:02

SPEAKER_13: usually like a one-time cost to convert like level fields with precision enough grading that they can

1:37:09

SPEAKER_13: be farmed in rice because rice requires incredibly level fields because they're very

1:37:12

SPEAKER_13: shallowly inundated. So there's a one-time sort of, or at least a one-time cost to a rice farmer to

1:37:19

SPEAKER_13: farm rice where it was being farmed in something like corn. Then the rice farmer, presumably is

1:37:26

SPEAKER_13: also making sufficient profit off the rice that the continued maintenance of the sites, etc., is

1:37:32

SPEAKER_13: being covered by the crop production. So that $1,000 an acre is coming from, there are programs

1:37:40

SPEAKER_13: like the Delta Conservancy has been paying and funding some farmers to put crops into rice

1:37:46

SPEAKER_13: production. Metropolitan Water District has also done that on some of their islands with grant

1:37:51

SPEAKER_13: funding. So yeah, it's been around $1,000 to $1,500 an acre, I think, for metropolitan.

1:37:56

Unknown: Then would you have maybe a short piece? And then that carbon sequestration value

1:38:00

SPEAKER_13: starting to erupt is an annual value. So if there's a one-time conversion cost, the annual

1:38:07

SPEAKER_13: value is like a consistent emissions reduction over what had been occurring on that land under

1:38:12

SPEAKER_13: the baseline scenario. I guess one of the questions I need, this stuff was murky because it's been so

1:38:18

SPEAKER_15: long, is what are we talking about in terms of a cost per ton and that marginal abatement cost and

1:38:26

SPEAKER_15: then comparing that to the cost of offsets as well. And then we've spent a lot of time as an

1:38:33

SPEAKER_15: organization board looking at carbon capture sequestration. One of the numbers we saw,

1:38:39

SPEAKER_15: very technical presentation a few months ago, was it was like, I want to say $60 to $80 to physically

1:38:45

SPEAKER_15: sequester the carbon out of the power plant emissions, but that didn't include the cost of

1:38:49

SPEAKER_15: actually piping them and putting them into a sink, which we also had a lively discussion about as

1:38:55

SPEAKER_15: well. There was no real strict dollar figures with those. They were so very perspective. So

1:39:01

SPEAKER_15: this was really thinking about cost effectiveness. And then I guess something to add to that

1:39:06

SPEAKER_13: conversation is that like for rice, I don't think there is a current protocol for like

1:39:11

SPEAKER_13: crediting that. With wetlands, there is a carbon protocol, someone referenced, that has been

1:39:16

SPEAKER_13: developed for the delta and wetland restoration. I think the rice protocol is sort of under development

1:39:21

Unknown: and consideration and it partly has to do with like additivity, like because there is sort of this

1:39:27

SPEAKER_13: move towards farming more rice in the delta because the delta in some ways is getting too

1:39:31

SPEAKER_13: wet to farm and things like corn. Anyway, however, the rice is really being promoted by

1:39:39

SPEAKER_13: entities that are trying to reduce these emissions and for that purpose as the primary purpose.

1:39:45

Unknown: Thank you.

1:39:46

Unknown: Thank you. Great. Well, any other final comments? If not, I do want to thank all of the presenters.

1:39:58

SPEAKER_00: It's funny, I know since I've been on the board, we've had several presentations

1:40:06

SPEAKER_00: about this idea and I joked the last time that it usually takes three presentations

1:40:15

SPEAKER_00: to get a actual project going. So I'm just really excited about this project. I think that it really

1:40:26

SPEAKER_00: fits into our vision. I agree with President Tamayo that there's a lot of interest from our

1:40:36

SPEAKER_00: customers about the care of the delta and you know, maybe we could find a way to engage our

1:40:47

SPEAKER_00: existing customers who are interested in helping preserve the delta. I also appreciate the

1:40:56

SPEAKER_00: testimony from our visitors today. I think Mr. Washburn's suggestion to talk to those

1:41:07

SPEAKER_00: two other water districts that are kind of very much involved in this kind of work is a good thing.

1:41:16

SPEAKER_00: I'm guessing you all have probably already done it, but I think this is groundbreaking for SMUD

1:41:25

SPEAKER_00: and you know, SMUD really prides itself on paying attention to how we impact the environment

1:41:35

SPEAKER_00: and also what our customers care about. So I'm excited for this. I can't wait to hear

1:41:43

SPEAKER_00: what the results are and to kind of forge a path where SMUD can be a partner with other entities

1:41:51

SPEAKER_00: to contribute to preserving the delta. So with that, let me ask if we have any comments

1:42:03

SPEAKER_00: on the agenda or actually any comments for items not on the agenda. We do not. Okay.

1:42:15

Unknown: Oh, my apologies. I missed one. John, the floor is yours.

1:42:20

SPEAKER_04: Can you hear me? Yes. Yes, this is John Weber and I just had a comment. So good evening,

1:42:34

SPEAKER_08: Chair, Board and committee members. When the budget is posted tomorrow morning, the draft budget,

1:42:42

SPEAKER_08: please add an email address so we can put our inquiries there. It sounds like the current date

1:42:50

SPEAKER_08: for opportunity for budget detailed inquiries is the 13th. That really doesn't give a lot of time

1:42:58

SPEAKER_08: for people to read a probably 100 page document and have inquiries. So please extend that until

1:43:06

SPEAKER_08: at least the 20th, the following Friday from the 13th, that gives people about a little over a week

1:43:15

SPEAKER_08: to look at it and have inquiries. And if you post the email address there, we'll know where to send

1:43:21

SPEAKER_08: the inquiries. Thank you very much. Yeah, we do have the budget presentation coming up on the 17th

1:43:35

SPEAKER_00: of November. So thank you, John, for your comments. And I know you are very conscientious

1:43:45

SPEAKER_00: and we will be getting comments from you and I look forward to them. Any other?

1:43:55

SPEAKER_00: All right. Then I just want everybody to know that written comments received on items not on

1:44:02

SPEAKER_00: the agenda will be included in the record if they're received within two hours of the end of

1:44:08

SPEAKER_00: the meeting. The last item on the agenda is to provide a summary of committee direction.

1:44:15

SPEAKER_04: One was to contact Yuba and Placer County Water Agency to find out more about their

1:44:21

SPEAKER_04: watershed management activities and the possible effect on sedimentation and other reservoir

1:44:25

SPEAKER_04: operation impacts. And the other was to have staff reach out to other entities to partner

1:44:30

SPEAKER_04: in carbon sequestration biodiversity projects. Wonderful. Okay. Well, seeing no other further

1:44:37

SPEAKER_00: business, this meeting is adjourned.