Unknown: DOWNLOAD
Unknown: LEARNES
Unknown: Video
Unknown: Now
Unknown: yeah
Unknown: the
Unknown: the
Unknown: you
Unknown: I'm
Unknown: a
Unknown: the
Unknown: triple Otherwise you feel excited
Unknown: And my stomach hurts
Unknown: I've never patched a
Unknown: I was supposed to be there.
Unknown: Now, we can pick next time andwomen today.
Unknown: I'm so sorry.
Unknown: Okay, everybody ready?
Unknown: Five second.
SPEAKER_19: Five seconds.
SPEAKER_53: Five seconds.
Unknown: Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the Policy Committee and Special Board Meeting of November 11,
SPEAKER_19: 2026.
SPEAKER_19: I just want to take a second to let you know that both Rob Kurth and Nancy Bui-Thompson are online.
SPEAKER_19: They're representing us at a conference, but they are listening to all of the testimony,
SPEAKER_19: and we'll get an opportunity to speak if they want to.
SPEAKER_19: I also want to acknowledge that it's Veterans Day,
SPEAKER_19: and many of us have family members who were in one of the services,
SPEAKER_19: and all of us benefit from the sacrifice of veterans,
SPEAKER_19: giving us a world that we can speak our truth,
SPEAKER_19: we can come to a public meeting, we can share what our concerns are,
Unknown: and we have that freedom because of all those men and women who keep us safe and keep our country safe.
SPEAKER_19: So I just want to take a second for us to think about anybody in our family
SPEAKER_19: or anybody we know who's a veteran, just so that we can say thank you.
Unknown: Okay, well, let me tell you some other things.
SPEAKER_19: This room is equipped with a safety alarm.
SPEAKER_19: If the alarm sounds, please leave in an orderly manner via the exits to the lobby or behind the dais,
SPEAKER_19: assemble in front of the building and wait to hear the all clear announcement from security before reentering.
Unknown: This meeting is being recorded and can be accessed on SMUD's website.
SPEAKER_19: Please remember to unmute your microphone when speaking in order that our virtual attendees may hear.
SPEAKER_19: The microphone will display a green indicator light when the mic is on.
SPEAKER_19: You do not need to touch it. It will pick up your voice.
SPEAKER_19: For members of the public attending in person and who wish to speak at this meeting,
Unknown: please fill out a speaker's request form located on the table outside this room and hand it to the security officer.
SPEAKER_19: Members of the public attending this meeting virtually who wish to provide verbal comments during the committee meeting may do so by using the raise hand feature in Zoom
Unknown: or pressing star nine when dialed into the telephone toll-free number at the time public comment is called.
SPEAKER_19: Technical support staff will enable the audio for you when your name is announced during the public comment period.
Unknown: You may also submit written comments by emailing them to publiccommentatsmud.org.
SPEAKER_19: Written comments will not be read into the record, but they will be provided to the board electronically and placed into the record of the meeting.
SPEAKER_19: If the comments are received within two hours after the meeting.
Unknown: Deputy General Counsel, please conduct the roll call.
SPEAKER_41: Director Rose.
SPEAKER_41: Here.
SPEAKER_19: Director Kurth.
Unknown: Here.
Unknown: Chair Herber.
SPEAKER_41: Here.
SPEAKER_41: All committee members are present as well as Directors Bui Thompson, Fishman, Tamayo, and Sam Borne.
Unknown: Okay.
Unknown: Just want to let you know that item number one on tonight's agenda is to discuss adoption of SMUD's large load customer service principles.
SPEAKER_19: Just to be clear, we will be discussing policy tonight.
SPEAKER_19: We won't be voting on whether to approve a data center in South Sacramento or anywhere else.
SPEAKER_19: We will be listening to you and coming up with conditions that we would want our staff to put into any kind of a large load policy.
SPEAKER_19: So that is our purpose tonight.
SPEAKER_19: And so with that, I'd like to call forward the presentation.
Unknown: Oh, wait.
SPEAKER_19: There's more that I get to read to you.
Unknown: Okay.
Unknown: Okay.
SPEAKER_19: Okay.
SPEAKER_19: I just want to again make sure that we're talking about large load policy.
SPEAKER_19: And the purpose of the public comment time is to have you tell us what you think is important to put in that policy.
SPEAKER_19: But I do want you to know that SMUD nor this board has the legal authority to approve or disapprove data centers or any other development projects.
Unknown: That authority lies with cities and counties.
SPEAKER_19: We will not be discussing approval of any development projects tonight.
SPEAKER_19: Secondly, SMUD does not have the legal authority to refuse to provide power to customers based on the nature of their business.
SPEAKER_19: We cannot say, no, we're not going to give you power because we are the utility that has the monopoly that serves Sacramento County.
SPEAKER_19: However, what we can do is put conditions on them receiving services.
SPEAKER_19: And lastly, we will not be considering electric service to any particular customer tonight.
SPEAKER_19: We do not have any large load projects right now that are requesting electric service.
SPEAKER_19: At this point, we don't know if we will be considering any approval in the coming months or beyond.
SPEAKER_19: But we will be discussing tonight the adoption of principles to govern how we would treat applications for service from customers seeking more than 50 megawatts of power.
SPEAKER_19: And we will be looking to determine what conditions we can and should impose on such service to continue to ensure that neither SMUD or other customers bear any increased costs,
SPEAKER_19: no increased costs or risk from providing service to a large electric load customer.
Unknown: And now we will hear from Tracy Carlson, the director of customer success.
SPEAKER_19: Chair Herber.
SPEAKER_09: Yes. Just clarify it.
SPEAKER_09: What you said, something along the lines of we don't have any applications.
SPEAKER_09: Can we clarify what we mean?
SPEAKER_09: Because I, like everybody else, have read the media articles that indicate we have applications, but I think there's some delineation in what we mean by that.
Unknown: I think that's a really good point, Director Rose.
SPEAKER_19: And can we have you say something, Mr. Attorney, who wrote that?
SPEAKER_41: No, we don't have any approved large load projects.
SPEAKER_41: We just do have a couple applications.
SPEAKER_41: We do have applications.
SPEAKER_19: Okay.
Unknown: Thank you for that clarification.
SPEAKER_19: Okay.
SPEAKER_19: And now we will hear from Tracy Carlson.
Unknown: Good evening.
SPEAKER_42: Thank you so much, board and the community for joining us tonight.
SPEAKER_42: Again, my name is Tracy Carlson.
SPEAKER_42: I'm the director of customer success.
SPEAKER_42: And I'm here to share with you, of course, we're we hear in the news on a regular basis.
SPEAKER_42: Every day we hear something about large load data centers.
SPEAKER_42: And the team got together at SMUD and decided we were going to review all of the roles and responsibilities, the strategic directives, build a team to understand what are the processes necessary to approve and move forward with a large load customer.
SPEAKER_42: That team worked together to build principles and a draft resolution for you all to consider tonight.
SPEAKER_42: So we understand how important this is within our community, as well as the news media and all of the headlines that we've all seen every day.
Unknown: While we are seeing inquiries around large load customers, we're not seeing the level of large load customer inquiries that other areas across the nation are seeing.
SPEAKER_42: Unlike Texas or Virginia areas, we have a handful of inquiries, as you mentioned, and we're not seeing the size.
SPEAKER_42: We're not seeing the gigawatt, the large facilities that other areas across the country are seeing as well.
SPEAKER_42: So just wanted to share that while we are seeing headlines in the news, and we're certainly hearing about it regularly, we have a team together at SMUD that's reviewing our policies, put together some principles we're asking you to consider tonight,
Unknown: and really making the best possible decisions that we can on behalf of you all and the organization, community at large.
SPEAKER_42: So just wanted to start there.
SPEAKER_42: We'll review the large load definition, what it means to be large, external and internal processes.
SPEAKER_42: As you mentioned, where the authority lies, policies that protect customers, and then large load principles that, again, our team of subject matter experts has reviewed and put together for your consideration.
SPEAKER_42: We're hoping that you'll review those this evening and then approve in the coming committee or the coming board meeting.
Unknown: So what is a large load at SMUD?
Unknown: We do have the obligation to serve based on the Public Utility Coves 451, as you mentioned, but with policies that protect our customers.
SPEAKER_42: And we're defining large as above 50 megawatts.
SPEAKER_42: The reason why we've defined it as above 50 megawatts is because a load of that size and greater would need to be served at our transmission level.
SPEAKER_42: It's not something that's served at the distribution system.
Unknown: Anything that's being served by our transmission system would need to be approved by the board through a customer tailored agreement and contracts.
SPEAKER_42: So again, we're just wanting to make sure everyone's aware of what the definition of large is.
SPEAKER_42: Now, the word large and the word megawatt and mega may be a little bit confusing to some.
SPEAKER_42: We wanted to be sure to level set.
SPEAKER_42: 50 megawatts is 1.5% of SMUD's peak load during the summer season of around 3,300 megawatts.
SPEAKER_42: So while we're using the term large to differentiate, and we are using the term mega, I am not an engineer or a physicist, but it is approximately 1.5% of our loads.
SPEAKER_42: Just giving you a little perspective there.
Unknown: Next slide.
SPEAKER_42: Internal and external processes.
SPEAKER_42: So project approvals and land use authority.
Unknown: Director Herber, you mentioned that while SMUD has the obligation to serve power to our community, we do not have the authority to determine the land use or the type of business that enters our community.
SPEAKER_42: The local jurisdiction has that role.
SPEAKER_42: The city, the county, the air district.
Unknown: They engage with key stakeholders.
SPEAKER_42: A potential candidate would submit an entitlement application to a local jurisdiction.
Unknown: There would, of course, be robust environmental reviews.
Unknown: There will be public review processes for each and every land use permit submitted.
SPEAKER_42: Then they obtain the local jurisdiction approval.
SPEAKER_42: SMUD, as you've mentioned, has a few inquiries that are at that internal study level.
SPEAKER_42: Internal study can happen early, and we encourage customers to engage with us very, very early.
SPEAKER_42: And that study can take anywhere between three months to 18 months, depending on the complexity of the project.
SPEAKER_42: This is the pre-application stage.
SPEAKER_42: This is where any potential customer is communicating with us to understand the reliability, the feasibility, and its extensive study that they go through.
SPEAKER_42: That's the only step that SMUD will take prior to local jurisdiction approval.
SPEAKER_42: When a local jurisdiction approves a project, that's when SMUD would move to the next steps.
SPEAKER_42: We would look to draft agreements and contracts that met the needs of the client and the organization and the community.
SPEAKER_42: We would bring things to the board for approval, review, and public comment.
Unknown: We would collect funds from the potential customer, and then we would build the infrastructure.
SPEAKER_42: So while there are studies that are taking place, there has been no submittal for application, and there has been no approval from the local jurisdictions.
SPEAKER_42: We would like to be sure that everyone's aware of the process and the steps that SMUD takes.
SPEAKER_09: Can you say a word about that internal study process and if it's public or private?
SPEAKER_42: It's not a public process.
SPEAKER_42: It is something, again, that in most, for lack of a better phrase, it's a hypothetical scenario, right?
SPEAKER_42: It's a scenario that a potential developer, builder would look to get our feedback on to determine if the project is even feasible.
SPEAKER_42: So we wouldn't want it to be part of a public review process because all of the information is relatively hypothetical.
SPEAKER_42: They're looking for our feedback to then submit their official application into the local jurisdiction to make that approval.
Unknown: Okay, great.
Unknown: So just to be clear, though, we have not received an application from any large load.
SPEAKER_19: We've talked with them about what the possibilities may be, but we have not actually received an application from them.
SPEAKER_42: I'll look to Joe to clarify the terminology, but what I am confident in communicating is that we have two potential customers that are in the initial study process.
SPEAKER_42: They have paid a fee associated with completing that study.
SPEAKER_42: So the time that SMUD invests in that study and the resources that we use to complete that study is all paid for on behalf of that potential client.
SPEAKER_42: We bear no cost.
SPEAKER_42: Again, even the cost to consider the idea is paid for by the potential customer.
SPEAKER_42: Thanks, but just I think a lot of people are confused.
SPEAKER_46: So there are data centers already in Sacramento that we serve.
SPEAKER_46: It's not like we've never seen an application and approved.
Unknown: Again, we just give power if they've had a permit and there's – we can.
Unknown: And now we're doing a large power load policy so we can put parameters around this.
Unknown: And that's what we're looking for feedback on tonight because we want to be able to do that, whether it's a data center or any big customer.
SPEAKER_46: But we've got, what, 18 data centers already in Sacramento County and there's different types.
SPEAKER_46: And I think part of the confusion is there's the different types.
SPEAKER_46: And there's been no real effort to me from – my frustration has been with the developers of these projects,
Unknown: they're not out educating the public about the different types, what they consume.
SPEAKER_46: There's hyperscalers.
SPEAKER_46: There's much smaller facilities that most people didn't even know were – I didn't know were here.
SPEAKER_46: So recently.
SPEAKER_46: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: And let's – I know you're going to talk about some of those things.
SPEAKER_19: You're absolutely correct.
SPEAKER_42: And I apologize.
SPEAKER_42: That was one of my speaking points on my very first slide.
SPEAKER_42: So thank you for reminding me.
SPEAKER_42: We do have upwards of 18 data centers within SMUD's territory today.
SPEAKER_42: We've had them for more than two decades.
SPEAKER_42: And I want to be sure I'm very clear on the questions that I'm asking.
SPEAKER_42: When I explained internal studies, it was a large load customer, right?
SPEAKER_42: Someone that's requesting something greater than 50 megawatts.
SPEAKER_42: As far as data center applications, yes, we serve data centers today.
SPEAKER_42: So I'm here being very clear to speak about large load, meaning above 50 megawatts.
SPEAKER_42: But as far as overall use in our territory, you're absolutely right.
Unknown: Okay.
SPEAKER_42: Tracy, one more question before you go on.
SPEAKER_23: Yes, please.
SPEAKER_42: To look at the timelines here, the internal study that we're doing is basically happening
SPEAKER_23: concurrently with – conceivably with the applicant or with the company that's proposing this,
SPEAKER_23: going to the land use authority and saying, I'd like to get entitlements and starting that process.
SPEAKER_23: So these things are happening at roughly the same time?
SPEAKER_23: It could.
SPEAKER_42: Okay.
SPEAKER_42: It could happen roughly at the same time.
SPEAKER_42: And then at some point when we're finished with the internal study, it will also – I mean,
SPEAKER_23: it will include information about how much it's going to cost and how long it's going to take
SPEAKER_23: for us to build the infrastructure needed to serve that new large load,
Unknown: given that the proposer is going to pay those costs.
SPEAKER_23: So at some point, they're going to look at those numbers too and decide if it's worth continuing their application or not.
Unknown: Overall, yes, you are correct.
SPEAKER_42: Okay.
SPEAKER_42: I would say the detailed dollars may not be completely covered in the internal study,
SPEAKER_42: but you are not incorrect.
SPEAKER_42: They're looking for information in order to determine the feasibility of their project.
SPEAKER_42: It may not be down to the last one-on-one, but we're going to give them some kind of figure
SPEAKER_23: that says it's going to cost approximately X amount of dollars.
SPEAKER_23: Yeah, order of magnitude.
SPEAKER_42: You're absolutely right.
SPEAKER_42: I just wanted to be sure the board determines a few components here,
SPEAKER_42: so we're not stepping in front of that with the study process.
SPEAKER_42: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Please continue.
Unknown: You're welcome.
Unknown: Okay.
SPEAKER_19: One more thing.
SPEAKER_19: Okay.
SPEAKER_19: The only thing I want to say though is that she does have a presentation,
SPEAKER_19: and if you think the information might be coming later –
SPEAKER_19: It's not on the user side.
SPEAKER_09: I've read through it thoroughly.
SPEAKER_09: Okay.
SPEAKER_09: We have up here on the left local jurisdiction approval process.
SPEAKER_09: Can you just give everybody an example of what those entities are in the region that we're talking about?
Unknown: Sure, yeah.
SPEAKER_42: A local jurisdiction is a city within our community,
SPEAKER_42: a county within our community, and potentially a local air district.
SPEAKER_42: So it's really an organization that has governing authority over the area in which the client is looking
Unknown: for their business to be located.
Unknown: That's like the county of Sacramento on the board of supervisors
SPEAKER_09: or the city of Sacramento on their board of directors
SPEAKER_09: or Folsom or Citrus Heights or Rancho or Galt, right?
SPEAKER_09: Correct.
SPEAKER_42: Okay.
SPEAKER_08: Yes.
Unknown: Thank you.
Unknown: Okay.
Unknown: So in the work that I mentioned, the SMUD expert team getting together to review,
SPEAKER_42: what are the policies that we have today?
SPEAKER_42: And our board has done really a wonderful job over many decades of developing what we all call strategic directives.
SPEAKER_42: And those are policies that guide our business every day.
SPEAKER_42: The three strategic directives that are most relevant here are strategic directive two, competitive rates.
SPEAKER_42: And it's more than just maintaining a competitive rate as a core value,
SPEAKER_42: but also that fair and consistent and not to burden any other rate class.
SPEAKER_42: That's really a broad commitment there.
SPEAKER_42: And then strategic directive four, reliability.
SPEAKER_42: SMUD will ensure that all customer energy requirements are met
SPEAKER_42: and maintain the electric system in good repair.
SPEAKER_42: And we have firm commitments about reliability and affordability
SPEAKER_42: that are illustrated in those strategic directives.
SPEAKER_42: We also have strategic directive seven, environmental leadership.
SPEAKER_42: This speaks to sustainability, conduct its business affairs and operations in a sustainable way.
SPEAKER_42: It also speaks to the guiding principles around power procurement
SPEAKER_42: and how we procure that power.
SPEAKER_42: So again, SMUD will procure the power and then offer it to clients.
SPEAKER_42: And I know there's been some concern around how will this impact sustainability and clean energy goals.
SPEAKER_42: And again, SMUD determines our power mix and then we sell that power to the community.
SPEAKER_42: Next slide.
SPEAKER_42: So digging in a little bit deeper here, getting into rules and regulations,
SPEAKER_42: we talk about strategic directives quite a bit, but we don't always talk about rules and regulations.
SPEAKER_42: But they exist and they're there and they're policies that guide our business.
SPEAKER_42: Rule two speaks to service conditions.
SPEAKER_42: And it's important to know that transmission service is not described as a standard service under rule two,
SPEAKER_42: only distribution services.
SPEAKER_42: So again, as we define large load above 50 megawatts,
SPEAKER_42: because it needs to be served through the transmission system,
Unknown: special facilities will be installed under the terms and conditions of a contract.
Unknown: Meaning each project that needs transmission level power would have a unique contract associated with it.
SPEAKER_42: It's not something that our standard rules will cover.
SPEAKER_42: We have to look at the unique challenges.
SPEAKER_42: We have to look at the unique costs to your point, Director Fishman, and address those.
SPEAKER_42: Rule two tells us that.
Unknown: Rule four is around contracts where customers' power requirements are unusually large
SPEAKER_42: and an economic hardship may be imposed upon SMUD.
Unknown: A contract may be required for a period that in SMUD's judgment is commensurate with the size of the power requirements.
Unknown: This is, again, we have to have a unique contract in place because this is clearly unusually large
SPEAKER_42: and potential economic hardship for customers.
SPEAKER_42: We have policies in place that guide us here where a unique contract would be needed.
Unknown: And then we have resolution 97-04-13.
SPEAKER_42: Customer tailored rates.
SPEAKER_42: Customer tailored rates will be subject to agreement with the district on mutually beneficial terms and conditions
SPEAKER_42: and subject to board approval.
SPEAKER_42: Again, this will be a contract specifically to this project.
SPEAKER_42: Any project that comes our way greater than 50 megawatts.
SPEAKER_42: And we would then bring those to the board for approval around the electric service agreements.
Unknown: So what don't we have?
SPEAKER_42: Those are the policies that we have in place that we know that protect our customers.
SPEAKER_42: But we are looking for the board to consider.
SPEAKER_42: You did receive the resolution.
SPEAKER_42: It's also posted on our website as part of this committee meeting.
SPEAKER_42: These are the headlines, if you will, for us to share with you all around the six principles
SPEAKER_42: that we're proposing the board to adopt as part of the resolution that would govern our ability
SPEAKER_42: and the process we would go through to negotiate these contracts that we're talking about.
Unknown: So if a customer requests, if a local jurisdiction approves a project that is greater than 50 megawatts,
SPEAKER_42: it's considered large load, we will be guided by our strategic directives and rules and regulations.
SPEAKER_42: We would also be guided by these principles to develop contracts unique to that client.
SPEAKER_42: The first one is large load customers pay their own way.
SPEAKER_42: Of course, this aligns to strategic directive two, but this does it more plainly, more clearly.
SPEAKER_42: They will pay their own way.
SPEAKER_42: Existing customers are held harmless.
SPEAKER_42: Again, further bolsters, further reinforces what we do today, but it very clearly says.
Unknown: Require protective commercial terms.
SPEAKER_42: Again, we recognize that each of these projects, as large as they may be,
SPEAKER_42: are things that could put potential concerns at play, and we want to acknowledge that.
SPEAKER_42: We require protective commercial terms.
Unknown: Protect clean energy and resource planning goals.
SPEAKER_42: While we, of course, are governed by strategic directive seven, we have clean energy goals
SPEAKER_42: from the state and other agencies.
SPEAKER_42: We have our own commitments.
SPEAKER_42: We are specifically calling out here clean energy and resource planning goals.
Unknown: Seek community benefit.
SPEAKER_42: As a community owned not-for-profit utility, that is the reason why we exist, right?
SPEAKER_42: We are the community asset to bring vitality to the community.
SPEAKER_42: We want to, again, clearly state that in these projects as well.
Unknown: Evaluate partnerships and emerging technologies.
SPEAKER_42: There may be opportunities for us to learn, for us to improve, for us to create even better tools
SPEAKER_42: and resources for our community.
SPEAKER_42: We want to commit to that.
Unknown: These are the large load principles that our team has put together, and I think they really speak plainly
SPEAKER_42: to our objectives and our commitments to communities.
SPEAKER_42: Love to hear your thoughts.
Unknown: Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_19: I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_19: What we're going to do now is take public comment, because there is quite a bit of public comment,
SPEAKER_19: and then board members will get to ask questions and give their opinions on what they've heard tonight.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_19: Chair Herber, I have a request.
SPEAKER_07: We're going to be considering some specific language that I think is actually...
SPEAKER_07: You guys don't need me.
SPEAKER_07: It's based...
SPEAKER_07: It encompasses the principles that were sort of summarized in that last slide, but I actually think it's important
SPEAKER_07: that before we receive comments that we go through specifically the exact language that's being proposed,
SPEAKER_07: because I think that, you know, it's nice to talk about the concepts that are in there,
SPEAKER_07: but I think that the actual language really sort of lands it on.
SPEAKER_07: I wanted to see if we can get that and just have it displayed, and then also just read through
SPEAKER_07: so that people know exactly what we're being asked to do.
SPEAKER_07: And also, you know, there may be...
SPEAKER_07: We may want to consider some tweaks.
SPEAKER_07: I don't see any particular problems, but I think it would be really helpful before we receive public comment
SPEAKER_07: on our principles that people actually see them.
SPEAKER_19: Okay, and that's fine. We can do that.
SPEAKER_19: I did have one comment on a specific word in one of the principles,
SPEAKER_23: and this was based on something that somebody either sent to me in an email or I saw online somewhere,
SPEAKER_23: and I forget which one it was, but existing customers will be held harmless,
SPEAKER_23: and somebody was worried that that means that future customers may bear some of that burden,
SPEAKER_23: and that's clearly not our intent, but maybe a different word than existing,
SPEAKER_23: maybe all customers or something along those lines.
SPEAKER_23: I just want to throw that out there and let you guys figure out, yeah, I mean, whatever word we come up with,
SPEAKER_23: but existing customers leaves out future customers.
SPEAKER_23: Okay, before I call the first speaker, I do want to once again acknowledge that Director Rob Kerth
SPEAKER_19: and Director Nancy Bowie-Thompson are virtual, but they are listening to your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Director Bowie-Thompson does have to receive an award for SMUDs,
SPEAKER_19: so she won't be probably here until the end of the meeting since we have quite a few comments,
SPEAKER_19: but she will be listening to the tape.
SPEAKER_19: So I want you to know that you have SMUDs attention.
SPEAKER_19: We are here to listen to you, and let me start by calling, I'm going to call three names,
SPEAKER_19: and if you could line up, that would help us go a little more quickly.
SPEAKER_19: Sure.
SPEAKER_63: Director, I thought that we were going to do the language before this meeting.
SPEAKER_63: Oh, I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry. I'm juggling lots of things.
SPEAKER_19: Okay, for all of it, I'd like to actually do the business at hand first, since I have to leave early.
SPEAKER_19: Very good, very good. Okay. Can we do that?
Unknown: I'm working on getting it to display right now, but it is within the information packet if you want to pull that up as well.
SPEAKER_19: All right, so is that all right with you, Director Tamayo, if we take some comments,
SPEAKER_19: or do you want to wait until we get it?
SPEAKER_07: How long do we think it will take?
SPEAKER_40: A few minutes, yeah.
SPEAKER_07: I'd prefer to wait, because we don't want to make sure that folks that are commenting
SPEAKER_07: are commenting at least have the opportunity to see exactly what's been recommended to us.
Unknown: Right, it was posted, but yes.
Unknown: Well, how about this?
SPEAKER_07: Well, it's okay.
SPEAKER_07: Why don't we accept comments if people don't care to see the actual language that we're considering
SPEAKER_07: and want to express their comments, and go ahead and make your comments now.
SPEAKER_07: It's not that long, and we can take a minute.
SPEAKER_19: I definitely think it's worth it.
SPEAKER_09: It's worth it.
SPEAKER_09: Do we know how many commenters have?
SPEAKER_19: Yes, we have. It looks like 35.
SPEAKER_19: At least 35.
SPEAKER_09: I think it's worth waiting the minute, so it's very clear.
SPEAKER_09: All right, so we are going to wait just a minute so that we can get the specific language
SPEAKER_19: that staff has put together that we would like for you to take a look at and comment.
SPEAKER_19: So I'm sure we will have it.
SPEAKER_19: There it goes.
SPEAKER_19: Okay, and who's the lucky person who gets to read it?
Unknown: Well, Joe, I would think it would be you, or maybe the general manager.
Unknown: Good evening.
SPEAKER_40: The first one is large load customers pay their own way.
SPEAKER_40: Large load customers shall bear the costs and risks attributable to their service,
SPEAKER_40: including direct, indirect, and system-related costs.
SPEAKER_19: And then the net, please go through all the points.
SPEAKER_19: Yes, okay.
SPEAKER_40: Second, existing customers are held harmless.
Unknown: Service to large load customers shall be structured so that existing customers do not bear adverse
SPEAKER_40: financial operational reliability impacts, including stranded or under-recovered costs.
Unknown: Principle three, SMUD will require protective commercial terms.
SPEAKER_40: Before SMUD incurs material costs or obligations to serve a large load customer,
SPEAKER_40: SMUD shall require adequate financial security, contractual commitments, rates, charges,
SPEAKER_40: and service conditions necessary to protect SMUD and its existing customers.
Unknown: Four, SMUD will protect clean energy and resource planning goals.
SPEAKER_40: Service to large load customers shall be planned and structured in a manner that supports
SPEAKER_40: SMUD's ability to meet its clean energy goals, resource planning objectives,
SPEAKER_40: reliability needs, and other applicable policy commitments.
SPEAKER_40: SMUD may require large load customers to support or bear costs associated with these resources
SPEAKER_40: needed to serve such load consistent with those objectives.
SPEAKER_40: Five, SMUD will seek community benefits.
SPEAKER_40: Were feasible and consistent were applicable by law.
Unknown: SMUD shall seek to negotiate community benefits in connection with service to large load customers,
SPEAKER_40: provided that such arrangements do not shift customer-specific costs or risks to existing SMUD customers.
Unknown: Six, SMUD will evaluate partnerships and emerging technologies where beneficial.
SPEAKER_40: Were feasible and consistent with applicable law, SMUD shall evaluate partnerships,
SPEAKER_40: operational strategies, and emerging technologies associated with large load services
SPEAKER_40: to identify opportunities for grid benefits, operational flexibility, and reductions to SMUD's costs.
Unknown: Okay, thank you very much.
SPEAKER_19: Now we are going to move ahead with public comment.
SPEAKER_19: And the comment, you will have two minutes to make comments.
SPEAKER_19: Please do not repeat the comments of other speakers if you can,
SPEAKER_19: but please feel free to reference agreement with those comments that other people have said
SPEAKER_19: and to add further new points.
SPEAKER_19: So when you come to the microphone, you don't need to move it.
SPEAKER_19: Just please state your name for the record and know that the microphone is going to pick up your voice
SPEAKER_19: no matter where you're standing.
SPEAKER_19: So you do not need to move it or to touch it.
SPEAKER_19: So I'm going to call out the first three speakers and we'll go from there.
SPEAKER_19: I think it's Amunella Owens from the Party for Socialism and Liberation,
SPEAKER_19: Jacqueline Dunkel, and Kat Van Housen.
Unknown: And we'll start first with Amunella Owens.
Unknown: Hi, it's Amanda.
SPEAKER_69: Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't read it right.
Unknown: Hi, so my name is Amanda. I am a resident of South Sacramento,
SPEAKER_69: as well as I work in South Sacramento as a mental health social worker.
SPEAKER_69: So the well-being and mental health of my family and those in South Sacramento are very important to me.
SPEAKER_69: I'm also going to address the elephant in the room.
Unknown: I am the woman who brought her five-month-old child because I thought that this was so important
SPEAKER_69: and I didn't want to be away from him to voice my opinion.
SPEAKER_69: I don't want my son growing up near a data center.
Unknown: What we do know about data centers is that it is not beneficial to the environment,
SPEAKER_69: that it causes noise pollution and can contaminate the water and take excessive amounts of water.
SPEAKER_69: I understand that you guys are saying that you don't have the authority to not say yes or no,
SPEAKER_69: but I think it should be like you're supposed to be representing the people.
SPEAKER_69: And I think going to the city and telling the city, hey, these people do not want a data center in their area.
Unknown: I also think the data center is with Blackstone, which that's giving modern-day robber baron.
SPEAKER_69: Also, they're the only ones who are going to benefit from this data center.
SPEAKER_69: The billionaires, not the working-class families. We're going to be the ones struggling.
SPEAKER_69: I know that it said that we won't bear the load, but can you promise us that?
SPEAKER_69: And also, why can't we see the study?
SPEAKER_69: If it's hypothetical, then what's the point of it? Let us see the study.
SPEAKER_69: To be quite frank, it's maddening that this is even being considered.
SPEAKER_69: We already know that data centers cause air pollution.
SPEAKER_69: It's the purpose of SMUD to enhance the quality of life of its residents by providing affordable electricity.
SPEAKER_69: And I just feel like how in the heck does this benefit anybody in Sacramento? Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you, Amanda, and my apologies for mispronouncing your name. Jacqueline Dunkel?
Unknown: Hi. Thank you, particularly the young lady in the beautiful dress, for telling us the parameters within which you can work.
Unknown: Within which you work and can impact this process.
SPEAKER_50: And as I was being educated, it came to mind that for my part, the citizens that are serviced by SMUD are the bedrock of what needs to be protected.
Unknown: And the kinds of people who run the data centers are corporations and rich people who seep into every place they go for advantage.
SPEAKER_50: They externalize the cost of their production.
Unknown: You as the caretakers of our public utility are going to have to be extraordinarily precise and careful to protect yourself from the robber barons that our friend just referenced.
SPEAKER_50: And I believe that the line there is to make sure, because I know you guys are all on the public grid, you can take, you can bring energy from any place you want.
SPEAKER_50: I think that they should always, by contract, have to pay the largest price.
SPEAKER_50: The highest price that is ever brought into this area needs to go to the giant data center, because they are not working for us.
SPEAKER_50: They're not going to work for us. They want to make a super brain so they can go to Mars. So let them finance it.
Unknown: And other than that, I also think that the local customers, because they often have medical devices, the large guy needs to shut down first.
SPEAKER_50: If there's a problem in the grid and the customers or the large guy have some place somebody's got to give, big guy every time.
Unknown: And thank you for your time.
Unknown: Thank you, Jacqueline.
SPEAKER_19: Next up is Kat Van Housen from Third Act.
Unknown: Hi, everybody. I'm Kat Van Housen. I just retired recently as a school principal.
Unknown: I believe in children and I believe in the future. And I believe in dreaming big for all of us.
Unknown: I also no shade to anybody, but I do have the best board member because I live in pocket.
SPEAKER_39: Thank you, Miss Herber. No offense to anyone else.
SPEAKER_39: And I know that I bet she has read this book by an author named Robinson called The Ministry of the Future.
SPEAKER_39: And what it sets is the dream for all of us. We are in Sacramento.
Unknown: We are the capital city of the fourth largest economy in the world.
SPEAKER_39: We are naturally going to be looked to for leadership in climate and energy policy.
Unknown: Let's just all have a really big open mind about all of this and realize, number one condition,
SPEAKER_39: they are going to need to pay not only for all of these costs, but for the cost of reusing the site once they fail.
Unknown: There was another one that was a really good, she just brought up a fee that was a really good one too to add.
SPEAKER_39: I will tell you the word moratorium, and I know it's not on you guys.
SPEAKER_39: It was the city of Oakland that did it. It's the city of Sac. We need to do it.
SPEAKER_39: But the word moratorium would be a great word from the leaders in the world on climate and energy policy while we study this more.
SPEAKER_39: Thank you. Thank you, Kat.
SPEAKER_19: Next up is Ruth Holton-Hodson, Anna Fosio, and I think it's Bladel, Samba, and my apologies for the pronunciation.
SPEAKER_19: Ruth is first.
SPEAKER_47: Hi, good evening. Ruth Holton-Hodson with Third Act.
SPEAKER_47: And looking at your principles, SMUD has been a leader in clean energy, not just in California but throughout the country.
SPEAKER_47: And yet you have stated recently that you're going back on your 2030 goals.
Unknown: So when I look at your principles, it says SMUD will protect clean energy and support your clean energy goals.
SPEAKER_47: Well, you need to be clear. What's the baseline going to be? Is it 100 percent clean energy, which of course would be terrific, or is it 5 percent clean energy?
SPEAKER_47: And when the data centers need a backup, they're going to turn to fossil fuel.
SPEAKER_47: So is there a requirement that there can be no backup that uses fossil fuels?
SPEAKER_47: Yes.
Unknown: It's really, really critical to be specific about what you mean by clean energy.
SPEAKER_47: And in fact, you could become a leader, a leader in data center and development if SMUD required that it was 100 percent clean energy,
Unknown: and then all the other cities and counties around the state and utilities, 100 percent clean energy.
Unknown: It would be a very different debate. So I would urge you, when you're focusing on the clean energy goal, to continue to be a leader and not backup just because, well, data centers are going to provide all this money for SMUD.
SPEAKER_47: Thank you.
SPEAKER_47: Yes.
SPEAKER_47: Thank you.
Unknown: Next is Ana Fassio.
Unknown: Hi. I'm Ana Fassio, SMUD customer for 40 years.
SPEAKER_18: Today, my focus is public health impacts of hyperscale data centers.
SPEAKER_18: Regarding the air pollution, data centers relying on fossil fuels for power and diesel backup generators emit localized air pollution, such as fine particulate matter and carbon dioxide.
SPEAKER_18: Exposure to air pollution increases rates of respiratory diseases, cardiovascular conditions, and premature death in impacted communities.
SPEAKER_18: Here we go.
SPEAKER_18: The second area is noise pollution.
SPEAKER_18: Low frequency hum may affect local well-being and adds to data centers' environmental footprint.
SPEAKER_18: Extended exposure to low frequency noises can negatively affect human health, well-being, and health.
SPEAKER_18: Water insecurity is also an issue inadequate or inequitable access to clean, safe, and affordable water impacts drinking, cooking, sanitation, and hygiene.
SPEAKER_18: These challenges may be compounded in areas with pre-existing water scarcity.
SPEAKER_18: Please demand the builder of the water and the health of the water.
SPEAKER_18: Environmental reports should include the cost of public health impact of hyperscale data centers.
SPEAKER_18: And I have 19 more seconds.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_18: Next is Ana Fassio.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you, Ana.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you, Ana.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you for your time.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you, Ana.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you, Ana.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you, Ana.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you for your time.
SPEAKER_18: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Next we have Dr. Goli Samba.
Unknown: Hi, thank you.
SPEAKER_48: Goli Samba, thank you.
SPEAKER_48: I know it's a hard name to pronounce.
SPEAKER_48: Thank you for the previous speaker talking about the health issues.
SPEAKER_48: I'm not going to address that as a family doctor.
SPEAKER_48: That's one of the big concerns.
SPEAKER_48: But I want to address the issue specifically about the AI bubble and why your policy that you've written is concerning.
SPEAKER_48: We have to ask them, if we're even going to let them do it, to pay up front all costs.
SPEAKER_48: Why?
SPEAKER_48: And let me read this to you.
SPEAKER_48: This is from Food and Water Watch.
SPEAKER_48: It's so a little bit complicated, so I just want to read it to you to see.
SPEAKER_48: This is how they describe it.
SPEAKER_48: Big tech.
Unknown: Oh, and the other thing I want to mention is that you have to realize that this is a way of the dying fossil fuel industry and nuclear industry,
SPEAKER_48: colluding with big tech, to bring back their energy.
SPEAKER_48: I know we're doing, you know, and you guys have promised our 2030 carbon zero date,
SPEAKER_48: but a 300-megawatt one that you guys are talking about and further ones, who knows?
SPEAKER_48: Anyhow, it's unlikely that we're going to end up if we allow them.
SPEAKER_48: So let me read you this so you can see what they have researched.
SPEAKER_48: The big tech is turning to the same financial instruments used in the lead-up to the dot-com bust and the 2008 financial crash.
SPEAKER_48: This includes circular financing.
SPEAKER_48: Microsoft invested over $13 billion in open AI from 2019 to 2023,
SPEAKER_48: and open AI sent much of this back to Microsoft to buy cloud computing power for its AI models.
SPEAKER_48: Stay with me, okay?
SPEAKER_48: This is a little complicated, but they want to confuse us.
SPEAKER_48: Other examples abound.
Unknown: More eyebrow-raising deals include one where open AI with an annual recurring revenue of around $13 billion in 2025
SPEAKER_48: committed $60 billion per year to Oracle in exchange for use of its cloud computing facilities.
Unknown: Oracle with a...
Unknown: Okay. Anyhow, it's really difficult because what's happening is the money is just not there,
SPEAKER_48: and so when the bubble bursts, we want to make sure that if you make any deals, you have them pay up front.
SPEAKER_48: Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_48: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: The next three speakers will be Casey Shuit, Mateo Gabrielli, and Isaac Quason.
SPEAKER_19: I'm sorry, I can't read the writing.
SPEAKER_19: I do want to ask our speakers to give us feedback on these principles that staff has laid out.
SPEAKER_19: Do you agree with them?
SPEAKER_19: Do you disagree with them?
SPEAKER_19: If you have any comments on that, that would be appreciated.
Unknown: Go ahead.
Unknown: Good evening.
SPEAKER_44: My name is Casey Shufte.
SPEAKER_44: I think you already know what the people want.
Unknown: You've gotten our calls, emails.
SPEAKER_44: You heard from us last month's meeting, and you're hearing us from us again tonight.
SPEAKER_44: The people could not be clearer.
SPEAKER_44: Out of state developers such as Blackstone and Link Logistics are not your constituents or your community.
SPEAKER_44: Tech billionaires spending millions of dollars to push the narrative that this technology is inevitable are not your constituents or your community.
SPEAKER_44: We do not want more data centers, unregulated AI or surveillance technology.
SPEAKER_44: We don't want our data being stolen and used against us.
SPEAKER_44: We don't want our resources exhausted, our environments polluted, our water and utility bills raised.
SPEAKER_44: It's really quite simple.
SPEAKER_44: Make a decision that doesn't harm the community.
SPEAKER_44: Support a moratorium or pause for at least a year.
SPEAKER_44: The people have been activated by this issue.
SPEAKER_44: Moratoriums were on the ballots this past election all over the country and past.
SPEAKER_44: Multiple towns, cities, unincorporated areas across California have already put moratoriums in place.
SPEAKER_44: Fresnel has completely banned them for 10 years.
SPEAKER_44: As of last month, there were 26 resolutions across California, moratoriums or bans on data center development that have been passed or proposed all across our state.
SPEAKER_44: Even where no data center has been proposed.
SPEAKER_44: There are also indications of an AI bubble.
SPEAKER_44: Your apparent new slogan, trust us, isn't going to work here.
SPEAKER_44: You aren't going to slip anything under CEQA.
SPEAKER_44: We the public want transparency where there is none.
SPEAKER_44: And let's see.
Unknown: We've received text messages as part of our PRA.
SPEAKER_44: Nancy Bowie condescendingly spoke to us last meeting saying, I live next to two and they're great.
SPEAKER_44: I could live next to more.
SPEAKER_44: Well, go ahead.
SPEAKER_44: We don't want them.
Unknown: And apparently in text messages, Nancy Bowie Thompson also appears to really pressure the SMUD CEO to get these projects to move forward.
SPEAKER_44: Why is that?
SPEAKER_44: Do you have financial vested interest in these?
SPEAKER_44: Yes, she does.
SPEAKER_44: We know that at least two board members here have serious financial interest.
SPEAKER_44: We are making our voices heard tonight and we will continue to show up over and over again.
Unknown: Remember who your constituents are.
SPEAKER_44: Put your community first.
SPEAKER_44: If the election last week was anything to go by, you saw people rise up and make political history across the country.
SPEAKER_44: We're done with elected officials nationally and locally who do not represent the community they live.
SPEAKER_44: We're watching and we're not going anywhere.
SPEAKER_44: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Next up is Mateo Gabrielli.
Unknown: Hello.
Unknown: Okay.
Unknown: Hello, everyone.
SPEAKER_03: My name is Mateo Gabrielli.
SPEAKER_03: I'm a lifelong Sacramento resident.
SPEAKER_03: I'm also with the party for socialism and liberation as well.
SPEAKER_03: So considering what is happening today with SMUD placing the health and livelihoods of thousands of people living in the Sacramento area at risk with these upcoming so-called large electrical load data centers,
SPEAKER_03: it actually came as a surprise to me when I recently learned that SMUD was originally created through public vote,
Unknown: quote, so that local residents could put the region's power and water resources under public control rather than letting a private corporation dictate their energy future and rates.
SPEAKER_03: Except that's exactly what it sounds like is happening right now.
Unknown: When you look at SMUD's page on the growth in demand for these projects,
SPEAKER_03: it states that some of the growth in demand comes from so-called large customers.
SPEAKER_03: That being manufacturing and data centers.
SPEAKER_03: But what that means is that this is not actually a response to public demand,
SPEAKER_03: and Sacramento residents who work for a living are not asking for this and evidently never had a say in this to begin with.
Unknown: Instead, SMUD is clearly catering to the demands of corporate power like Link Logistics,
SPEAKER_03: which has the money to bribe officials and go completely over the head and behind the backs of the actual consumers and animals also,
SPEAKER_03: who will inevitably end up bearing the costs.
SPEAKER_03: And they had to do it secretly because they knew that the public wouldn't support it as we see here tonight.
SPEAKER_03: We have seen the disastrous environmental effects of these types of data centers nationwide.
SPEAKER_03: I don't need to really tell you about that.
SPEAKER_03: And considering how large these are going to be, especially the 300 megawatts one, I mean, Jesus Christ,
SPEAKER_03: we will see similar effects.
SPEAKER_03: SMUD claims that this won't be the case for existing customers like us,
SPEAKER_03: but I'd say you guys need to give us a reason why we shouldn't believe or why we should believe that.
SPEAKER_03: But there's really no reason to believe it in the first place that it would somehow be different here.
SPEAKER_03: So we know this. They know this.
SPEAKER_03: That's why it needs to be dressed up in much nicer sounding language.
SPEAKER_03: So instead, I think that SMUD and all the public officials who signed off on this had really better reconsider these clearly unpopular anti-human projects as soon as possible.
SPEAKER_03: Or the public is going to have to remind them who they actually work for.
SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
SPEAKER_03: And the next speaker, I think I really messed up your name.
SPEAKER_19: Is it Isaac or is it Isaac?
SPEAKER_19: My name is Isaac Casada.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: All right.
Unknown: Principle four is all about resource management and environmental consideration.
SPEAKER_67: And an AI data center goes directly against this principle because of the amount of water it uses while putting more money in billionaire pockets while hurting working people here at home.
Unknown: Now, I grew up in a town in San Joaquin Valley, a valley and in the valley.
SPEAKER_67: Water is an important issue.
SPEAKER_67: A lot of our economy relies on it and a lot of our livelihoods rely on it as well.
Unknown: Water is one of those things that we need to survive.
SPEAKER_67: An AI data center compromises that.
Unknown: The reality of the matter is that when recently we've been blessed with wet winters, but it wasn't too long ago where we were suffering through one of the worst droughts the state's seen in centuries.
Unknown: When you build an AI data center, when an AI data center is approved in this valley, we compromise ourselves.
SPEAKER_67: Because when we start to run out of fresh water, then they start resulting to groundwater.
SPEAKER_67: That water has been there for billions and billions of years and the indigenous people in this community protected it for thousands and thousands of years.
SPEAKER_67: We compromise all that by approving projects like this.
SPEAKER_67: It's not, it's one of those things that should be clear to us where we should not be considering opening one of these centers.
SPEAKER_67: The groundwater has been sitting here for a long time, but to use it and to get rid of it permanently scars our environment.
SPEAKER_67: You think Sacramento summers are hot? Try a summer in Stockton.
SPEAKER_67: Try a summer in Fresno where they use the, like the vast majority of their groundwater.
SPEAKER_67: This is not a feasible plan.
SPEAKER_67: It's not sustainable.
SPEAKER_67: Ultimately, it doesn't benefit anybody in the working class because it barely provides any employment realistically.
SPEAKER_67: And so we, the people of Sacramento expect better.
Unknown: We, the people of the valley are looking to you to lead and go against these initiatives to open these centers because it is compromising our livelihoods and it's a compromising our way of life.
SPEAKER_67: Thank you.
Unknown: Next up we have John Weber, Pat Ferris and I think it's Leslie Wilson.
SPEAKER_19: I'm sorry if I am not pronouncing your names right.
SPEAKER_19: And again, if, if you could focus your comments on the resolution and what you like or what you don't like about it, it would be helpful for us.
Unknown: John Weber, we ask MUD to require all LLDC's large load data centers to pay up front for all new distribution, transmission and generation needed to serve the load of the project.
Unknown: This is the only way current customers can be protected.
SPEAKER_29: I quote from a utility dive article titled 12 actions to, 12 actions to tackle energy affordability.
Unknown: We literally the people who pay electric bills cannot afford to get this wrong.
Unknown: The major customers who demand this much power have to pay the full share of all the costs that are incurred to the system when they connect and take this much electricity.
Unknown: SMUD's new LLDC tariff needs to address the worst case and protect customers.
SPEAKER_29: The worst case is that all the distribution, transmission and generation are built and the LLC's go bankrupt.
SPEAKER_29: Two types of corporations profit from LLDC's.
SPEAKER_29: The first type is involved with the construction and the equipment of the data centers.
SPEAKER_29: Here are a few examples.
Unknown: AMD, Arista Networks, ASML Holdings, Bloom Energy, ESS Technology, IBM, Nvidia, Qualcomm and Super Microcomputer.
SPEAKER_29: The second is involved with renting or consuming the compute.
SPEAKER_29: Here are a few examples.
SPEAKER_29: Amazon, Apple, Google, Coinbase, Facebook, Robinhood, Tesla, Block, CrowdStrike and Microsoft.
SPEAKER_29: According to the most current publicly available information included in the form 700, at least two board members have substantial holdings in the companies I just listed.
SPEAKER_29: I will assume those two board members will, at the very least, abstain from voting on this issue.
SPEAKER_29: If one of them were me, I would leave the room now while this item is being discussed.
SPEAKER_29: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Next up we have Pat Ferris.
Unknown: Good evening.
SPEAKER_56: This is Pat Ferris.
SPEAKER_56: I've been a resident of Sacramento County for 23 years.
SPEAKER_56: I've been retired for nine years, so-called.
SPEAKER_56: I'm fully engaged now as a volunteer.
SPEAKER_56: I was an executive and leadership coach, organization and coach in private practice for 40 years.
SPEAKER_56: I had the great honor of coaching some of the high-performing, up-and-coming leaders in this particular organization.
SPEAKER_56: A number of them now are in key leadership roles in this company, in this organization.
SPEAKER_56: I'm proud of that.
SPEAKER_56: I was proud of these individuals.
SPEAKER_56: I continue to be.
SPEAKER_56: I was especially proud when this organization declared 2030 carbon zero goals.
SPEAKER_56: I was also proud when someone I know well became the chief carbon zero officer.
Unknown: I was very proud when Paul Lau was really a spearhead for that initiative.
SPEAKER_56: This organization was a leader throughout the nation.
Unknown: Unfortunately, in the Trump administration, the grants that you look forward to, the tariffs that have been imposed without very astute considerations,
SPEAKER_56: have really imperiled your trajectory.
Unknown: The principles you have are really great.
Unknown: They put the customer first.
SPEAKER_56: They consider benefit to the customer, but they're very short-sighted.
SPEAKER_56: They don't look at the long-term consequences of your actions, which is climate impacts.
SPEAKER_56: I'm very concerned that you're putting the climate impacts on the community and not putting them where they need to be on the applicants that are going to drive those climate consequences.
SPEAKER_56: If you don't put that into your principles, you're short-sighted and you're not taking care of the customer nor the community.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Next, Mr. Wilson.
SPEAKER_10: It's Luke Wilson.
SPEAKER_10: I've got a shaky hand, so I'm sorry about my filling out the form.
Unknown: I'm a member of Third Act Sacramento, and I'm also a part of the Sacramento Area Coalition for Data Center Moratoria.
Unknown: Of course, we're working with the cities and the county here for this moratorium.
SPEAKER_10: I'd like to make a couple of points here about your plans.
Unknown: One thing I think you should be doing is meeting with the city and the county and working out some details of how you're going to work together on these proposed data centers.
SPEAKER_10: That's one thing.
SPEAKER_10: And another, we need a generalized tariff for all large loads, no customer-tailored fees.
SPEAKER_10: That means upfront payment for everything.
SPEAKER_10: You've got to protect the ratepayers.
Unknown: Another thing.
Unknown: Clean power is harder to provide at night, right?
Unknown: Is that true?
SPEAKER_10: I think it must be.
SPEAKER_19: In the summer between 5 and 8, yes.
SPEAKER_10: And it's going to be harder to provide as the climate changes and we get less snow in the winter.
SPEAKER_10: You guys got to take those into consideration.
Unknown: Make them put in batteries.
SPEAKER_10: Okay?
Unknown: And one more thing.
Unknown: We're looking to limit, we're calling large loads over 20 megawatts.
SPEAKER_10: So, you know, I don't know if you can do that.
SPEAKER_10: You know more about that stuff than I do.
SPEAKER_10: And I'd like to leave you with one thing.
Unknown: This is what democracy looks like.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Next up is Catherine Keeney, Colin Lena Rodriguez, and Fatima Garcia.
Unknown: And again, my apologies if I butchered your name.
Unknown: Hi, I'm Catherine Keeney with Third Act Sacramento.
SPEAKER_11: I'm speaking on behalf of my two grandchildren who are in bed and can't be here this late.
SPEAKER_11: And on behalf of your grandchildren, babies or grown.
Unknown: I'm very disappointed in SMUD's actions on this.
Unknown: I am feel cheated that you have backed off your 2030 renewable energy promise.
SPEAKER_11: I've been counting on that.
Unknown: I was here only six months ago when you said that you would be meeting that goal.
SPEAKER_11: And suddenly about a month ago, I heard that, oh, we're not going to be meeting the 2030 goal for renewable energy.
Unknown: These data centers are going to kill that completely.
SPEAKER_11: I feel shame that you have taken this underhanded approach to dealing with this whole large load issue, calling it large load.
SPEAKER_11: We all know what that means.
SPEAKER_11: Something new is going in that's big.
SPEAKER_11: And what is it?
SPEAKER_11: We would know that in town.
SPEAKER_11: What is it is big that's going in right now?
Unknown: It's data centers.
SPEAKER_11: So use real language.
SPEAKER_11: It's false that you don't have.
SPEAKER_11: It's patently false that you don't have applications in process.
SPEAKER_11: Your own staff said that you have two that are being paid for.
SPEAKER_11: It's just deceptive.
Unknown: On this and other issues, SMUD has said they don't have any influence.
SPEAKER_11: And I've heard this the last time I was here.
SPEAKER_11: And you know what?
SPEAKER_11: You do.
SPEAKER_11: You're a large organization that had influence.
SPEAKER_11: They vocally support moratorium.
SPEAKER_11: You don't have to go against your principles or your policies to support a moratorium.
SPEAKER_11: Yes.
SPEAKER_21: Yes.
Unknown: In Fresno, there's a 10-year ban.
SPEAKER_11: I, you know, there's already a water shortage.
SPEAKER_11: I'm repeating stuff because it bears repeating.
SPEAKER_11: It bears repeating until it happens because it's important.
SPEAKER_11: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you, Catherine.
Unknown: Next up is Catalina Rodriguez.
Unknown: Hi, my name's Catalina.
SPEAKER_51: I'm here on behalf of my family and all the beautiful people that I see every day when I work in the community in Sacramento.
Unknown: Thank you for the information about the principles that you guys have put together.
Unknown: But as far as we can tell, as far as that I can tell, they stand in direct opposition for the creation of,
SPEAKER_51: and let alone partnership of data centers.
Unknown: If we want to benefit our community, if we want to make sure that no customers are harmed,
SPEAKER_51: like data centers do not go hand in hand with that, as we've heard all night.
Unknown: Excuse me, sorry.
Unknown: Under the current administration and those in charge of AI,
SPEAKER_51: they've proven day after day that what they're doing, that they're not doing anything to keep us safe.
SPEAKER_51: And because of this current reality, it is with absolute certainty that we cannot give power to another data center,
SPEAKER_51: let alone a mega data center.
Unknown: And we don't want large data centers here.
Unknown: And I'm asking along with my community members for you guys to say no, not for principles,
SPEAKER_51: but for you guys to say no and to use your voices to protect us and to stand for moratorium.
SPEAKER_51: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you.
Unknown: Next up we have Nate and Eraman and Katie McKemmon.
Unknown: Hey, I'm Nate with the Party for Socialism and Liberation.
Unknown: To offset the significant costs that you can't force on to link logistics,
SPEAKER_20: you would use federal grant money, which is working class tax money.
SPEAKER_20: If you charge them, then they get tax breaks from the city, as they always do,
SPEAKER_20: which means our taxes go up and further gutting of municipal budget and quality of public services.
SPEAKER_20: Even if Blackstone pays for its own substation, the added power demand means that you will end up buying large volumes of green energy to compensate
Unknown: or cheaper non-green energy, which will drive up our rates.
SPEAKER_20: They will control a massive share of utility and real estate capacity and gain immense power over local governance.
SPEAKER_20: If you try to play hardball with them, they'll hold your revenue and budget hostage, and you and the city council will capitulate.
SPEAKER_20: They'll have even more leverage to lobby city council for expansion.
SPEAKER_20: The work of local orgs will be benefactors, some local orgs will be benefactors to generate philanthropic political influence for link logistics.
SPEAKER_20: As such, we demand that you declare that this would put you even further off track on affordability, grid lot reliability, and your zero carbon plan.
SPEAKER_20: This admission would give the city council evidence of the need to deny zoning permits for the data center and a pushpoint for public pressure on city council.
SPEAKER_20: Admit that serving them violates your duty to serve us.
SPEAKER_20: Like any other tool or technology, AI and data centers' potential depends on who controls it, the costs, and who benefits.
SPEAKER_20: There is untapped potential in our already existing systems.
SPEAKER_20: And also, someone mentioned that 50 megawatts is only 1.6% of the peak load.
SPEAKER_20: It actually makes it sound pretty miniscule.
SPEAKER_20: It's actually, if it was 50 megawatts, which is going to be more, if it was 50, that would be like 37% of Roseville's daily load.
SPEAKER_20: But since it could be 300, it would be more than Roseville's daily load just for daily data center operation of this one.
SPEAKER_20: So that's what it is.
SPEAKER_20: Thank you. Thank you, Nate.
Unknown: Next, Erman.
Unknown: You called Fatima before that?
SPEAKER_54: Oh, I'm so sorry.
SPEAKER_19: It's okay.
Unknown: All right.
SPEAKER_54: Good evening. My name is Fatima Garcia, executive director with Sembrano Semillas Day Labor Worker Center here in Sacramento.
Unknown: I'm here today to voice my concerns about positioning the Sacramento region as a hub for massive AI data center development at the expense of our environment, our communities,
SPEAKER_54: particularly marginalized black and brown communities where we know these data are being built and our public resources.
SPEAKER_54: We must ask who truly benefits from this development and who bears the cost.
SPEAKER_54: These projects can place enormous demands on our electricity, supply, water resources, land, and infrastructure.
SPEAKER_54: Our communities should not be expected to absorb increased environmental catastrophes, potential impacts on air quality, water consumption, and pressure our energy systems to support the profits of some of the world's largest corporations.
SPEAKER_54: SMUD's own record shows that it prompts Sacramento as a premier destination for AI data centers and applied for up to $122.7 million in federal and matching funds to support the link logistics sites.
SPEAKER_54: But let us remember something fundamental.
SPEAKER_54: SMUD is a publicly owned entity.
Unknown: It belongs to the people and the communities it serves, not to private equity firms or large technology corporations.
SPEAKER_54: SMUD responsibility should be to protect children and families and ensure reliable and affordable electricity, safeguard our environment, and serve the long-term interest of our communities.
SPEAKER_54: We should not sacrifice community health, environmental sustainability, or our future to turn Sacramento into an AI data center hub.
SPEAKER_54: SMUD, local elected officials and decision makers should put people and environment before corporate expansion, demand full transparency, and carefully evaluate the impact before moving forward.
SPEAKER_54: Public resources must be served for public good, not private corporation profit.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you.
Unknown: Next is Ehrman and then Katie.
Unknown: Good evening. My name is Ehrman Barabona. I'm the executive director of the Sacramento Environmental Justice Coalition.
Unknown: I'm very disappointed in all of you and your staff.
SPEAKER_00: You have a moral responsibility to step up against even the city and the county.
SPEAKER_00: We know that you hang out with them, that you talk to them, you can influence them and say, you know what, we don't want this in Sacramento County.
SPEAKER_00: We know the harm that they're causing, the data centers or any kind of super technology.
SPEAKER_00: We know the harm that it's causing in other states where they're being banned.
SPEAKER_00: Cities across the state of California are banning these.
SPEAKER_00: Why can't Sacramento lead the way instead of opening the doors to evil?
Unknown: We know in the history of this country, whenever we have a really cool technology, it gets sold to the community as entertainment and then it gets weaponized later.
SPEAKER_00: My people, immigrants are being hunted with high level technology and these data centers, I'm sure, are not going to help liberate my immigrant families.
SPEAKER_00: We have federal government agents hunting our people, kidnapping them from their houses and they're using technology to do this.
SPEAKER_00: I'm not sure that the floc system can operate without data centers. I'm not sure. I'm not a technician.
SPEAKER_00: But what I can see here is that you have a responsibility to think through this and make a moral stance.
SPEAKER_00: I don't know how many of you are here to negotiate or mitigate, but when evil comes knocking at your door, it is a lot harder to let it out of your house once you welcome them in.
SPEAKER_00: So you do not stand for the people, then we will not stand with you. This is a public institution.
SPEAKER_00: I'm going to leave you with this quote, my last 10 seconds here, from my favorite thinker, Hannah Arendt.
SPEAKER_00: The sad truth is that most evil is done by people who never make up their minds to be good or evil.
Unknown: Thank you, Erman. Next up is Katie.
Unknown: Hi, thanks for taking public comment tonight. I'm Katie McCammon, executive director with 350 Sacramento, a local climate justice organization.
SPEAKER_37: According to recent news, our community is being pitched by SMUD as a quote, premier destination for data centers.
SPEAKER_37: The community has been clear and unified in their message of no.
Unknown: AI is extremely under-regulated and has massive potential to be socially and environmentally destructive.
SPEAKER_37: We deserve time to develop proper regulation to protect our region and environment.
SPEAKER_37: Right now, the push by some local reps to bring mega data centers in quickly is beyond disrespectful.
SPEAKER_37: Now is the era of accountability and listening to the needs of the public.
SPEAKER_37: We seek a focus on zero emissions, grid stability, and decreased energy costs.
SPEAKER_37: Those who choose to publicly support, those who choose to halt data centers, we see you and want you to be louder.
SPEAKER_37: Data centers have no home here, and SMUD is a publicly owned utility, as has been pointed out.
SPEAKER_37: I believe the public is seeking the representation we all vote and pay for.
Unknown: Climate change provides no free resources for corporations. We know water, land and air is more polluted than ever,
SPEAKER_37: and we refuse to willingly hand our communities over to the desires of investors.
SPEAKER_37: What do you believe future generations will appreciate more?
Unknown: Investment in a fleeting and possibly violent idea or protection for everything we have and love?
SPEAKER_37: Stop pretending to be neutral, support the community, and stop data center buyout.
SPEAKER_37: Thank you to all the young people who showed up here tonight.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Next up we have Safi and Megan Shumway and David Wright.
SPEAKER_19: I just want to say again that we really are looking for feedback on these principles that have been put forward.
SPEAKER_19: I hope that some of you will direct your comments to that.
Unknown: Safi, please.
Unknown: Hello, my name is Safi and I am a member of DFLOC, but I just want to say my fellow oligarchs,
SPEAKER_52: I come to you as another who has a devout hatred of the pores.
SPEAKER_52: I too believe we should make life harder for the peasants that we rule over,
SPEAKER_52: and we can do that too if you help approve of this data center.
SPEAKER_52: The pores don't need clean water to drink.
SPEAKER_52: They claim that these data centers steal anywhere between 300 and 5 million gallons of clean drinking waters from communities per day.
SPEAKER_52: But, pitch posh, why should we care?
SPEAKER_52: The water is going to turn brown.
SPEAKER_52: We can't allow these beggars to be choosers.
SPEAKER_52: They should be happy that you are allowing them to drink water.
SPEAKER_52: One of the tactics that I admire the most is how we are killing off the pores in a more subtle and covert way.
SPEAKER_52: Data centers release pollutants that elevate the risk of cancer for those living nearby.
SPEAKER_52: And if those residents don't die from cancer, then they still have a good chance of contracting a respiratory disease.
SPEAKER_52: And it's diabolical.
SPEAKER_52: I support it just as much as you all do.
SPEAKER_52: And something that tickles me is how you are intentionally making life harder for minority groups.
SPEAKER_52: Families who live by depot park are Latino, Vietnamese, and Laos.
SPEAKER_52: And what's fantastic is 47% of those households don't even speak English.
SPEAKER_52: So all this is happening to him, and they don't know about it, and they can't fight back or say anything about this.
SPEAKER_52: And I am just so impressed at all these sneaky tactics and how cunning you all are.
SPEAKER_52: Tell me, I want to know, how much money are you all making from this?
SPEAKER_52: Don't be shy. You can stay in front of these ingrates.
SPEAKER_52: Let them know. Let them wallow in despair, knowing that you are willing to sacrifice them for personal gain.
SPEAKER_52: Let them know that when it comes to money, they are a sacrifice you are willing to make.
Unknown: My fellow oligarchs, I do thank you for your time.
SPEAKER_52: I truly hope you take all of our words into deep consideration and realize that the whiny words of these constituents mean nothing as you financially gain from this.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Next we have Megan.
Unknown: Good evening. I'm Megan Shumway. I belong to numerous climate organizations. I will not reiterate them here.
Unknown: SMUD was created for a not-for-profit utility that would protect ratepayers from corporate run utility costs and subsequent high rates.
SPEAKER_26: In 2021, SMUD passed a climate emergency declaration promising to do everything possible to become carbon zero, close out efficient gas burning plants, and get to 100% clean energy by 2030.
Unknown: KISO is so concerned about high demand events, such as heatwaves, that they ask SMUD not to close inefficient power plants that are polluting the health of frontline communities.
Unknown: Now large, low customers are becoming more ubiquitous and demanding kilowatts that in many cases would power the entire community where they are located.
Unknown: Unless SMUD puts policies in place to protect itself and ratepayers, we could see SMUD building infrastructure to provide that load and increasing procurement demands and then be left with stranded assets.
SPEAKER_26: A large, low customer could go bankrupt and leave the state with SMUD and the taxpayers and the ratepayers shouldering the bill for it all.
Unknown: This is why SMUD needs to impose an agreement for connection to our grid, which should include a tariff as insurance against these issues.
SPEAKER_26: Also, it is not unreasonable to require the customer to abide by county and state regulations of air and water quality standards.
SPEAKER_26: SMUD would not want to collude in an unlawful operation, therefore opening themselves up to litigation.
Unknown: In addition, asking a large, low customer to reduce the demand by a reasonable percentage during a grid emergency is common sense.
SPEAKER_26: Many of your other customers are already doing this. They should too.
Unknown: Also, we understand that some large, low customers cannot just turn down their demand and therefore have to have backup energy systems in place.
SPEAKER_26: Please wrap up your comments. Your time is up.
SPEAKER_19: These systems need to be clean energy and not pollute our environment. That's exactly what the ratepayers want. Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you, Megan.
Unknown: Next up we have David Wright.
Unknown: Good evening. Thank you to the veterans and the audience.
Unknown: One thing we've learned in the last ten days is that when our elected representatives will not lead, the people will lead and the representatives must follow.
Unknown: So while I think one of the things that you ought to do is work with the cities and the county to encourage data center moratoriums,
SPEAKER_73: I will say that I think that, is it item four of your principles, says structured in a manner to support clean energy goals.
SPEAKER_73: Previous speaker also noted that this is not specific enough. I believe it should say SMUD will explicitly back projects that meet a zero carbon standard, including for backup and emergency power and large load projects should accept SMUD curtailment of power in power emergencies.
Unknown: Item five of the principles says SMUD will seek community benefits.
Unknown: I say, fine on that. We don't want no hyperscaler bribes.
Unknown: SMUD should not offer or take any inducements.
SPEAKER_73: Should not offer grants in advance of city or county approval.
SPEAKER_73: And should not accept bribes or community benefits before city or county approval.
SPEAKER_73: SMUD should publish all interconnection requests exceeding five megawatts, including the project location.
SPEAKER_73: I would like to see you guys remain neutral and adhere to ethics requirements. Thank you.
SPEAKER_73: Thank you for your testimony. Next up we have Peggy Glenn, James Wood and Vanessa Kudak.
SPEAKER_19: And again, really would appreciate getting feedback on the principles that staff has put together for us. And thank you all who have done that. Peggy.
Unknown: Thank you. I'm so glad my name was easy to pronounce. And there you go.
Unknown: I am Peggy Glenn. I live in Natomas and I did a little research. It turns out that SMUD is just two years younger than I am.
Unknown: So I would hope that you have a little bit of wisdom like I've gained a little.
Unknown: You serve a population of roughly a million and a half people. This is a microcosm of that.
Unknown: Governance, community owned. I know what that means. That means the people here.
Unknown: And govern my seven member board. And I think I heard in the other room that some of your members are listening in. They're not able to be here in person.
SPEAKER_28: Yes, that's correct. You know, as your customer, I keep getting notes that you'd love us to support a clean energy future.
SPEAKER_28: And you ask for policy. The first piece of policy I would like to offer is that you support humans before data.
SPEAKER_28: And the reason for that is I looked at SD7 as you put that up earlier and it's just a little vague.
Unknown: You know, this is an area that has a lot of issues. In retro Cordova, people are living where there was a super fund for Crown Out Loud.
Unknown: The data centers are not just power. They're also water. And they're more than just power that they use. They're power that they wield.
SPEAKER_28: So when you think about your constituents, the people who voted you in, I would hope that you would just think about them for a minute.
Unknown: How much will all of your services need to be improved just to serve that increase while still supporting the rest of your constituents without problem?
Unknown: I believe that infrastructure that you need to create is better spent on people, not mega billionaires and data tech companies.
Unknown: I think you have a responsibility in terms of policy of communicating more clearly worded goals to all the agencies in your jurisdiction.
Unknown: And my number one comment.
Unknown: Policy humans first. Be proactive, not performative and remember that you are elected by your constituents. Thank you very much.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. Next, James Wood.
SPEAKER_19: Maybe the only human in this room that's going to tell you a personal story about why I think data centers should be in Sacramento.
Unknown: Let's talk about the micro first. Sacramento is the only large city in California that is not on a fault line.
Unknown: So if I want my EMS, I want my computer driving my car, or I want my cell phone, I want that data center in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_16: I don't want it in Los Angeles or San Diego.
SPEAKER_06: I think they were quiet when you spoke, but anyways, I'll get to some jokes later. Why couldn't the data center have a relationship with the server?
Unknown: It couldn't take the cooling off constantly. Anyways, let's make an assumption that we've got two things. We've got a data center and we've got a mini storage building.
Unknown: I personally hate mini storage buildings. I think they're ugly. I think they do nothing for the economic impact, and I would love to ban them.
SPEAKER_16: But I know that we live in a place where that would be foolish to ban mini storage buildings.
SPEAKER_16: Where would the people that are too stupid to know their house is small store their stuff?
SPEAKER_16: So if you want to compare mini storage and the jobs, you've got low paying jobs and three of them versus a hundred.
SPEAKER_16: You've got a construction boom that employs lots and lots of people versus sticks and matches almost.
SPEAKER_16: And the reason that I'm pushing on this is because everywhere I drive in Sacramento, I am assaulted by mini storages, advertising and signs.
SPEAKER_16: I have yet to have been assaulted by a single data center. And when those hard drives need erasing, it is my company that goes in there and erases those hard drives and puts sacraments into work, gaining meaningful employment.
Unknown: I'm sorry, did you want to say something?
SPEAKER_16: Please wrap up your comments. You're out of time.
SPEAKER_16: Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you. Next up we have Vanessa.
Unknown: Good evening, members of the board. My name is Vanessa Cuttabak, and I'm proud to serve both as the vice president of the Sacramento City Teachers Association and as a long time educator in Sacramento.
Unknown: Couple of fans.
Unknown: Every day I see firsthand how deeply our students rely on their neighborhood schools as safe, healthy spaces.
SPEAKER_68: It is unfortunate that all too often decisions are made in our city without sufficient collaboration with our local schools and without fully examining how those decisions will affect our students.
Unknown: That is why I'm urging our SMUD board members to deeply consider the impact on our local schools while reviewing any principles or policies that open the door to data centers in our communities.
Unknown: There has been talk that some developers want to create a data center in southeast Sacramento near Depot Park.
Unknown: It is important that you are proactive in considering the potential impact on the three local schools that are just down the street from the proposed location.
SPEAKER_68: We're talking about real children at Camille Elementary. We'll see Wood Middle School and Earl Warren Elementary.
SPEAKER_68: These are school sites where nearly 90% of the students are economically disadvantaged and already face a myriad of challenges such as higher than average homeless youth rate.
Unknown: We all know that lower income communities have unfairly shouldered the burden of environmental pollution and data center developers frequently target such communities.
Unknown: What are you doing to prevent this potential disaster from happening to our local children?
SPEAKER_68: What conversations are you proactively having with our local school leaders about how you will follow principle two holding your customers harmless?
SPEAKER_68: I share call I share call learning next to a data center harm.
Unknown: SMUD is our community owned utility. Please stand with Sacramento's working families and ensure your actions protect our schools and neighborhoods.
SPEAKER_68: Reject any proposal that opens the door to data centers and please boldly support a moratorium. Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you for your comments. Up next we have Quinn and then cater and then.
SPEAKER_19: Then seen is it.
Unknown: Quinn.
Unknown: There's like people in the other room. Yes, we can wait.
Unknown: Is cater here yet? Why don't you come forward? Let's hear from you.
Unknown: Hello, my name is cater Shay and I got my master's degree in composition rhetoric and professional writing and a lot of what I did to was in digital literacies and while I could talk about for on and on about the issues that a I is racist a I is you know invasion of privacy so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_34: The thing I want to talk about especially for SMUD is the different impacts environmentally in our public health. So each a I search takes about one bottle of water to cool these day AI data centers and that water is unusable to the public after the steam that is created after that water has been known to have health effects such as asthma and other bronchial issues that are usually in black and brown communities where these AI data centers are put.
SPEAKER_34: Additionally, that water that has been shown outside to be used in rural and urban communities is undrinkable. There are communities that have no drinking water. Additionally, the noise that is produced by these large data centers is known to cause extreme stress and hearing loss to not only humans but to animals.
SPEAKER_34: Most of the time, AI data centers also have lithium ion battery plants with it, which has been known to be the future of climate change. But however, in the worst case scenarios has been known to cause thermal runways, which are fires you cannot put out and there have been fires in certain cities and towns that have gone on for a year.
SPEAKER_34: I keep hearing from the board to express what we want to improve about the language and these policies, but we don't want improvement. We cannot negotiate with large corporate greed. We want SMUD to have a complete moratorium on large AI data centers. Thank you. Thank you. Next up is Quinn.
Unknown: Across the country, Americans have rejected these large load data centers geared towards AI. And yet we still see people like this board genuinely considering proposals that would waste our water, pollute our air, bottleneck existing resources and force Sacramento residents to face constant noise pollution, a phenomenon we know to have negative psychological impact and is considered a form of psychological warfare when used in combat regions.
SPEAKER_55: So my question then becomes, is SMUD truly willing to engage in psychological warfare against the people whose tax dollars pay your salaries? You claim there will be no harm or load on existing customers. But what about the harm that comes from being ignored by the people who claim to serve us?
SPEAKER_55: What about the harm of having energy you pay for diverted to power corporations who see us as nothing more than pawns? What about the harm of constant noise that will not let us rest as we see our siblings in Palestine being subjected to a new threat?
SPEAKER_55: What about the harm of Palestine being subjected to by the same organizations and capitalist mindsets SMUD is now seeking to make our neighbors? If you want these data centers so badly, build them next to your homes. But the people did not ask for this. Your own greed hat is frankly, it is nothing short of sad and pathetic. And that is why we are all here.
SPEAKER_55: So you have to push forward with a proposal like this. It's going to make everybody that voted for you people, it's going to make the people who live and work and love this city see you as nothing more than corporate shills, oligarchs and pathetic useless public servants. Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Next up we have, I don't know if it's Vivian or Venomi Trotus.
SPEAKER_19: Okay, let me call Emily Valme and Kristen and Daniela.
Unknown: Did the name say Vincent Trotter or Vivian Vivian? How I only get someone else that can actually read. I can give a damn if a fucking data center gets paid properly. Hey, shut up. It's my turn to talk. It's my turn to talk. I can care less if a data center gets built or not or if they pay for that data center. I don't want that data center. You know what that's gonna do?
SPEAKER_33: No, what?
SPEAKER_33: Okay, that's enough.
SPEAKER_19: That's enough. You know what a data center sounds like.
SPEAKER_33: It's loud as hell. It's gonna screw everyone's ears up. It's gonna screw one's health up. The mental health. You know what happened in Texas with Waco? They blasted them with the noise of dying bunnies for days. They were going to do that to everyone else here in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_33: And you think that my voice, the way I'm angry, is a thing that should be looked at as too much? This is the least I could do to you people. You don't want to see me do more to you people. The way you treat our people like we're trash. You guys are the trash. You're leeching off of our money. You're leeching off of all our resources, our water. Why are you getting antsy up there?
Unknown: Boo fucking who? Big Woop! You're not... Yeah! You're scared of my voices? You're scared of my voice? Then you should be fucking worried when the world wakes up to you. You're gonna be glad we're not France right now. You're gonna have to bow to happen when you make this data center have to stay the same time. You guys, I'll see myself out. Because I'm too emotional. Thwack!
Unknown: You know, I just want to remind everybody why we're here. SMUD is not in the position of approving data centers. The city and the county have the jurisdiction to give permits to businesses. And when they are permitted, SMUD must serve them.
SPEAKER_19: It is a requirement by law. However, what we're saying is that we have the ability to put some constraints on what, you know, large load data centers could ask for. So... Bring this energy to City Hall. Bring the energy to City Hall. Okay, now, we are gonna hear from the rest of you.
SPEAKER_19: We are gonna hear from the rest of our speakers. I think that is, you know, good advice to bring the energy to City Hall. Because the city and the county do have the ability to approve these projects. If they don't, we will not be serving them. If they do approve them, we will be putting requirements on the agreements with the large load companies.
SPEAKER_19: So, I just want to put that out there and ask that we all treat each other as fellow human beings. You and I are not that much different. None of us are getting payoffs from anybody. But we do want to hear what people have to say. And we've heard loud and clear that you hate data centers. We've heard it.
SPEAKER_19: But we also are trying to get our arms around what kind of principles should go in this document that will guide the decisions that this board makes. So, we're gonna go on with public comment.
SPEAKER_07: Chair, I want to say something. So, you just saw that one of our board members had a very negative reaction. And it wasn't out of anger. It was a visceral reaction. Now, I defend everybody hears right to say what they want.
SPEAKER_07: I defended that man who was yelling and screaming at us and calling us names. You have a right to call us names, to assert all sorts of bribery and things like that. But I do want to call out when he left the room, and I'm not discount the terrible angry man that triggered that.
SPEAKER_07: But some of you applauded that. And I want you to think about that. That you applauded somebody who triggered a reaction like that. You should be ashamed and you should apologize to Director Rose for supporting. You saw that reaction. He wasn't making that up.
SPEAKER_07: And I defend your right to say what you want to say, but don't applaud when somebody has a reaction like that. That's horrible. It's mean. It's bullying. And you don't need to do that to make your point.
SPEAKER_07: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Okay, so let's move on to Emily Christian and Daniela.
SPEAKER_32: My name is Emily Valente and I'm a resident of Elk Grove and also a member of the Eco Club at the CRC campus. I'm here to advocate for a moratorium on data centers in Sacramento. As you have heard plenty of times before from every other person that's spoken.
SPEAKER_32: They have a lot of more costs than do benefits. There's not a lot of benefits from AI that we're seeing besides a lot of the data centers that are being built are for generative AI, which is not the AI that detects cancers and is used in the medical field to save numerous lives.
SPEAKER_32: They're also a massive drain on the town's electricity and they skyrocket the electric bills. If you want to protect your consumers, you need to ensure that they, excuse me, if you'd, if you want to protect your consumers and put them first, you need to ensure that you are not advocating for things that are going to negatively impact our economic status.
SPEAKER_32: It is also true that the groundwater that they're using to cool their systems is also contaminating the drinking water and making it less usable, which as people have said before, it leads to health risks.
SPEAKER_32: And it also risks the health of the employees here and the people that are working here because you also use this water. And I believe that the right to live and the right to be healthy is more important than any AI innovation. Thank you.
SPEAKER_32: Thank you, Emily. Next up is Kristin.
Unknown: Hello, I'm Kristin. I am an affiliate with Sacramento Environmental Justice Coalition, SACIJC. I'm also on the board of the environmental group 350.org. I'm here also as a SMUD customer.
Unknown: Okay. One of the things that I liked about SMUD was the fact that, you know, it was supposedly community owned, but apparently it's owned by Blackstone now. Okay.
SPEAKER_64: We can't, we can't go on like that. Yeah. And we do have, we don't have, we're not the same, by the way. You and us, you guys are in a position of power and we are not. Okay.
SPEAKER_64: We are at, I can't even call myself a customer because I have no choice. Right. And you guys are making these decisions and we just, we're no longer a community run organization, are we?
Unknown: So what can we do about it? We're here today to tell you for the record, that's why we're here, to put this on the record, to make it known that you know how we feel.
Unknown: Okay. And the only thing that I disagree with about that young man who that young peasant, like myself, who is angry and you know, understandably acting like that is that now you guys get to play the victim and disappear.
SPEAKER_64: Also, I want to just point out that the other two board members, I can't see their faces up here. All right. This is a problem. This is a problem. I can't see your faces in the other room.
SPEAKER_64: This, it's a clear sign that you guys just do not care about what we're doing, about who we are and why we're here. Okay. You're just, you know, going to keep doing what you're doing.
Unknown: And if Nancy is still here, you know, there's plenty of room over where you live in Rancho Córdova, over at the, uh, Cávola Ranch, plenty of room at Cávola Ranch, Nancy, for a data center over there. All right. Let's put one there. How about that?
Unknown: Okay. Thank you for your comments. Daniela?
Unknown: Hey, uh, chair, I'd just like to log in and be sure folks know I'm still here. Thanks.
SPEAKER_24: Thank you, Director Córdova.
Unknown: Hello. My name is Danielle Simucy. I live here in Sacramento. I have been obviously getting my service with SMUD, but I'm also a green energy customer.
SPEAKER_27: And I have been extremely disappointed with the outcomes of that program because of questionable decisions like Coyote Creek project, as well as now this data center collaboration that despite your statements that you're not the ones that get to the side.
SPEAKER_27: If a data center moves forward, you have a voting decision to take the contract. You can refuse to take the contract. And that is not something that the city can force you to do.
SPEAKER_27: If you find it morally questionable and you should.
Unknown: Also, um, there I have concerns about sustainable sourcing of the additional energy that will be used for the proposed data centers. So there's no fossil fuel, derived energy used to power it.
SPEAKER_27: Principal number four says you aim to protect a clean energy and resource planning existing solar and wind supplied energy is already inadequate for current needs and to serve 100% of the needs of existing customer.
SPEAKER_27: All focus should be to make that your number one goal of supplying 100% clean energy for all existing needs before such a large scale project is undertaken, especially given the long term demand of a data center cannot be act estimated with any accuracy.
SPEAKER_27: Principal two says that you want to aim to hold all existing customers harmless so that we do not bear any adverse financial effects. That is not possible. And such a big statement is not useful because there will be exorbitant financial cost to the customers in the areas of personal health, public health and environmental damage that data centers cause.
SPEAKER_27: Including as others have mentioned noise pollution, water contamination, depletion of our local aquifers and groundwater.
SPEAKER_27: And those are not required to be mitigated by data centers before they are built. Our environmental review is significantly weak.
Unknown: It needs to be strengthened before such projects should move forward. Principal five says that you wish to see community benefit if you truly wish to walk the talk. We demand that somebody will categorically categorically refuse any and all data center projects until Sacramento residents and California voters generally.
SPEAKER_27: Have the opportunity to discuss legislation that keeps our communities and ecosystems safe. If you choose to proceed with this project despite the clear and unequivocal demand of the public that you are supposed to serve, you will be complicit in causing human suffering and all you will stand for is hypocrisy.
Unknown: Okay, thank you, Rachel. Next we have Mo Kashmiri and Lena.
Unknown: And Rachel Flemming Bob. Take this energy to city council, y'all let the mayor know your thoughts.
Unknown: Hello, I'm Mo Kashmiri. I live in Southside Park, and I moved here from Fresno, just after the pandemic and I thought it was, you know, my son didn't want to go to the wanted to go to the closer school because he was afraid he'd die of climate change when he was in fourth grade.
SPEAKER_30: And I didn't really pay attention to climate issues before then I was just kind of like, yeah, that's a thing too. And I started reading out it and I was like, holy crap, this is a big problem. And then I was so proud to hear that smud was taking on a 2030 goal and doing leading the way in the fight that mattered.
SPEAKER_30: I was so proud to be a part of smud. I was like, we could never pass this shit in Fresno. Like here in Sacramento, I'm finally part of a place that's leading the way.
Unknown: I think you're seeing some anger here today, because the message is loud and clear. The message about your statement the word is missing is hell no to data centers.
SPEAKER_30: It's also missing some wording, such as more rad for him. That's kind of missing. I really don't like it when people play a politician say they can't do anything about a problem. Oh, we were just powerless.
SPEAKER_30: You know, what I've learned is that politicians can delay. They can make things difficult. They can make them harder. They can put more loops on it. When I wanted to get solar panels put in my house, it took forever to get those approved.
Unknown: And you're talking about approving data centers make it hard. Our community does not want that. They are saying unequivocally, hell no to the surveillance state.
SPEAKER_30: Hell no to the AI and corporate overlords. And hell no to data centers in Sacramento. We want you to protect our water, our air, our land and our communities.
SPEAKER_30: Put that in the docks. Send it back to the staff and say rework this over. It's not good enough. This community does not want this period.
Unknown: I want, I want to be proud of smud again. I don't want to feel, feel fooled by any more greenwashing bullshit. Thank you. Hell no to the data center.
Unknown: Thank you for your comment. Next person is Lena.
SPEAKER_19: Hi, I'm Lena. I was born and raised here in the Northern California Valley and I'm from a suburb, but I'm also a Sacramento State alumni.
SPEAKER_31: And I wonder what does this, how does, who does this benefit in Sacramento? Is it only benefiting you four people and the other three that couldn't even show up? Oh, wait, no, Rob Keith. He's on the thing.
SPEAKER_31: But anyways, who is it benefiting? And do we want this building that ideologically speaking doesn't represent us as citizens. It doesn't represent the values we want our children to lead.
SPEAKER_31: And when this data centers up and the AI bubble burst and it's just flooded maybe because we completely destroyed the groundwater table and it's completely destroyed and you guys are long dead by now.
SPEAKER_31: What is going to happen? Do you care? Do you care about us? I don't understand. You're supposed to serve us, but you act as if you're helpless and that it's just the city. It's not just a city. You play a huge role in this.
SPEAKER_31: Why can't you do anything? Why are you just sitting here and being upset that people are angry? They have a right to be angry and you have your right to act.
SPEAKER_31: We need you to do this for us. It is not just on us. It is also on you. Who do you care about yourself or us?
Unknown: All right. Next week is Rachel.
Unknown: Hi, thanks. My name is Dr. Rachel Vlamenbaum. I'm a professor at Sac State and I do research qualitative research on issues of language and digital literacy.
Unknown: You've repeatedly reminded us that you want us to speak to the principles and you've heard repeatedly that you are as a public community based institution a major voice in larger conversations about the approval and existence of these data centers in the first place.
SPEAKER_35: Contrary to popular belief, while there are students using AI tools in my classes, and there's a lot that I could say about that, the vast majority of my students working class first generation students who are trying to build better lives for their families and themselves, let's futures that are being stolen by AI tools.
SPEAKER_35: They are vehemently against AI for ethical and moral reasons, for privacy reasons, for environmental reasons. They believe in the value of thinking deeply and critically and grappling with big ideas. They believe in human thriving.
Unknown: There is simply not the demand for AI in the way that the companies pushing these tools insist exist.
SPEAKER_35: It is not inevitable. It is not inevitable. And we've said repeatedly this evening, this community that you serve wants you to put the full weight of your organizational power against these data centers.
SPEAKER_35: I frankly do not believe that the data center contract engaging in that would be at all possible to maintain the principles you've put up in this proposal.
SPEAKER_35: The data centers themselves are antithetical to the goals of maintaining your existing obligations, maintaining your clean energy goals that this community deeply cares about and wants to see happen.
SPEAKER_35: They're antithetical to maintaining all of those existing obligations. And you may feel unsafe being yelled at in this room, but engaging in these contracts would actively endanger this entire community. So as my students would say, be so for real right now.
Unknown: Okay, thank you for your comments. Next up we have Amanda Mack, Christina Corriera and Leah Painter.
Unknown: Hello. Thank you for saying my name almost correctly.
SPEAKER_36: So you say you can't say no to data centers, but actually you have the power and the responsibility to make sure they don't have an easy time building in Sacramento.
Unknown: The only positive comment you saw tonight was from a man who had personal financial gain from a data center and he admitted it as he was walking away from the microphone that his business was integrally tied to data centers.
Unknown: To start, you can apply support for a moratorium or you can openly support a moratorium. You can keep asking for feedback and it's clear what people want, the moratorium.
Unknown: But let me address what you have here because this is what you're asking for. You're asking for feedback on this. And I want to say and be clear, words matter.
SPEAKER_36: You definitely should have taken more time to look over this document and look over the verbiage and words that you are using. That is irresponsible. That is your literal job.
Unknown: First, you have the power over the cost allocations. Data centers should be paying 100% of the new substations, transmissions and transformer upgrades.
SPEAKER_36: No cost should be passed on to the residential or small consumer. Residential or small consumer.
Unknown: Financially, you can require these multi-million dollar companies to have a non-refundable deposit or bank back guarantees.
SPEAKER_36: 90% of their reserve capacity should be procured. I can't word. I'm sorry. The timer is freaking me out.
SPEAKER_36: Utilities may throttle or cut power. These utilities may, you can have the ability to make sure these utilities throttle or cut power during peak emergencies.
SPEAKER_36: Facilities should have on-site batteries or backups and guarantee for rapid AI load spikes. And you have a requirement to create legal safeguards.
SPEAKER_36: You can build a tariff. You can require these ultra large loads, these 20 plus megawatts. Not sustained as...
SPEAKER_19: Please wrap up. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_19: Or not... You don't need the standard light. You can charge them the specialized tariffs. Just specialized tariffs the shit out of them.
Unknown: Okay. Thank you for your comments. Next up is Christina and then Leah.
Unknown: Is Leah or Christina...
SPEAKER_19: I'm sorry. I'm waiting to see if Christina is here to speak for herself.
SPEAKER_19: I see. Why don't you come forward, Leah? And if she comes in, then we'll have Christina go after you.
Unknown: Sure. Okay. My name's Leah. I'm 26. I was born and raised in Sacramento, California. And I'm not going to reiterate what everyone said about data centers being fucked up. You all already know that.
Unknown: But I do have some things to say to you. You, in your condescending tone, telling people you have no power here is absolutely abhorrent and disgraceful. You serve us. You are elected to serve us. And you, talking about your little feelings being hurt, womp womp. That's your job for your feelings to be hurt. You are elected to hear us out. And yes, we are angry. And we will be angry. So get used to it.
SPEAKER_58: If your organization chooses to let any large, low data centers into Sacramento, California, you will face backlash. Whether that's in a city hall meeting, a SMUD board meeting, or out on the streets. So prepare yourself. I'm not done.
Unknown: Everyone in this room besides you people agree that data centers are absolutely abhorrent. It is a misallocation of necessary resources that we need to survive. Your reputation with the public will never be the same if you serve power to any large, low data centers.
SPEAKER_58: I, and I'm sure I can speak for all my friends here, will not stand for future generations' childhood memories to be soundtracked by incessant humming noise. Sitting there, twiddling your thumbs, lying that you have no power when you do. You do.
Unknown: You have the power to choose whether or not you throw the people of Sacramento under the bus. Asking us, oh, is it okay if we finally sell out you working class Americans to billionaires? No! It's not okay! Listen! And again, the condescension. I'm saying, oh, I fight for your right to be heard. We have freedom of speech here. Excuse me. You don't need to fight for that. It was already fought for and won. Thank you, veterans.
Unknown: Like, anyway, when you consider these conditions, consider whether or not you want to destroy countless lives, leaving already impoverished and struggling communities desperate with nothing to lose. Have you ever seen what a cornered animal will do when it's desperate to survive? Because you could.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments, Leah. Next we have Christina. Is Christina in the room? If not, we'll call up Jesse Montoria, Noah Dagle, and Owen Nagyica.
Unknown: Are you Noah or Owen? Owen, please come forward and the other folks will go after you.
Unknown: Hello, directors. My name is Owen Nagyica, and I am the student board member of Sacramento City Unified School District's Board of Education, and I'm urging you to support a moratorium against data centers in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_02: A proposed data center in Depot Park in South Sacramento puts working families at risk and our most youngest learners. As previously stated today, the proposed site is located by four of our elementary schools, Orr Warren, Elder Creek, Camilia Basic, New Joseph Bonheim, a middle school, Wilsey Wood, and two high schools, West Campus High School and Hiram Johnson High School.
SPEAKER_02: I am a student at West Campus High School. This does very much affect me. Up until I was 14, I lived in Southeast Village, a neighborhood located by Depot Park.
SPEAKER_02: We are already a working class community that is suffering from Sacramento's history of redlining and unclean air. By allowing the construction of a data center near our neighborhood and for that matter anywhere in Sacramento, we're not just putting our youngest Sacramento further at risk, but Sacramento all over the area.
SPEAKER_02: How can we ask our students to learn with the noise, air, water, and other forms of pollution caused by data centers?
SPEAKER_02: Please think of the future that you want for our youth. And data centers stand in clear opposition to a green future where air isn't a commodity that we have to labor for, where the rivers that surround our beautiful community aren't polluted, and where we as Sacramento as a city are carbon neutral.
Unknown: Also, Director Herbert, to link this back to the principles that you are asking us to mention, the construction of data centers stand in complete opposition to principle two, existing customers are held harmless, and principle five, protect clean energy and resource protecting tools.
SPEAKER_02: I urge the board to pursue a moratorium to meet with local boards of government in Sacramento and most importantly, meet with your constituents to expose yourselves to the consequences of data centers suffered by the people.
SPEAKER_02: Please choose people over profit, the many over the money, and protect our working families and our environment, not our private corporations. You as elected members of this board have the power and responsibility to go to our counties and our cities to advocate for a more
SPEAKER_02: moratorium on data centers. It's what we elected you to do. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Jesse Montoya.
SPEAKER_22: Am I good to go now? Yes, you're good. Hi, I'm Jesse Montoya, and I'm here to speak as a citizen of Sacramento. And I say it would be flat out wrong to build another AI data center in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_22: AI data centers consume millions of gallons of clean water leaving only dirty water for us, the citizens to drink, cook, clean and bathe with, not to mention our rivers coming even dirtier than they already are when the wastewater from the center is dumped.
SPEAKER_22: Think about the wildlife. Think about the people who won't have clean water or clean air. Anyone who believes large load data centers should be built in Sacramento is an absolutely vile, inhumane, inconsiderate and disgusting individual.
SPEAKER_22: We don't want constraints on AI data centers. We want zero data centers. You people are not helpless as helpless as you portray to the public eye and you hold the power to stop this and if you don't, we fucking will.
Unknown: Okay, next commenter will be Noah.
Unknown: Hello, my name is Noah Daigle. I am a more recently new constituent in the resident of Sacramento, and I'm also a student at Sacramento State studying biological sciences.
SPEAKER_17: There are so many issues with data centers, as we've all heard and we all know. One that I have not heard mentioned much is that data centers, of course, are known and shown to support the creation and publishing of child sexual assault material.
SPEAKER_17: Among other things, and of course as a biological sciences student, I am extremely worried about the environmental impacts.
SPEAKER_17: As I and other students have talked about, we're going into these studies to aid in conservation and what will we and our future biologists be able to protect if there's nothing left and if we are not here.
SPEAKER_17: It's also very hard to hear that you say you have nothing that you can do when I'm sure that there is and people have shown you that there is.
SPEAKER_17: And seeing all of this and the shadiness that I have learned of from these propositions is hard to hear and the pride that I once felt moving into Sacramento and hearing about smuds effort to clean energy and sustainability has been completely lost. Thank you.
SPEAKER_17: Thank you, Noah. Our last speakers are Isla Piscoso, Nathan Dom, and Christina Carriera.
SPEAKER_19: We're coming up, I do want to point out that I have about 13 cards that are marked for items not on the agenda so ordinarily they would be called at the end of all the other items that we have to discuss tonight.
SPEAKER_41: In case anybody's wondering why the name's not been called.
Unknown: Okay, Isa or Nathan or Christina.
Unknown: Isa.
Unknown: Okay, please come forward.
Unknown: Hello, my name is Isa Piscoso. I respect you and I ask that you respect me.
SPEAKER_61: I respect that you've requested response to your principles specifically. If you are concerned about principles I'm going to read you some facts that I find relevant.
SPEAKER_61: The Sacramento homeless population is up 13% in the past year. Blackstone is the largest rental housing owner in the US.
Unknown: They spent over $7 million, first in 2018 and then again in 2020 just to oppose rent control ballot initiatives.
SPEAKER_61: Then in 2022, when the initiatives were applied, they evicted tenants, because while the grant control limited rent increases to existing tenants, it didn't limit how much they could charge new ones.
Unknown: And before you dismiss these facts as irrelevant, I remind you that Link Logistics is Blackstone's new venture through which they can profit off of hurting people.
SPEAKER_61: They have proven again and again that they will not hesitate to throw people under the bus, all to appeal to investors and turn a quick buck. That is their principle.
SPEAKER_61: That is the principle that all of these large corporations are founded on, profits over people, and if you give them the space and resources to do that, they will.
Unknown: If you are willing to put all of that aside, you cannot hold your customers harmless. You do not seek community benefits and you can't apply your listed principles in reality.
Unknown: People are angry. People clearly do not want these data centers in their communities inconveniencing and harming them just so corporations can profit.
Unknown: We know what these corporations are willing to do and we know what they are willing to take.
Unknown: So I'm begging you, on behalf of your community, the people you serve, for a full and complete moratorium on data centers, that's what we're doing here, everyone we're begging.
SPEAKER_61: But you aren't listening. So if you don't listen to us when we beg, you will find more and more people find that they have no choice but to shout and to curse and to get mad and to scream.
SPEAKER_61: Thank you.
SPEAKER_61: Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: The last two speakers, Nathan Phan and Christina Carriera, are you out there?
Unknown: Is anybody coming?
Unknown: Yes, please come to the microphone and give your name.
Unknown: Good evening. My name is Nathan Phan. I was born and raised here in Sacramento and as a math student, I wanted to speak pragmatically about math.
SPEAKER_04: So just on the proposal of an increased load of up to 50 megawatts or more, up to 300, our infrastructure is already strained and aging from the build out from the mid century.
SPEAKER_04: And there is, with the decline of our manufacturing, there is a shortage in, as was said, of our substations, of our transformers.
SPEAKER_04: And your principles, your goals are in direct opposition to any opposition to data centers.
Unknown: When this gets approved, there will be no reliability. There will be no alignment with your 2030 carbon free goals.
SPEAKER_04: So I'd like to join the overwhelming opinion and call for a complete moratorium on data centers. Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_04: Thank you for your comments. The last speaker is Christina Carriera. Christina, are you here? Welcome. Please come to the microphone.
SPEAKER_62: Hello. I'm Christina and I'm a concerned member of the Filipino community here in Sacramento. I'm a member of Gabriela Sacramento, which is a Filipino women's organization fighting for the liberation of our homeland.
SPEAKER_62: And we are here to say that we're in solidarity with all our fellow community members who are saying no to data centers in our community.
SPEAKER_62: As Filipinos organizing for the liberation of our homeland, we also want to share the struggle that we are also fighting against back home for the Philippines.
SPEAKER_62: There's also a lot of presence of AI and data centers too that is shared right now. Trump is even planning to come visit the Philippines to broker deals with the current president to allow data centers to be built over indigenous ancestral lands.
SPEAKER_62: And this is called Pax Silica. It's a U.S. led initiative that, you know, similar to what y'all are, that people have spoken about here, spends billions of dollars to create AI hub, not for the people, but for billionaires and war profiteers.
SPEAKER_62: And it plunders the resources of our country and gives over 3030 acres to the U.S. for free.
SPEAKER_62: And, you know, this will only also further the surveillance of our people and at the expense of our environment. And, you know, that's a fight that we all are familiar with here in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_62: We invite other allies to join the Shut the Pax Down Coalition in joining the global movement to oppose AI data centers in Pax Silica.
SPEAKER_62: We are stronger when we take collective action as we see here tonight. From the U.S. to the Philippines, data centers out of communities reject Pax Silica. Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. Now we will go to our virtual attendees. Are there any comments from our virtual attendees?
Unknown: We have a number of virtual attendees. The first to speak is Simone Harb. The floor is yours.
Unknown: Hello. Can you hear me?
SPEAKER_66: Yes, we can.
SPEAKER_19: Okay. My name is Simone. I am for a moratorium on all data centers. I want all the studies posted publicly current and future. I want the type of data center being applied for and what already exists posted publicly.
SPEAKER_66: If there's an NDA signed by a SMUD member, I want that posted publicly. I want the live feeds to be visible in the future. I want to stipulate all energy needs be 100 percent sustainable clean energy.
SPEAKER_66: Production be built out to subsidize the needs of data centers and be paid for 100 percent by the data center owner solely.
SPEAKER_66: Zero, 20 megawatt or larger, let alone 50 megawatt data centers, applications accepted at all.
Unknown: I have a question for you. When we see clusters of data centers in one location that add up to over 50 megawatt collectively, does this prompt a new environmental study? If not, why not?
SPEAKER_66: And I have another question, which is, can we please request business viability studies be done on the field of general of super AI if the data centers are specifically for those purposes?
SPEAKER_66: A study done on the stability, regulations, purpose, longevity, creators of it themselves speak of everything from future imminent bankruptcy to end time events as possibilities.
Unknown: The field itself is not something we should be putting into our communities, investing in, relying on, having anything to do with.
Unknown: And before everybody has spoke about the ethical, environmental, privacy, everything else in regards to it. So I don't want to reiterate that, but I would really appreciate if you could honor my first requests and statements and answer my question. Thank you so much.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. I don't know if we can answer those questions, Joe.
Unknown: Normally we don't answer questions during public comment. If the board members feel like they particularly want to respond, you can do so briefly.
Unknown: Well, I don't have the answers to those questions. So, you know, she's asked for some specific data.
SPEAKER_19: We cannot share publicly. There are codes that prohibit the release of certain kinds of data usage data by customers, names of customers, locations of customers. This was adopted by the legislature to prohibit individual customers electric and water utilities from having public scrutiny into their what they're deemed as private business.
SPEAKER_41: As far as non-disclosure agreements, if a board member were to sign a non-disclosure agreement, and I've never heard that anyone ever has, the agreement could be provided. And if there was any confidential information in it, it would be redacted.
Unknown: Okay. Thank you. Can we hear from the next speaker?
SPEAKER_19: The next speaker's name is Thomas. The floor is yours.
Unknown: Thomas.
Unknown: Hello.
Unknown: Yes, we can hear you, Thomas.
Unknown: Can you hear me?
Unknown: Yes.
Unknown: Okay. My name is Thomas. I am a long-time resident of Sacramento, California. I was born and raised here. And I am opposed to data centers being developed in my city.
SPEAKER_71: Why do we need a data center here? What will it benefit? What will it cost? And to the gentleman who said that he will benefit from his business from it, yeah, to help with it. James Woods himself.
Unknown: But I will say this. We don't need another data center. Our environment is already in the environment itself is already in the pit. Why do we need another one here? What will benefit from it?
Unknown: I have family that lives in Sacramento. I grew up in that area. I don't want it being polluted by groundwater and by the atrocities that will be caused by these centers.
SPEAKER_71: I am tired of seeing them develop. Why not? And if anything, you people do have the right to say I'm rejecting this proposal. You do.
Unknown: And the reason why that man earlier who left the chamber or whatever, Matt, yeah, I relate to him too. I'm mad as hell too. I don't want my water or my utilities being raised.
Unknown: I'm an American and I'm mad as hell about the fact that this would come to my city. We don't need any more of that. What we need is equal housing and for the block term must also be brought down as well.
Unknown: It's not for data centers. Okay, because what we got again, all benefits from it, only the rich class will be stuck with the bill will be stuck with paying the bill will be the stuff with the polluted water will be with the ones stuck with the humming noises and and even then, the future.
SPEAKER_71: One lady mentioned her grandchildren. I have nieces and nephews. I don't want them going up around that type of crap.
SPEAKER_71: This is unforgivable. Yes, we can. I understand that, you know, if you take this energy to City Hall to the mayor. Yeah, I have anything that hasn't post about calling the mayor's office and I will be making folks all done to oppose it because we bought it for you all.
Unknown: And I'm done. No one data set.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker. Next we have Trinity Smith or smith.
SPEAKER_21: Hello. Hi, Trinity. I am a resident of Sacramento, and my recommendation really echoes all of those folks that you continue to tell stick to the principles, and it really is make this environment of Sacramento as hostile as possible to large scale data centers, as
SPEAKER_21: folks have said, you do have that power. I hope you understand that now. Just one more person adding that having to surprisingly empower you all as board members.
SPEAKER_21: I guess that's what community run and owned entity means is us empowering you instead of you all supporting and empowering us.
SPEAKER_21: We really need more than just these principles. You need new explicit detailed policies, you can create a moratorium and everything but name if that's really what is freaking you out here.
SPEAKER_21: Since you seem to have forgotten how bureaucracy can work, as other folks have mentioned, you can be a squeaky wheel you can make delay stall.
SPEAKER_21: Deny those are all things that are within your power. Some recommendations, you can take all the folks in this room and say, Oh man, we really need to establish and a community advisory group pay people, though, that shit can take forever.
SPEAKER_21: Also consider again reaching out to your friends at city and county, establishing a coalition with them. Similarly, that can stall this for years.
SPEAKER_21: Further in your internal studies, consider things beyond just utility rate costs, consider the water impact the healthcare costs include community engagement in those internal studies.
SPEAKER_21: And in defining existing communities are held harmless change that to all households and small business customers, well being and affordability is prioritized.
SPEAKER_21: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker.
Unknown: Speaker is Dadley McDonald.
SPEAKER_60: Hello, thank you. My name is actually Catherine shorter McGuire.
SPEAKER_60: I would like the board to consider the cybersecurity implications of any large data center proposals and implement governance and oversight principles that demand data centers guarantee that their compute infrastructure and their SMUD provided electricity will not be used to commit cyber
SPEAKER_60: crimes against organizations and individuals within our region.
SPEAKER_60: The SMUDs principles should also include that if data centers in our area are used to commit cyber crimes, particularly against the state agencies, medical centers businesses nonprofits, educational institutions or community members of the greater Sacramento
SPEAKER_60: region that those data centers will be held financially liable for the full cost of the hack and any other damages or losses, resulting from these hacks.
SPEAKER_60: We will incentivize developers to implement the highest levels of cybersecurity standards and minimize the negative cybersecurity impacts that will inevitably come as a result of large compute data centers coming to our area.
SPEAKER_60: Our area is the beating heart of our state government as an IT auditor at CalPERS who is responsible for protecting the incredibly sensitive healthcare and pension system that two and a half million Californians rely on.
SPEAKER_60: I can tell you that AI and hyperscale data centers are only making that job harder. Our state and local community IT professionals are terrified of the incoming tsunami, and we are simply not ready to deal with this crisis.
Unknown: The governor has recently issued an emergency executive order in order to for state agencies to prepare for this impending disaster.
Unknown: It is critical that SMUD make data centers liable because the cyber hacks often originate in foreign countries that do not have diplomatic or extradition agreements with the United States, namely Iran, Russia, North Korea.
SPEAKER_60: This means that American victims of these crimes, whether they are your grandmother or the large financial institution you bank with, will never see justice or restitution.
SPEAKER_60: A recent cybersecurity conference I attended where an FBI agent from our local Sacramento office gave a presentation about how our regional hospitals and medical centers are the most common targets and victims of ransomware attacks, which cripple their ability to provide critical medical services to their sick and dying patients.
SPEAKER_60: Please wrap up your comments. Your time is up.
SPEAKER_60: Thank you.
SPEAKER_60: Thank you. Next speaker. Next speaker is Ellen.
Unknown: Can you hear me? Yes.
Unknown: Good evening. I'm part of D flock Elk Grove and D flock Sac Metro, and I've been a SMUD customer for 20 years, many of those as a green energy customer. I felt fortunate to get my electricity through SMUD, especially when I hear about the significant challenges people served by other providers have had to deal with.
SPEAKER_43: The consideration of AI data center proposals in our community is something we expect from PG&E, not SMUD. The SMUD website says, quote, for over 75 years as your community owned not for profit electric service.
SPEAKER_43: We've delivered on a fundamental promise to provide you with safe reliable electricity at affordable rates. We've been committed to serving our community because we're part of the community.
SPEAKER_43: And I quote, you asked for comments about policies. Please listen to what folks here are saying. This is the community you say you serve and are part of. And the bottom line is we do not want data centers here. That's the only policy we need.
Unknown: This situation has me thinking about Georgia's Project Camellia data center, which is the subject of a massive lawsuit due to corrupt practices and backroom deals.
SPEAKER_43: The defendants in that case include county commissioners and the county manager who are having RICO charges brought against them.
SPEAKER_43: Specifically, it's alleged that the defendants committed fraud and concealment through non-disclosure agreements and misleading public statements so that the residents remained unaware of the nature of the project for as long as possible.
Unknown: The practices used for approval of that data center are a common strategy used across the US for specific data center proposals and also for the development of policies and principles for future data centers.
SPEAKER_43: Based on how things have played out here so far, I would not be surprised to learn that's what's happening with SMUD here in Sacramento. You say you have to serve any projects that are approved. Come on now, that is feckless statement to make and smacks of just following orders.
Unknown: That's BS that never stands up for scrutiny. Please wrap up your comments. Your time is up.
Unknown: You each have personal agency and need to take a stand against this. The community demands it. Thank you.
SPEAKER_43: Thank you. Next speaker. Our next speaker is iPhone.
SPEAKER_12: Hello. My name is Isabella, and I am a concerned constituent in Sacramento. And thank you again for hearing us all out as we have a united front against the AI data centers.
SPEAKER_12: In the beginning, I believe Tracy stated that we have 18 data centers already here in Sacramento and I'm very much appalled at that fact.
SPEAKER_12: Data centers are negatively impacting the environment due to how much water is used to power and cool the data centers. Sacramento has many rural areas that play an integral part in the agricultural industry as well.
SPEAKER_12: Notably like Galt or Lodi and other rural parts of Elk Grove. We need that water for agriculture so we can feed our communities locally, nationally, and even globally.
SPEAKER_12: Additionally, there have been headlines about how data centers affect the water pressure because of how much water is used. Our customers will certainly be disappointed and frustrated with the quality of their services that they pay for with their hard-earned money.
Unknown: From a public health perspective, there are social determinants of health, which affect a population's access to care or ability to form healthy habits. Built environment is a social determinant of health.
SPEAKER_12: And if a data center is placed in a community that is primarily underserved or vulnerable like the depot park, this will negatively impact these populations.
Unknown: Additionally, I also work in childcare and these children in Sacramento are future leaders, problem solvers, educators, and more. Children deserve to live and learn and play in safe areas so they can also be successful in life.
SPEAKER_12: If data centers are going to be placed here, the environment and air quality will be severely affected, which will also cause many health consequences. We already have high rates of eczema and asthma in Sacramento.
Unknown: Echoing the concern about cybersecurity, AI and healthcare do not mix. Sacramento communities rely on Medi-Cal, private insurances, etc. We want our health and dental care data secure.
SPEAKER_12: If data centers are placed here, it would be a threat to HIPAA and our privacy about our health. Health is a human right and I urge SMUD to lean into how data centers will take away our rights to a healthy environment, security, and our right to have safe water. Thank you.
SPEAKER_12: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker.
SPEAKER_19: Next speaker is the Sacramento Homeless Union.
SPEAKER_41: Since they're not coming to the line, how about Jessica Jimenez?
SPEAKER_19: What happened? Hello.
SPEAKER_19: Jessica.
SPEAKER_19: Are you there?
Unknown: Shh.
Unknown: Jessica, are you there?
Unknown: Is it the other person maybe?
Unknown: Hello.
Unknown: Please identify yourself.
Unknown: This is Crystal with the Homeless Union. Can you restart my time?
Unknown: Yes, we will do that.
Unknown: My name is Crystal Sanchez and I'm the president of the Sacramento Homeless Union. I wear minihats statewide, nationally and internationally.
Unknown: You guys want us to talk about your principles. Your principles mean that you have accepted the partnership of this environmental disaster.
Unknown: A great principle would be that you make a plan as an influential environmental utilities to advocate to stop this. You are not obligated to energize harm.
Unknown: Those with invested interest, you should, number one, rethink your priorities and number two, recuse yourself from any votes or anything having to do with this.
SPEAKER_59: We're going to talk about some things. Number one, we're going to talk about poverty, redlining, and environmental racism. We are not guinea pigs.
SPEAKER_59: Corridors, especially like North Highlands, already carry far more than their fair share of toxic hazards.
SPEAKER_59: We deal with freeway exhaust, heavy traffic, a 50 mile an hour street. We have rail lines, jet fuel storage tanks, nearby airports, and the unhoused shelter placements, permanent supportive housing, are located directly next to these heavy industrial hubs.
SPEAKER_59: You guys are targeting low income communities, dropping a massive energy-harguing industrial data center in these exact low income neighborhoods, this textbook environmental racism and poverty redlining.
SPEAKER_59: Policies that neglect the vulnerable. It's the same recurring pattern. Macro policies are written behind closed doors to favor corporate growth for tech giants like Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, Apple, and Blackstone.
SPEAKER_59: While the people living right next to these toxic corridors are completely left out of protection, we are not guinea pigs.
SPEAKER_59: The most vulnerable are always impacted by policy, but neglected in protection, and our health is not negotiable.
SPEAKER_59: Number two, still talking about North Highlands, violating Superfund protections, stirring up toxins, speaking of McClellan Park specifically, has a data center right now with 10 megawatts, was just rubber stamped to add an additional 18 more, with no vote, with a capacity of over 200 megawatts.
Unknown: The former McClellan Air Force Base is not just a piece of land, it's a designated EPA National Priority List Superfund site, with decades of deep, dangerous contamination.
SPEAKER_59: We are talking about volatile organic compounds, VOCs, TCEs, and PCEs, heavy metals, and persistent PFAs forever.
SPEAKER_59: Please wrap up your comments.
Unknown: For sure. You guys are continuing to put these in poverty-stricken areas. We are asking for you to stand on our side and advocate with the city and the county to stop these data centers. Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker.
SPEAKER_41: Jessica Menes, the floor is yours.
Unknown: Jessica, are you there?
Unknown: Are there any other speakers?
SPEAKER_19: Let's move on to JD.
Unknown: Hi, can you hear me okay?
SPEAKER_19: Yes.
Unknown: All right. Hi, my name is JD. I'm a resident and a one-time customer at SMUD. I'm here to speak on the Large Load Customer Service Principles.
SPEAKER_25: I do appreciate SMUD's effort in putting this together, but I'm concerned that this draft is full of promises and not real protections.
SPEAKER_25: My background is in construction contracts for large projects, and I know that these kinds of deals are built to allocate risk amongst all of the parties involved.
SPEAKER_25: Who pays when a project is delayed, when power is curtailed, or when something can't be served?
SPEAKER_25: In the energy world, we already know that grid operators are often forced to compensate power generators for forced downtime during oversupply.
SPEAKER_25: Curtailment risk and its costs also get written into similar contracts with large power centers like data centers and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_25: So my question for the board is pretty simple. In a contract with a large load customer like this, who would carry the cost of curtailment and the risk?
SPEAKER_25: Could they force SMUD to saddle the fees for power that it couldn't deliver to a data center?
SPEAKER_25: That question matters a lot when lives are on the line.
SPEAKER_25: A large load center like this may push the grid past what it can carry for every customer at once.
SPEAKER_25: If SMUD has to shed load during a heatwave, as we received warnings about several years ago, I want to hear from this board,
SPEAKER_25: will you commit that something will be put into the contracts, that the load center will be curtailed first,
SPEAKER_25: and residential and essential service customers will be curtailed last?
Unknown: This should not affect consumers and residents in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_25: We've elected you, you take care of the community, you represent us. So we're asking you to take care of us.
SPEAKER_25: SMUD's own summary admits that there are issues all across the country with these things,
SPEAKER_25: rising utility bills and a strain on electricity and water.
SPEAKER_25: But principles one and two say that large loads pay their own way and that existing customers are held harmless.
SPEAKER_25: But where will you put the contract mechanisms to enforce that?
SPEAKER_25: One last ask, which is that I ask that the board not recommend the adoption on November 19th
SPEAKER_25: unless you add a lot of things to this to ensure that the terms are enforced
SPEAKER_25: and that there is financial security, guaranteed payment commitments, exit fees, and curtailment protections
SPEAKER_25: and protections for the community and members of your constituents here in Sacramento,
SPEAKER_25: all before you spend even a cent on interconnection.
SPEAKER_25: And I second what other people have said.
SPEAKER_25: Lastly, that you have all the power. I know from my own experience in my work that I do for companies that build stuff.
SPEAKER_25: Okay, I'll be quick. That you do have the power to slow these kinds of things down.
SPEAKER_25: You can require further inspections. You can second-guess things. You can add extra studies.
SPEAKER_25: Please do this stuff. We really want you to represent us and protect us from these things. Nobody wants this.
SPEAKER_25: Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, please.
SPEAKER_19: Now we'll hear from Kai Bizoski.
Unknown: Hello. Can you hear me?
Unknown: Okay. Nice. All right. Good morning, Chair Herber and members of the committee.
SPEAKER_13: My name is Kai Bizoski. That's B-Z-O-S-K-I-E.
SPEAKER_13: And I am the member of
SPEAKER_13: the
SPEAKER_13: Sacramento County Sacramento County Sacramento County Sacramento County.
Unknown: And I'm here to help you with your research.
SPEAKER_19: Along with my research paper.
SPEAKER_41: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker.
Unknown: Except we have Darlene Westfall.
Unknown: Hello. Yes, Darlene. We can hear you.
SPEAKER_53: I live in the county, Sacramento County.
SPEAKER_53: I have lived 33 years across from a major energy complex of SMUD at Rancho Seco.
Unknown: And I'm speaking in regards to power generation and community involvement.
Unknown: You are working on an integrated resource plan that has not been finalized yet.
SPEAKER_53: However, there are policy meetings coming up.
SPEAKER_53: Recently in social media, there's a meeting set for January 28th of 27.
Unknown: In Herald, which also affects Wilton and Galt.
SPEAKER_53: And this is in respect to the generation of power throughout the region.
SPEAKER_53: Data centers take a lot of power.
SPEAKER_53: And what we found with Rancho Seco is that solar power is something that you need batteries to store that energy.
Unknown: Along with that comes other environmental risks, such as thermal runaway.
Unknown: However, with this meeting that's coming up in January, the attendance has already been restricted to 70 people.
Unknown: And the other thing is that you have to pre-register to participate online for this meeting.
Unknown: The reality is we have a place to meet, but we're not getting yes, ma'am.
Unknown: We have a place to meet, but we're not allowed to participate in our own future regarding power generation.
Unknown: Thank you. Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_41: Next speaker. The next speaker is a telephone number ending in the numbers 703.
Unknown: Or I'll say 9 1 6 5 3 9 9 7 0 3.
SPEAKER_41: My apologies. Do you hear me? Yes, we can.
Unknown: Please state your name.
Unknown: Oh, sorry. My name is Ethan. I'm a native Sacramento and for nearly 10 years, a happy smud customer.
Unknown: I understand that it may not be within your power to stop or otherwise reverse the large load project that's up for comment tonight.
SPEAKER_05: So myself and other Sacramento demand for transparency, accountability, responsibility, and all facets regarding the project in question.
SPEAKER_05: I define these demands as follows.
Unknown: Transparency. I cannot be led to believe that any developer seriously interested in operating a large facility would make moves to purchase or lease the space in which to build that facility without consulting the energy provider, which would be powering that facility.
SPEAKER_05: So I would demand that SMUD disclose any and all past and future correspondence between themselves and the developer of the project in question.
Unknown: Accountability. Sacramento from all walks of life should not be made to carry the financial burden of infrastructure modifications made to support large load developments, nor the increased energy rates that follow along with the operation of these facilities.
Unknown: Myself, other families, and the general public should not be subsidizing the cost of operation for large load facilities or their operators.
Unknown: Create a 10 year protection of Sacramento area energy rates under the current load and plot future rates against this projection.
Unknown: Make large load operators pay their fair share.
Unknown: Responsibility. The public is not happy with nor are we in support of initiatives like this.
Unknown: Do everything within your power to obstruct, delay, lobby against, and otherwise impede the progress of projects that are fundamentally harmful to your customers, your constituents, your community.
Unknown: The note that the lineman made of making policy curriculum facilities like this before residences and hospitals during load sheds. It's a fantastic example of the accountability and responsibility that we demand. Thank you for your time.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker speakers.
Unknown: Hello.
Unknown: Hello. Can you state your name for the record?
Unknown: Yes. Hi, my name is Elaine born and raised in North islands.
SPEAKER_72: I'm urging some to put a permanent moratorium on data centers and the construction of the prime data center and McClellan.
Unknown: I want to bring attention to the harmful impacts that we'll have on our future generations the construction of this data center severely harmful for children due to the pollutants that persistent noise and software.
Unknown: But when associated with the quickly expanding data center industry are linked to asthma other respiratory illnesses neurological and developmental damage and children.
Unknown: People living around the data centers are also a high risk of cancer, heart and lung disease.
SPEAKER_72: Children are especially vulnerable to these pollutants because their organs are still developing the noise pollution emitted by data centers is a constant hum 24 seven ranging from 40 to 90 decibels compared to having a vacuum constantly on outside your window.
SPEAKER_72: Children are especially harms as a persistent background noise has been linked to sleep disturbances for cognition to serve or decrease learning.
SPEAKER_72: Learning comprehension has been sent to interrupt classrooms in other states near McClellan.
SPEAKER_72: We have F.C. Joyce Elementary a low income several low income health centers of VA health clinic community center several parks residential homes subsidized housing food distributions, etc.
SPEAKER_72: McClellan is already home to an airport which comes with its own baggage and has a history of pollutants such as the PFAs in the groundwater.
SPEAKER_72: We must not exacerbate these health issues is exactly what it looks like to take advantage of marginalized communities into further abandon the people who have already been left behind.
Unknown: Additionally, to further advocate for our children, we must not support the development of data centers that are running for AI because AI is being used to generate CSAM, which is child pornography.
SPEAKER_72: There has been a 380% rise in related AI generator reports totaling to over 20,000 AI generated images in just one month.
SPEAKER_72: AI CSAM feels perpetrator sexual interest in children and increases the risk of physically offending. Generative AI models are trained using pictures of abuse which directly revictimized survivors and scrape non sexual photos of children to generate these images.
SPEAKER_72: That means if you have ever posted your child online on Facebook, Instagram, their picture may be scraped to create CSAM without your knowledge or consent.
SPEAKER_72: This is the same thing if schools are posting them online for any normal casual picture, they can be used to create child porn.
SPEAKER_72: So and the construction.
SPEAKER_72: Please wrap up your comments and the construction stop sacrificing our children, our communities, my neighbors for a paycheck.
SPEAKER_72: Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_72: Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Next speaker.
SPEAKER_19: Let's go back to Jessica from Jimenez.
SPEAKER_19: Jessica Jimenez.
SPEAKER_19: Are you there?
Unknown: Jessica going once.
SPEAKER_19: Jessica Jimenez.
Unknown: Twice and three times.
SPEAKER_19: Okay, so we.
SPEAKER_19: Yes, go ahead.
SPEAKER_19: We have had comments to the security team that a lot of the people who submitted cards for comments not on the agenda actually made a mistake and would like to speak.
SPEAKER_41: Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_19: Well, very good.
SPEAKER_19: I think there's about 10 of them here.
SPEAKER_19: So let me call out Desiree Moreno.
SPEAKER_19: Lorena Ramirez and Allison Hickox.
SPEAKER_19: And just again to say that, you know, we're looking to get feedback on these principles to guide us in making potential agreements with large load companies.
SPEAKER_19: So I know many of you just don't want us to make those agreements, but it is the law that we do have to provide power to them.
SPEAKER_19: So Desiree Moreno, are you around?
Unknown: How about Lorena Ramirez?
SPEAKER_19: How about Allison Hickox?
SPEAKER_19: How about Victoria Johnson?
SPEAKER_19: Very good.
SPEAKER_65: Hi, my name is Victoria. And just to keep from like repeating too much of what has already been said, I'd like to speak a little bit to your regulations that you've been asking us to speak about.
Unknown: And as I've been looking at this list, which also I'd like to add, this isn't visible in the other room. So it's a little hard to speak exactly to what you're saying without being able to see it back there.
SPEAKER_65: But I'd like to add that a lot of these, I feel like they are bandage statements and it feels almost as if a lot of these cannot be promised to us simply by the fact that AI is being put in these areas.
Unknown: You say that existing customers will be held harmless without exactly saying how you are going to ensure that these AI data centers are going to need their energy from somewhere.
SPEAKER_65: And it's clear that they are going to be taking a lot of it. And when it comes to making sure that constituents are held harmless and that our rates are the same, I feel that there is something that is just cannot be promised.
SPEAKER_65: Same thing going is for your regulation saying that you will protect clean energy and resource planning goals.
Unknown: Clearly that is something that cannot be promised to us.
SPEAKER_65: Previously you had stated that you had that 100 zero carbon goal by 2030, something that had to be draw back on.
SPEAKER_65: So I guess my main concern is that these regulations are things that you can draw back on. They're not things that are promised.
SPEAKER_65: It's clear that you guys aren't able to come through on some of these things.
SPEAKER_65: And I guess my main, just to reiterate the things that other people have been saying, there are ways that you guys can make it harder for them.
SPEAKER_65: I think that paying their own way, making them pay more than their own way because they are going to be hurting in ways that go beyond what they are paying for.
SPEAKER_65: I think that there are just oversights that a lot of these regulations aren't really addressing and I think that it can be looked at a bit better. Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you for your comments. Next we have Francesca Wander, Faith DeGusman and Abraham Mutani.
Unknown: Yes, I'm going to let this person after me go first because I have to restart my phone because my battery was dying. So who was the second agent?
SPEAKER_49: Faith DeGusman or Abraham Mutani.
Unknown: It looks like neither of them are here and my phone just powered back up. Thank you for your patience.
SPEAKER_49: Okay. And just please introduce yourself when you...
SPEAKER_49: While I'm opening up my document, my name is Francesca Wander. I am a 10-year activist, a grassroots organizer with Indivisible.
Unknown: I am also a proud California state worker and an officer in my union, SEIU Local 1000.
Unknown: And I am a voting constituent in the city and the county of Sacramento, District 1. Go Team Flow.
SPEAKER_49: I know you want us to answer your questions and I guess I would just echo what some other people said was that whatever you need to do to set the bar so impossibly high for data centers to enter our community, that's my answer to your question.
Unknown: From a financial standpoint, from a legal standpoint, and from a legislative standpoint, that bar needs to be set impossibly high so that it's not worth their coming here.
SPEAKER_49: Now that I've answered your question, in the historic 2026 midterm elections that just passed, there were no fewer than 47 ballot initiatives calling for moratoriums on data centers across the country.
SPEAKER_49: 46 of which passed by wide margins. Data centers, as you've heard tonight, are wildly unpopular across the country, the state, and here in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_49: We really shouldn't even be having this hearing here tonight because approving another one of these environmental and economic monstrosities should be a complete non-starter.
SPEAKER_49: Yet here we are. And the reason we're here is because public utilities, like SMUD, which is barely better than PG&E, I will add, historically serve the 200 billionaire corporate oligarchs who control our politicians, including gaslight McGavin Newsom, our social climate champion, the CPUC who contribute to protect utility profits over people,
SPEAKER_49: contrary to its public mandate, and SMUD, whose executives are more concerned about their pocketbooks and their promotions than the people they're chartered to serve.
SPEAKER_49: We either want nor need another large load 300 megawatt data center in Sacramento, and as my t-shirt explicitly says, fuck data centers in Sacramento. Thank you.
Unknown: Okay, next up we have Lena Sakab, Amaris Clay, and Takobi Arhager.
Unknown: Are we seeing any of those folks? Lena, Amaris, or Takobi? Takobi, yes, please come forward.
Unknown: Good evening. I think since the principal, the, what's the word I'm looking for? I think since the principals have been thoroughly commented on already, I would like to make a direct appeal to pathos.
Unknown: I live one block away from Carmelia Elementary School. I live smack dab in the middle of southeastern Sacramento.
Unknown: Pretty much every single person living in my neighborhood is part of some kind of marginalized community. We have immigrant communities. We have other kinds of black and brown communities.
Unknown: We have people who have been redlined. We have people who rely on Medicaid. We have people who are struggling just to survive.
Unknown: Every single day I see some kind of unhoused person in my community. I can't go to a park. I can't go to a public library. I can't go to the grocery store without seeing someone who is on the bottom rungs of society.
Unknown: You have the power to, at the very least, frustrate the development of these AI data centers in our community. And if you can't do that, your moral responsibility is to recuse yourselves.
Unknown: You know what the stakes are. This is unacceptable. Thank you. Thank you for your comments.
SPEAKER_19: Dylan McLeod, Christopher Manheit, and Brianna Church.
Unknown: Hi. Good evening. I'm Dylan McLeod. I'm a software developer living in Sacramento County. And I've been studying machine learning and AI safety for the past 10 years.
SPEAKER_15: And I just wanted to say that the consensus among the world's top AI researchers is that AI is very, very dangerous. Like in their own IPO filing, anthropic said, quote, AI may pose existential risks to humanity.
Unknown: And I don't know if you believe that. And I don't know if that's really relevant to a utilities company, but that should perhaps indicate the amount of risk that is involved in the AI industry.
SPEAKER_15: And if there is that much risk involved in the AI industry, then we should be accounting for that in our risk assessments. We should be very hesitant to, in particular, to increase our own exposure to those risks.
SPEAKER_15: So what I recommend is that you take them at your word. You should go through the writings of AI companies, which there is no shortage of them on the particular risks posed by AI, in particular, frontier training runs, which would be presumably held at data center, at data centers that you approve of.
Unknown: And you should go bullet by bullet, see what those risks are, and see where you can account for those risks in your own risk assessments. So you should hold them to a very high standard, be very thorough, and don't go easy on them. Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, go ahead and identify yourself.
Unknown: Hello, my name is Chris Monhite. I'm affiliated with people who pay their SMUD bill every month. So you keep saying you want feedback on your principles. So every one of these principles, as we've stated, is unacceptable because every one of them allows the existence of data centers that we have spent all night opposing.
SPEAKER_14: SMUD once said that they would aim for net zero carbon emissions by 2030. I understand that may have been renounced at this point. But if SMUD does not choose to fight this project, then it will be clear that they never held those principles that their constituents support to begin with.
SPEAKER_14: Your principles should be this, to do whatever it takes to make it impossible for data centers to be built in any of our communities in Sacramento County.
SPEAKER_14: Make the requirements for a data center so utterly infeasible that any corporation would want to build here, they would never try ever. Get as creative with our protection as you have with the allowance of collaboration thus far, and you will have served your people.
SPEAKER_14: Good politicians, good board members know how to finesse the bureaucracy to their constituents' needs. Do this. You can do this now.
SPEAKER_14: This year, we have watched the mayor of New York City do things that for decades that city said weren't possible. We no longer believe that you are powerless. If you don't have an actual say in this by some strange miracle, then postpone to take on the hearings with corporations. Make policies that are antithetical to those corporations. Demand a five-year study and back it with a committee review. Send proposals back for revisions forever.
SPEAKER_14: I'm not elected and I'm coming up with these things. I was writing these while I was sitting in this chair. Get into fights with your bosses. Force a crisis if you must to protect the people. Get into good trouble and we will have your back. If you can't, resign and one of us will do it for you. We don't want that. We want you to protect us. We trust you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_14: Thank you for your comments. Brianna Church.
Unknown: Hey everyone. My name is Brianna Church. I'm 19 years old and a resident of Sacramento and here with the party for socialism and liberation.
SPEAKER_01: The people of the city recognize what this board of directors are up to in these meetings, that the board wants to build large, low data centers in our area.
SPEAKER_01: Some stats from the city of Sacramento clearly show that historically hazardous facilities have been concentrated in black and brown communities and we have seen the consequences.
SPEAKER_01: Populations of Granite Park, the rail yards, Noralto, who have populations that have up to 64% of people of color report a decrease of life expectancy to 68 years.
SPEAKER_01: This being a direct result of exposure to toxic release, industrial activity and hazardous materials. This is a pattern of environmental racism and approving these developments without addressing these inequities, risks perpetuating the same cycle.
SPEAKER_01: Is the building of multiple data centers across the city happening for the benefit of the people of Sacramento? No.
SPEAKER_01: This is happening for billionaire profit while working people have to overwhelmingly foot the bill.
SPEAKER_01: AI data center expansions are at the core of big text corporations and billionaires consolidations of power and resources at the expense of everyday people.
SPEAKER_01: These AI data centers power flock cameras that are used by ICE agents to abduct our neighbors and serve as an example that this is connected to struggles happening across the country.
SPEAKER_01: Why would Sacramento residents want a data center that powers unchecked mass surveillance cameras to target and detain community members?
SPEAKER_01: SMUD has claimed that it values enhancing the quality of life of its customers and props themselves up as a promoter of environmental justice.
SPEAKER_01: But I asked the board, how does supporting the proliferation of data centers ensure this?
SPEAKER_01: Data centers consume enormous amounts of electricity and water, placing additional strain on our energy grid and water resources while increasing pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.
SPEAKER_01: These impacts disproportionately burden surrounding communities, raising serious concerns here about the priorities of SMUD.
SPEAKER_01: Is it environmental justice and public health, or are the needs of existing residents being sacrificed for corporate interests? Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you.
Unknown: OK, and now this is the last call for the speakers that signed in but haven't spoken.
SPEAKER_19: Desiree Moreno, Lorena Ramirez, Ibrahim Mutani, Faith De Guzman, Allison Hickox, Lina Sakub, and Amaris Clay.
SPEAKER_19: OK, I see no one coming forward, and so now we'll take questions and comments from board members. Does anybody want to speak?
Unknown: Board Member Sanborn.
Unknown: Thank you so much, and I want to thank everybody for coming and using democracy the way it's intended. Just tell us what you think, so thank you for that.
SPEAKER_46: I want to address the 2030 goal that was brought up several times. As a person, we all voted for the climate emergency resolution,
Unknown: and it was heartbreaking to say that we are not sure we can make it because of the administration policies and the grants that were pulled back and the permits that weren't given to us for our windmills and so forth.
SPEAKER_46: But I want you to know that we are still trying, so please know that, but we have hit a lot of headwinds.
SPEAKER_46: When it comes to this issue tonight, and it is related to the environment, we try really hard on reliability. That is our number one job to you, so make sure we can turn the power on.
Unknown: But we're trying to protect the climate, we're trying to do all these things at once. This particular situation, I feel like I have notes for pages from all of you.
SPEAKER_46: I had some of these ideas, but some of them were new too, and thank you for that. I am not ready at all to adopt this tonight. I feel that this needs some time.
Unknown: I would think the soonest I would probably be ready is February after some time to think about it, so I would encourage my colleagues to let's take our time and make sure we get this right, but I could wordsmith this.
SPEAKER_46: But it's already been three hours. I'm tired. This is not how I like to do things. So that would be what my ask would be, is that we delay this, we spend more time, and we think about, because I want to make sure that we've done, run all the traps and made sure we've got every tool that we have in our power used to make sure that our customers are protected.
SPEAKER_46: And I can't feel confident that I could do that tonight. So that is my request. And I do want to just say to the public, I have a house, second house in South Lake Tahoe, one of the things that happened up there was we were told we weren't going to have any power because the power was being diverted to a data center.
Unknown: And we had 13 months before they were going to pull it. And I still don't know where the power is coming from in Tahoe or how much we're going to have to pay. So I do hear I hear you. I just wanted you to know that. Thank you.
Unknown: Yes, director Fishman.
Unknown: Back in 1989, I was a journalist covering SMUD part time. And the board then was struggling with a huge public outcry to close Rancho Seco, the nuclear power plant that was the backbone of SMUD's power supply system at the time it was, it had a checkered past it ran it didn't run, there were some accidents and releases of radiation.
SPEAKER_23: It was the same design as the Three Mile Island. And the board could not agree on what to do. Obviously, none of us were on the board at that time. It was a much different board. And I'm not sure that staff really knew what to do at that point either. And eventually it came to avoid a vote of the people.
Unknown: And the people in 1989 voted to close down Rancho Seco. And it was a very difficult period for this institution for SMUD to go from having this 2000 megawatt source of power to having, well to not having that.
SPEAKER_23: I probably that was that was probably about our peak demand at that point. Maybe, maybe well more than our peak demand. And so given the laws that we must operate under and I listen we've we've heard every word that was said tonight, we understand you want a moratorium. We understand you want no new data centers. And we can't do that. We do not have the authority to do that.
Unknown: As an individual, one member of this board, I will get behind an effort to put this issue on the ballot and let the people of Sacramento County decide whether they want this or not.
Unknown: And SMUD obviously will abide by that the same way we abided by the loss of Rancho Seco. It wasn't easy back then. This will not probably not be as big a hit to SMUD in any way because it's just not that big of a factor for us at this point.
SPEAKER_23: But that's what I can do. And that's what I will do. I agree with the principles. And I think I'm torn between what director Sanborn has said about the need to understand the better the need to wordsmith this better the need to take some time to get this right.
SPEAKER_23: And the need to say, look, to our community, we want to take some steps that do protect the rest of our customers. And I've heard a lot of people say that this doesn't guarantee that protection.
SPEAKER_23: And maybe it needs to be a little bit more explicit, but I know that our staff and that our board understands what those principles mean. And it absolutely means you will not pay an extra dime because of some data center that may get approved.
Unknown: You will be protected not only from the costs associated with serving that load from the newest standpoint to the power supply that is required to serve that load over whatever period of time.
SPEAKER_23: There will be financial instruments that they have to abide by and agree to and sign on to in contracts. Maybe we require them to purchase power directly from another supplier. And all we do is deliver it.
SPEAKER_23: And then if they go belly up, then SMUD is not on the hook for that contract. The power supplier is. There are ways that we can facilitate that protection that absolutely protects you from a financial standpoint.
Unknown: And I believe that. And I believe these principles encompass that.
Unknown: Having said that, I would be happy to set it aside for a little while longer. Take some more time to flesh this out. But still give I think.
SPEAKER_23: I don't want to speak for anybody else on the board. I think our staff understands that we expect you to abide by the broadest brush strokes of this of these principles. We expect that already. We need to codify that.
Unknown: We need to put it either in some kind of principle or maybe in our strategic directives. We need to make sure that that it is not just understood that it is written.
Unknown: And so I'm torn a little bit between do we do that now or do we do that in a couple of months or whenever we've had a chance to really wordsmith this. Laura.
Unknown: Yeah, Laura Ingway CEO. I was just going to say that I know the board is really right now looking at what isn't what's within the realm of our responsibility as an organization. And really, I know when director Fishman and director Sam Bernard are speaking in the rest of the board members. It's really around.
SPEAKER_40: What are the actions that we can take as an organization? And so these principles are really meant to protect and I know it doesn't get to the protections that you're asking for. And that is what the cities and counties in the jurisdictions. If we were to get an application for service that is approved by the city and county.
SPEAKER_40: The intent is to have something in place to make sure that we protect the community from the from increased cost of our service because that is what we're responsible for. But I understand that that doesn't meet the needs and desires of this of the people here.
SPEAKER_40: I do think that we can wait until February. I'm okay with that because I do understand that we do have we do have rules and regulations in place today that do protect us that do protect our customers. And we do understand that these are the things that we need to do.
SPEAKER_40: These are the principles that you want us to act and negotiate behind. And so and I do we don't have an active approved project at this point in time.
Unknown: Thank you, Laura. A few more thoughts. As part of our continuing deliberations, can we look at the the impact of changing our definition of a large load to something less than 50?
Unknown: Maybe 25. I mean, what would the implications of that be? And can we also come up with a number that's a ceiling? So right now that says, look, at some point, we know that we cannot serve a load of X number of megawatts, whatever that whatever that that new large load might be.
Unknown: Can we include that in in these principles, just as a clear statement to the potential developers that if you're over that limit, don't even bother.
Unknown: And where would that limit be? Well, we'll take a look at that and get back to you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_23: And finally, I want to echo what director Sanborn said. Look, this isn't easy. This isn't fun. It isn't. It's messy and nobody's going to get everything they want tonight. Nobody's going to come away with with, you know, feeling great about this.
SPEAKER_23: But we've heard you. We've exercised our rights tonight. This is democracy and it's messiest ugliest, you know, most difficult best. And so thank you all for being here and participating.
Unknown: Thank you, director Fishman. Mr. President. Yeah. Thank you, chair. Herber.
SPEAKER_07: You know, I wanted us to adopt these policies just to make it clear to the public that we do take it seriously, that we're not going to allow the cost to be borne by the rest of our rate pairs.
SPEAKER_07: We're not going to allow.
Unknown: Us to be endangered by the potential stranded assets. And I do believe that there's a legitimate concern about, you know, a bubble and over investment and these companies coming in and making big promises.
SPEAKER_07: We're going to do this. We're going to increase your load. We're going to do all this stuff. And but please notice that we're talking about that any agreement would be structured.
SPEAKER_07: And these are instructions to how this do these agreements.
Unknown: So we understand that that's a significant concern to the public about not bearing the cost of these. And I also recognize that you're coming up, you know, you're coming to us with your concerns about the impacts on the community, on the environment, on the water supply, on public health.
SPEAKER_07: And I hear that. But we can't exercise our limited authority and do it in a way that, you know, we have a duty we've been given the authority to provide electricity to our region, to our service area.
Unknown: And that comes with strings under the law. And we can't just say, we're going to make it extra hard for this purpose. We have the right to say, you can't hurt our community financially, reliability wise, all those things.
Unknown: But we are very limited in how we can exercise that authority. And there's been a number of suggestions that, oh, yeah, we should play games with this. And I mean, you've already put it on the record that that's what you're asking for.
SPEAKER_07: And if we acted in that way in response to that, and it was really clear that we were putting up roadblocks, that would be a problem for us. And we would end up losing. We'd have to send and we might actually lose the leverage to come up with more favorable things.
SPEAKER_07: Now, we structured this in a way to protect our rate pairs and make sure that it's out there. This is what is expected of our staff, even though we've already told them that's what we need to do. They've already acted in that accordance.
SPEAKER_07: And none of these things, a number of people have said, well, there's not enough detail. The detail will be in the contracts.
Unknown: If it goes forward, the detail would be in the contracts that come forward for our eventual approval that would be publicly noticed and that you would have the opportunity to look at and say, does this really protect us?
Unknown: Now, I'm talking about these principles as if they're moving forward. I'm actually, I kind of like what what director Fishman said. Okay, if there's that much concern in the community, you know, in the in the cities in the county don't stop the development.
SPEAKER_07: And, you know, we can't do that. We can't say no to something that's permitted by them. But if the if the citizens of our region say no, and you have a you have a public vote and the vote is no, then that's something that we abide by.
SPEAKER_07: And I, I don't have an objection to doing that. I'm not sure that's the best way to do public policy. But if that's what people want to do, I would support putting it on the on the ballot as well.
SPEAKER_07: So, but please recognize we have to live within the legal authority that we have.
SPEAKER_07: You know, we've recently seen the effect of government just doing whatever the hell they want to do outside of the law. And we have to stick to doing this under the rule of law. And we have a set of laws that we have to abide by.
SPEAKER_07: And we can't just say, well, we don't like that. I mean, there's plenty of types of businesses in this community that I don't like.
Unknown: Right. And there's other people on the other other end of the spectrum. They don't like this other type of business.
Unknown: But that's not the role of the electric utility to decide we're going to exercise our control of the electricity system to limit your ability that is otherwise authorized by the land use authority and by the laws of the state of California.
Unknown: So I don't have a problem with with waiting on this. I have faith that that staff is is going to abide by the spirit of these in the meantime.
SPEAKER_07: I'm guessing that the cities and the county will have pressure to not approve things for a while anyway.
SPEAKER_07: So, you know, you may think that we're passing the buck, but we're just recognizing the limits of our authority and, you know, your calls for us to act outside of that.
SPEAKER_07: You know, I understand the reason you're doing it and you're making the arguments that that we really need to take a moral stand.
SPEAKER_07: But that's just not we're here to provide the electricity and we can do that, you know, and we can put forward these.
SPEAKER_07: We can adopt these principles to protect our rate pairs and to hopefully I mean, there are ways that we could.
SPEAKER_07: Make sure that these actually enhance our ability to move forward on our zero carbon. So, I mean, maybe we wouldn't be successful in doing that sort of thing, but.
SPEAKER_07: But I'm willing to I'm willing to set these aside and really actually consider some of the things we might be more explicit of.
SPEAKER_07: You know, and I think, you know, I would comment on a couple of people said that we should make sure that if there's a power shortage that those that the large large loads be curtailed first.
SPEAKER_07: I don't have a problem with that, you know, especially they're all going to put in their backup and and I will say that we don't have the authority to say what kind of backup they have.
SPEAKER_07: So that's more up to, you know, that's their business decision and that's also limited by the air quality district. We might have mechanisms to encourage one type of backup over another.
Unknown: But, and I think that that this is structured in a way that we can ask for that type of backup. I can't really give the technical details of how that might work, but that is the type of thing that we could have in agreements that.
Unknown: That would also help protect their environment. I certainly am not in favor of massive numbers of diesel generators that are very dirty and that have the potential of being misused when they're when they decide that that's more convenient or cheaper for them.
SPEAKER_07: So anyway, those are sort of my rambling thoughts on that. Thank you very much for taking the time to share your very obviously heartfelt concerns. I'm actually very concerned about some of these potential problems.
SPEAKER_07: I don't know that much about the noise aspects. I'm very curious about that. I live in the areas that you guys are talking about as well. So I have a personal interest in making sure that this is not harmful to our community, but I can't really exercise that control here as a SMUD board member.
SPEAKER_07: I can as a citizen of the county and of the city. So anyway, thanks for your patience and thanks for sticking it out through all of this. Thank you. President tomorrow, Director Rose to have some comments or questions.
Unknown: I'll make a couple of a couple of thoughts and comments.
Unknown: It's been a difficult evening for me and I apologize how my body reacted to some of the comments and actions tonight.
SPEAKER_09: And I think that's because I care about the community so much. SMUD is very much a labor of love.
SPEAKER_09: I have a regular full time job. This is all done after hours. And I think a lot of people Sacramento don't realize that we do get paid but but it's nothing like a full time job so it really is a labor of love to me.
SPEAKER_09: I wanted to just comment about the room arrangement we rearrange the room tonight to try to fit more people in from our standard committee meeting set up. What I don't care about though is it then puts us at the dais and the dais has the space.
SPEAKER_09: And that creates the sense of removal as a board member, right, like, I live in the community right like yes I stand for office.
SPEAKER_09: And, but I like it when we can have our normal arrangement we're much closer right as the point of tonight was to hear and have a discussion about this this issue what's going on.
SPEAKER_09: I've of course been reading and following this like everybody else, right.
SPEAKER_09: And I've done a tremendous amount of trying to make sure I understand these topics in the AI stuff is both fascinating this is, there's huge risk, but I also see people who are working with this stuff and it can do some amazing things.
SPEAKER_09: And I think we're trying to figure out these impacts right and we're trying to figure out and I, I was scratching my head a couple weeks ago said like, as like, how was that conferences less than five years ago we were talking about meeting our zero carbon goals and this was the Google was talking about meeting these
SPEAKER_09: zero carbon goals and I look, well you know though we got chat GP in November of 2022 means so right we were talking about, like, it will come up on the anniversary days we're talking about four years that we've gone from this doesn't exist to this.
SPEAKER_09: Which is fast and so I remember we're all trying to scramble and we're just trying to keep up with what's going on in the world and the reality and we know there's there's we know there's risks through those benefits and so I apologize if it takes all of us some time we're trying our best to get this right.
SPEAKER_09: And I know there's a lot of passion, and we read about some of these projects in other states, and they're talking about 1000 2000 megawatt mile long data center is especially in the south and we had a comment or come because of listening to this thing.
SPEAKER_09: And I think like, we have the data center in town I parked out in front we went to couture uses years ago and it was probably quiet but I thought well like there's places in the country where they have jet engines 30 jet engines powering them.
SPEAKER_09: And they're just open because of course you're going to hear that 10 miles away, right, certainly not the reality in California, and the protections in place but I definitely.
SPEAKER_09: You know we are in a different position being in in California and being in Sacramento than some of what we read in the news and the media so just sort of keep that in mind.
Unknown: And the other thing I want to point out right that there's a quote I wrote down earlier we're stepping back or step back from her 2030 plan.
SPEAKER_09: I just want to point out the business journal use that as a title of an article. And now bridge use that in their article citing it. If you read the business journal article that's not what was actually said by our CEO and the text of the article that was so I feel a little bit we're having words put into our mouth.
SPEAKER_09: We said back in April. Yeah we've had our cost God reels on her 2030 work. The others have mentioned why. And like the weaponization of trying to build these trying to build clean energy right not being able to get a permit from these federal agencies not being able to get a take permits and the real details.
SPEAKER_09: So I don't want the words put in my mouth that the integrated resource plan process is to investigate where we stand and what's the path forward.
Unknown: And so I think it's premature to say we're stepping back right I don't like that and somebody wrote 2030 words into the into the climate emergency declaration.
SPEAKER_09: This is very meaningful to me and the rest of the board members and we're definitely been to this country's politics are swinging back and forth.
SPEAKER_09: And right now it's not been friendly environment for certain things and I suspect that will change in the future as well and we're trying to be as nimble as possible. We also know and I said this in their last meeting right we need to be protective of our population who struggle to pay their utility bills.
SPEAKER_09: That's something that's always in the forefront of our mind and we're always trying to to balance that we all breathe we all we all breathe the air together.
SPEAKER_09: So I'm ramming a little bit. The only thing I wanted to point out is this board. We asked for an AI data center update about this time last year and we have the public the public meeting in a February timeframe.
SPEAKER_09: I remember was February because I was remote calling into it and we asked we said what we really don't have we have. Yeah we have some of these and we talked about that we have some of these basic protections already built into our policies.
SPEAKER_09: But we said look we really need more right. We see this this common and that's one of the reasons why this we've had this policy why we're talking about it tonight is trying to do this and.
SPEAKER_09: The conversation is definitely evolved right over the last six to twelve months and and we all see and we see it around the country we're having it tonight.
SPEAKER_09: This this furiousness. So just keep that in mind we this board are the ones asking hey we need more protections are the ones who are saying that and so I just want to be make sure people are aware of that.
SPEAKER_09: I was very concerned I went on a little mini round about business as usual a few weeks ago we shouldn't be doing business as usual part of that's because we read about the spark grant that our staff applied for which which I will admit I read I learned about it in the bridge article like everybody else.
SPEAKER_09: And I want to be clear you know like the staff should not be advocating for these data centers and that's why I say it's business as usual these people like oh well our job is to support the people coming and asking us right and that's when I want to make sure they're remembering you know don't just don't do the same things you always do.
SPEAKER_09: It is a bureaucracy we have to have thousand staff it is a is a live organization and I will say this that pertains to it is the confidential business information right like we don't go and talk about your utility your utility use why is just what which is why the same logic we don't do it for potential customers as well and I don't think anybody wants us to start putting a list of their utility.
Unknown: The utility uses on the Internet for God's sake right like that's your own private information I feel very strongly about privacy but but we're also balancing right what are our requirements and it's hard when.
SPEAKER_09: Right you have these big companies right.
SPEAKER_09: On the other side of the transaction and it makes it difficult does just keep that in mind I do we don't want us to talk about your your your data my data.
SPEAKER_09: And then the other thing is there's a lot of variability in size right smud's load is about 3000 megawatts at the peak of the summer.
SPEAKER_09: And that's where that one and a half percent came from a blowed right it's roughly 50 megawatts we talked about earlier but like.
Unknown: What was reported in the news was several hundred megawatts.
SPEAKER_09: Which is like size one and a half of a power plant so you know that's huge right and and the side of the Roseville comparison we heard tonight was also very accurate right there peak demand something like 378 something like that.
SPEAKER_09: But then some of them are much smaller right some of the five or 10 megawatts right most people didn't know that we do have these data centers in town already.
SPEAKER_09: I mean honestly they keep our phones working they do things that we do like.
SPEAKER_09: And so there's just a lot of variability it's not a one size fits all I feel like.
SPEAKER_09: So I just wanted to say that and we're sure not talking about the thousand 2000 megawatts right these are just the it's just boggling what's being done in the rest of the country.
SPEAKER_09: So anyway that's those are things I had a question this is probably more for Joe's or as our deputy legal counsel that there was some question about the ethics being brought up tonight.
SPEAKER_09: Is there could you maybe make a comment like we all do a for FPPC forum 700 that discloses your financial your financial disclosure as an elected official.
SPEAKER_09: Which I don't know if I'm not it's not mine right but do do board members need to recuse themselves from a policy because somebody who gets impacted from that may get it from a policy.
SPEAKER_09: No board members are allowed to adopt policies of general applicability and this is a policy of general applicability to anybody who would bring a load fourth of a particular size.
SPEAKER_41: If a contract came forward to the board and a board member owned money in the entity whose contract was being brought forward either we wouldn't be able to enter that contract at the board was getting a financial interest from it or the board member would have to recuse themselves but it would be a very fact intensive analysis.
SPEAKER_41: Okay perfect because I don't know any I don't know any individual stock personally.
SPEAKER_09: I think those are the main things my only other sort of calm my only question was really we heard a couple things about the principles on principle 3 and let me echo this I tend to agree with what we heard from director Sam board and I think we need more discussion about this although I'm not convinced.
SPEAKER_09: If you can come back to February people are still going to just straight up be opposed to data centers and so I definitely like the idea from director fish move of people pursuing a public vote option to give a much stronger signal to the actual authorities with their with the jurisdiction I tried to point that out earlier in the meeting but I guess with principle number three one thing I'd be curious to clarify is what is protect actually mean would be something I'd be talking about interesting.
SPEAKER_09: And then what we heard about in the public comment I think it was I think it was maybe David right.
SPEAKER_09: I'm principle number for backing a project that meets our zero carbon standard and then backup power and curtailment I know that certainly an active been an active discussion and I work in the transportation electrification space or I do I do battery and hydrogen trucks my specialty and how do you when you connect.
Unknown: Those projects efficiently so the certainly active policy I was sort of curious about that I definitely don't want to see like all this clean energy that we've been procuring.
SPEAKER_09: For like for the last five years just going to a data center right that's nothing that appeals to me and we worked very hard to try to get as much as clean energy as we can and so my what so the other question is is somebody brought up using a general agreement and so I wasn't quite sure what that potentially might look like and I don't know if there would be any.
SPEAKER_09: Maybe Joe there any thoughts or comments on is that a different as a general agreement would that be a different policy alternative these principles or like what we're talking about needing to do a custom agreement for these gigantic projects.
SPEAKER_09: I think it would probably off the cuff of my head it would play be infeasible to develop a general contract that would be applicable to any unknown configuration of different centers there also extremely different.
SPEAKER_41: The idea would be to negotiate things based on the board's principles and then bring them back to the board to see whether the board is satisfied that we achieve those principles and other things that were thought was important.
SPEAKER_41: Okay those are all of my comments and as many thoughts I'm sure things are missing and as always thank you everyone for spending your time and coming out and being engaged in active tonight.
SPEAKER_09: Thank you.
SPEAKER_09: Next I would like to ask if director Rob Kurth wants to make any comments.
SPEAKER_19: Thank you. Yeah I'm hoping you can hear me I did have my hand up and I was looking forward to it.
SPEAKER_24: You know first off thanks for everyone who joined us tonight to talk over this very important issue and we heard lots of great concerns and things that we need to think about as a community.
SPEAKER_24: But most of the dire concerns are really going to have to be decided at other governments.
SPEAKER_24: You're going to see these questions at the cities and the counties where they're considering this and it's all then it falls under the environmental impact reports of any large project like this.
SPEAKER_24: You know I think I have to admit I'm a little flattered that folks are asking us to decide who gets power and who doesn't but that is that was taken away that ability to decide who gets power was taken away from the utilities many many many years ago when frankly some shenanigans went on where political opponents you know many years ago.
SPEAKER_24: And so the legislature sought to take that take that decision away from electric utilities.
SPEAKER_24: It's you know that includes either directly refusing not to serve one someone or through subterfuge by artificially inflating prices dragging our feet all those sorts of things.
SPEAKER_24: You know the law is pretty clear we can't do any of that and if we tried some judge would get to decide what happened there instead and that may be much worse.
SPEAKER_24: You know a couple things about data centers I have to say some of the things I hear about and read about and studied up on in the country are just shockingly irresponsible to me.
Unknown: I can't imagine that an electric utility would do something like that.
SPEAKER_24: I have to say most of them are done by investor owned utilities not community owned utilities like smud but it's still just unbelievable to me that they would foist these sorts of nightmares on their communities that is not smud.
SPEAKER_24: One other thing you know the data center people.
SPEAKER_24: Yeah they are not standing still.
SPEAKER_24: There's a significant evolution going on in data centers. They're tending to get a little smaller.
SPEAKER_24: They're also not using water anymore.
SPEAKER_24: The latest generation of data centers don't use water at all.
SPEAKER_24: Everything is closed cycle and they just use air cooling.
SPEAKER_24: And so that and you know the air quality issue.
Unknown: Some of them are absolutely horrible but that's just not the kind of thing ever going to happen in California.
SPEAKER_24: The air quality air management districts would never allow that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_24: And so there's there's these nightmares out there that while you are so right to worry about would come home to roost here.
SPEAKER_24: But everybody's on guard about that and we're going to make sure that doesn't happen here.
SPEAKER_24: Yeah let's see one other one thought you know I'm.
SPEAKER_24: We asked for these policies to give guidance to the staff should a proposal come in.
SPEAKER_24: These were really all pulled together from existing policies so there's not really much new here.
SPEAKER_24: But having it all in one place sure makes it a lot easier to discuss and I heard some great ideas tonight for things we can do to expand them.
SPEAKER_24: Or sort of clarify them and so I'm happy to wait till we work them over a little bit more.
SPEAKER_24: Because these things are already in place and so we need to make sure that you know I don't want a data center application slipping in before we get back to this.
SPEAKER_24: That it's sort of unguided and I don't think that's concern at this time with that.
Unknown: The only other thing is you know always in public testimony people can get so angry and it's just not helpful if you find yourself getting really angry when it's time to testify.
SPEAKER_24: You're straining too hard to make your point and it's not going to work for you so just try to calm down a little bit think these things through.
Unknown: This is not an issue that's right in front of us today that has to be decided we've got time to work through this and make it right.
SPEAKER_24: And so with that thanks to everyone and I appreciate it very much.
SPEAKER_24: Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_24: Thank you.
SPEAKER_24: Thank you.
SPEAKER_24: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you.
SPEAKER_24: Thanks to everyone and I appreciate it very much.
Unknown: Thank you.
SPEAKER_19: President Tamayo you had another comment.
SPEAKER_07: Yeah.
SPEAKER_07: Sorry for taking a second bite at the apple.
SPEAKER_07: A number of people talked about things even beyond the local effects but just misuses and potential terrible things that that happen with a that are happening you know surveillance.
SPEAKER_07: Cybersecurity issues a number of other things I fully support regulating these things on a national basis.
SPEAKER_07: I'll be there with you.
SPEAKER_07: We're not going to do it by smud refusing to follow the law on and not providing these data centers power.
Unknown: They'll move somewhere else.
Unknown: It's a national issue.
Unknown: I agree with you.
SPEAKER_07: Those things need to be dealt with and stopped.
SPEAKER_07: So because they are a threat to our freedom and our security and our safety.
SPEAKER_07: So anyway thank you for bringing this up but you know I'll I'll support you on efforts to make changes at the state and federal level.
SPEAKER_07: To protect us from things like that.
SPEAKER_07: Thank you.
Unknown: Thank you President Tamayo.
Unknown: I also want to thank you all for coming tonight and expressing your opinions.
SPEAKER_19: I took lots of notes too because there were good ideas that came forward.
SPEAKER_19: I I do think that I'm not comfortable deciding on this tonight.
SPEAKER_19: There are too many things that are spinning around in my head that I need to think about and much of it comes from the things that I heard tonight.
SPEAKER_19: I did look at the principles.
SPEAKER_19: I tell you that what I really want to do is number one make sure I protect our customer base and number two if the city and county agree.
SPEAKER_19: That they're going to permit these data centers.
SPEAKER_19: I want to make sure there's some benefit to our customers.
SPEAKER_19: You know that already exists.
SPEAKER_19: There's been talk about having the large load customers drop load during the middle of the day when we need the energy.
SPEAKER_19: I totally support that and I would expect that to be in some kind of agreement.
SPEAKER_19: I would expect that we also would be able to protect our goal to be zero carbon by 2030 not have a large load customer come in and say well you know too bad I don't like green energy.
SPEAKER_19: I'm not going with that.
Unknown: We are going to be able to set the boundaries for these A.I. customers in receiving electricity if they're approved by the city and the county.
SPEAKER_19: I don't have any problem with having it go to a vote but just like President Tamayo I don't feel that I can not follow the law.
SPEAKER_19: So what do I do instead?
SPEAKER_19: Well I look at okay how do you know first of all is this project going to be approved by the city and the county.
SPEAKER_19: And if it does get approved then what kind of parameters does the SMUD board want to put on this.
SPEAKER_19: Again lots of good testimony tonight that I need to chew on a little bit.
SPEAKER_19: You know it's kind of ironic if the city or county doesn't act on a permit that is pretty much a moratorium.
SPEAKER_19: I wouldn't be you know surprised if we do see something like that.
SPEAKER_19: And if it is then essentially we will be part of that because we can't provide power to businesses that are not permitted.
Unknown: I also want to say that it's important that you know that you can come and talk to us about issues and we will do our best to meet your needs.
SPEAKER_19: You know this SMUD company or not for profit community owned utility has been around for a long time.
SPEAKER_19: And we've been around because we're cautious. We make good decisions about energy and we watch our dollars.
SPEAKER_19: So I am perfectly fine with having a little bit more time to think about this chew on this and discuss it later.
SPEAKER_19: But I do want to make sure you all know that we have heard you. We are concerned. We are responsive.
SPEAKER_19: We are here to make sure data centers don't cause problems for our community.
SPEAKER_19: And so with that if there's no objection I think that we'll go ahead and move this topic to another policy meeting where we can have further discussion.
Unknown: And so it's a quarter till 10 and so we're going on to item number two.
Unknown: And that is to discuss the election of officers for 2027 our president and vice president for the SMUD board of directors and I'll turn that over to our president to Maya.
Unknown: Well you know you're not all going to stay for item two. Wait a minute.
Unknown: All right. So you know we all know how this works. We have sort of a rotation that we've adopted informally. We're not obligated to it.
SPEAKER_07: Unfortunately the next person in line to be president is director Kurth. So I would nominate director Kurth to be our next next president.
SPEAKER_19: I'll second that.
SPEAKER_07: And unless I'm mistaken the person that follows him is director Bowie Thompson.
Unknown: And I would. Should I make this two separate motions or. OK. We'll do we'll do President Kurth and if if he fails then we'll we'll move Nancy up so.
Unknown: All right. So I'll move that we elect. Oh actually I can't move anything. This is a committee meeting right. So.
SPEAKER_07: I think we attend. OK. So that would be my intent to nominate director Kurth for.
SPEAKER_07: To be a president in our next calendar year and my intent would be to nominate or have somebody else nominate director Bowie Thompson to be our.
SPEAKER_07: Vice president for for next calendar year. And of course the rest of the board is welcome to make other suggestions.
SPEAKER_07: Does anybody else know. I think they'd be a great pair. OK. All right.
SPEAKER_19: If I can chime in especially after the events of tonight I'm looking forward to it. Thank you so much. I'm just an honor.
SPEAKER_24: So you you'll accept that. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. OK. All right.
SPEAKER_07: OK. Sorry. Thank you. Do we have any request to speak on item two from any of our virtual attendees. We do not. Oh darn. OK.
SPEAKER_19: I'm afraid my wife would call in. Yeah she'd call in and say she doesn't want you to be president. OK.
SPEAKER_19: Item number three is the annual review of standing committees and. I'm really not sure what this is.
SPEAKER_19: I apologize somebody just raised their hand. I'm sorry what. Let me just raise their hand. Oh virtual attend. Oh OK. We've got a hand. All right. Let's hear from them. Thomas wants to speak. Go ahead Thomas.
SPEAKER_41: Good evening lady. It's me again. So on the topic of then of the data center is it now going to be moved into the next calendar meeting in February as you all have stated.
Unknown: It looks like it will be then it appears it will be moved unclear exactly to when.
Unknown: OK. Well I just wanted to clarify that but either way I'm at least going to be staying on for the rest of this meeting to hear about what's going to be happening for them all. So so can we until then.
Unknown: OK. Thank you. Item number three is the annual review of standing committees.
SPEAKER_19: I am. Oh wow. Oh. I. Yeah. I mean I don't think I think we're all happy with the committees unless somebody feels differently. I think the board policy says review the committee's. Yeah I think that's all it is. Typically the board liaison will query who who's interested in which committee.
SPEAKER_08: I mean I would be thrilled if we could get him down to in one week and do three but I don't know if that's possible. I know I'm having a hard time especially on two Tuesdays in a row because a lot of local governments meet on Tuesdays and for me that's a work issue but.
Unknown: I think we should have a discussion later. Yeah. It's not 10 o'clock at night. Yeah exactly. Yeah. Yeah. I mean we're all here. Yeah. So move this to next.
Unknown: Next board meeting our next policy committee policy. Yeah. OK. Good idea. All right. Well do we have any folks who want to talk about this item on the virtual.
Unknown: I see no raised hands. OK.
Unknown: Item number four is the board work plan and we'll turn that over to President Tomayo.
Unknown: Well I'm not going to spend a lot of time on this so we've got our budget discussion coming up.
SPEAKER_07: One thing that's going to be really interesting is next week we will have a meeting with McGuire Whitney to talk about the what to look forward to at the federal level.
SPEAKER_07: Things seem to have changed a little bit over the last week and then.
SPEAKER_07: I'll just leave it at that. So could I make a request to put something on the agenda for a future meeting in brief conversations with Alberto Ayala from the air quality management district.
SPEAKER_23: He was asking and talking about linear generators as backup generation and he said that they have actually permitted one here in Sacramento County. I was unaware of that.
SPEAKER_23: I would love to get some kind of a briefing on linear generators and other kind of emerging technologies if there are any that sort of are at that point where they're reaching commercialization.
SPEAKER_23: And you know where are we with with those possibilities doesn't have to be long.
SPEAKER_23: I'm going to leave it up to staff if it's if it's a meeting agenda item terrific if it's a memo that's fine too.
SPEAKER_23: Okay. Director Sanborn you have a question. Yeah. We had talked for a long time about our land acknowledgment and we had an ad hoc and we we don't have that yet but I don't see it on your did I miss something.
Unknown: Actually we did meet with tribe talked about the statement and Frankie McDermott wanted to work on it just a little bit more so I really do see us coming back to us probably in January.
SPEAKER_19: I too am anxious to get this statement done. I was the one who suggested that we do it. So it's just taking a little bit longer but we'll get there.
SPEAKER_19: Let's put it on the parking lot. Chief Diversity Officer obviously with Frankie's retirement. I don't think he'll be coming back to work on that but I'll be stepping in as the executive supporting Emily Bocaini's team and we'll be coming back to the board.
SPEAKER_45: With an update on that. Yeah. Can we get a date. I mean this thing's been going on for years. We're making eye priority or at least put it in the parking lot. I don't want to forget it. Yeah. Let's put it in the parking lot. So we keep can do remind us to bug you about it. Sounds good.
SPEAKER_07: OK. Do we have any cards for folks who might want to talk about our calendar. I have received up. OK. Let's see. Just want to let folks. Oh. Are there any requests to speak on items not on the agenda. There are no.
SPEAKER_19: Sorry John just raised his hand. John the floor is yours.
SPEAKER_41: All right. This is John Weber. I would have said more earlier but I will provide the rest of my oral comments as a written comment. But last night I gave a comment about posting of the budget and I've searched the website all day today and I still don't see the budget posted.
SPEAKER_29: It was supposed to be posted today. Supposedly we only have till Friday for in quiet to ask inquires about the budget which I asked last night to be extended to the 20th. I request some staff person or somebody please send me to a link to the proposed budget and I asked the board to have inquires open till at least Friday the 20th. Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_29: Thank you John and we will make sure that staff get you the budget as soon as possible.
SPEAKER_19: Maybe it has happened but I'm on the website right now and it's posted currently. Oh it's posted on Smud's website.
SPEAKER_19: The standard the standard board page but I don't know they could have uploaded it tonight for all. Yeah. OK. But John take a take a refresher page as I see it posted.
SPEAKER_09: With the with both the board the book and the presentation. I am looking at the website right now and I find it nowhere.
SPEAKER_29: I'll email you I'll email you the links. All right. Thank you. I'll do it right now.
SPEAKER_09: Yep. I tried the smart search and the old search and neither give me the budget. They gave me the 2026 budget but not the 2027.
SPEAKER_29: So if we just got posted tonight I mean that's a big budget. So are we only giving people till Friday to comment.
SPEAKER_46: That's not much time. The budget actually gets approved in December. And so we're representing on it next week but it doesn't get approved by the board until December so they can actually comment in December. Right. But they. Yeah. So John I think you can comment a lot longer than.
SPEAKER_46: According to the presentation the employers on the budget were due by the 13th of this month. That's in smud's presentation. Yeah. Those dates are for inquiries for the board members. We brief them.
SPEAKER_57: That's from the October. That's for us to have queries based on the October. That was the pre the pre budget presentation. Yes. So it's a very good presentation.
SPEAKER_09: So like Laura had mentioned you have we are not coming to the board until December to approve the budget. So I'll review it next Tuesday. Plenty of time to get comments. Great. So you've got more time John and we look forward to your comments. Are there any other speakers for tonight on matters not on the agenda.
SPEAKER_19: There are no. OK. Then the last item on the agenda is to provide a summary of committee direction. Do we have any. I have that the large load principles we brought back at later date perhaps February standing committee review it'll be reviewed the next policy committee meeting and a briefing on linear generators as backup generation and other emerging technologies.
SPEAKER_41: Wonderful. OK. Well seeing no other business. This meeting is adjourned.
Unknown: Thank you.