Energy Resources  Customer Services Nov 18 2026
Ep. 73

Energy Resources Customer Services Nov 18 2026

•

Episode description

Energy Resources & Customer Services Committee meeting, held November 18, 2026 at 05:26 PM

Download transcript (.vtt)
0:00

Unknown: The

0:56

Unknown: The

9:06

Unknown: Thank you.

9:36

Unknown: Thank you.

10:06

Unknown: Thank you.

10:36

Unknown: Thank you.

11:06

Unknown: Thank you.

11:27

Unknown: Five seconds.

11:29

SPEAKER_03: Ready?

11:31

Unknown: Five seconds.

11:36

Unknown: Okay, good evening and welcome to the Energy Resources and Customer Services

11:41

SPEAKER_03: Committee and Special Board meeting of November 18th. This meeting is being

11:44

SPEAKER_03: recorded and can be accessed on Spud's website. Please remember to unmute your

11:48

SPEAKER_03: microphone and speaking in order that our virtual attendees lay here. The

11:51

SPEAKER_03: microphone will display a green indicator light when the mic is on. For

11:55

SPEAKER_03: members of the public attending in-person that wish to speak at this

11:57

SPEAKER_03: meeting, please fill out a speaker's request form located on the table

12:01

SPEAKER_03: outside of the room and hand it to security. Members of the public attending

12:04

SPEAKER_03: this meeting virtually that wish to provide verbal comments during the

12:07

SPEAKER_03: committee may do so by using the raise hand feature in zoom at the time public

12:12

SPEAKER_03: comment is called. Technical support staff will enable the audio for you when

12:15

SPEAKER_03: your name is announced during the public comment period. You may also submit

12:19

SPEAKER_03: written comments by emailing them to publiccomment at Spud.org. Written

12:23

SPEAKER_03: comments will not be read into the record but will provide the board

12:26

SPEAKER_03: electronically and placed into the record of the meeting if received within

12:29

SPEAKER_03: two hours after the meeting ends. Chief Legal Officer, please conduct the roll

12:33

SPEAKER_03: call. Dr. Sanborn, here. Director Fishman, here. Chair Buettomson, present. All

12:39

SPEAKER_06: committee members are present. Also present are directors. Herber, Rose and

12:44

SPEAKER_06: present Tamaya. Item number one in tonight's agenda is to discuss adopting

12:48

SPEAKER_03: the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, Mitigated Negative Declaration

12:52

SPEAKER_03: for the Pocket Substation Rebuild Project, adopting the Mitigation Monitoring and

12:57

SPEAKER_03: Reporting Program and improving the project. Our presenters, Emily Bakhinich,

13:00

SPEAKER_03: the Director of Safety, Environmental and Real Estate Services. Great. Thank you

13:06

SPEAKER_01: for that introduction. Again, I'm Emily Bakhinich. I'm the Director of Safety,

13:09

SPEAKER_01: Environmental and Real Estate Services here tonight to discuss adopting the

13:13

SPEAKER_01: CEQA document, the Mitigated Negative Declaration for the Pocket Substation

13:18

SPEAKER_01: Rebuild Project, along with adopting the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting

13:21

SPEAKER_01: Program and approving the project. So the project is construction of a new bulk

13:26

SPEAKER_01: substation. In this upper portion of the outlined area, we're planning to build a

13:32

SPEAKER_01: Meadowview substation. It would be on approximately 11 acres, and it's just

13:38

SPEAKER_01: north of our existing pocket substation, which you can kind of see here in the

13:42

SPEAKER_01: south. As part of the project, we will decommission that existing

13:47

SPEAKER_01: substation and remove all of the infrastructure. We'll also include

13:53

SPEAKER_01: construction of about a mile and a half of overhead or underground 69 kV lines

13:58

SPEAKER_01: that would lead from the substation along Garden Dale Way, which is the road

14:04

SPEAKER_01: that runs east-west, and then along 25th and 24th streets that run north and

14:10

SPEAKER_01: south between Florin Road and Meadowview Road. The project also, I'm sorry,

14:18

SPEAKER_01: construction is anticipated to begin in 2027, so next year, and then we expect

14:23

SPEAKER_01: decommissioning of the existing substation to wrap up in 2031. An initial

14:30

SPEAKER_01: study Mitigated Negative Declaration, or ISM&D, was the CEQA document done for

14:34

SPEAKER_01: this project. It found that all potentially significant impacts could be

14:39

SPEAKER_01: reduced to a less than significant level with mitigation measures for the five

14:43

SPEAKER_01: environmental resource areas listed on the slide here. The impacts are all

14:48

SPEAKER_01: construction related, and so we have our typical mitigation measures that we

14:53

SPEAKER_01: that we normally see for our construction projects. I do also want to

14:57

SPEAKER_01: point out the images here. The top image, the building on the right, is our

15:01

SPEAKER_01: existing control building at our pocket substation, and the area on the

15:07

SPEAKER_01: left shows the field or the parcel that the new substation will be built. The

15:12

SPEAKER_01: image below is a simulation, a visual simulation, showing what the new

15:18

SPEAKER_01: substation will look like. Our public review process started in August. On

15:25

SPEAKER_01: August 20th, we published our draft initial study Mitigated NIGDC, and we

15:29

SPEAKER_01: had a 30-day public comment period. The document was published online at

15:33

SPEAKER_01: smud.org and at the state clearinghouse, and we had hard copies of the document

15:38

SPEAKER_01: available at the customer service center and at our East Campus Operations

15:42

SPEAKER_01: Center. We also mailed notices to landowners and occupants that had that

15:49

SPEAKER_01: lived within 500 feet of the project along, and that that notice was also

15:54

SPEAKER_01: published in the Sacramento Bee. We had a public meeting in the community on

15:58

SPEAKER_01: September 3rd, and we had one member of the public attend. They had some

16:03

SPEAKER_01: questions about construction activities related to traffic and noise, and we're

16:07

SPEAKER_01: able to respond to their comments then. We also received one public comment

16:12

SPEAKER_01: letter from Caltrans, but that was just a form letter, and there was no response

16:16

SPEAKER_01: needed to that letter. The final initial study Mitigated NIGDC was published on

16:21

SPEAKER_01: November 6th and is also available online. Our tribal consultation process, we

16:28

SPEAKER_01: started, as we always do, reaching out to our four tribes that include the United

16:33

SPEAKER_01: Auburn Indian Community, the Wilton Rancheria, Shingle Springs Band of

16:39

SPEAKER_01: Miwok Indians, and the Ione Band of Miwok Indians. Wilton Rancheria requested

16:45

SPEAKER_01: consultation, and that started in late February. We met with them regularly

16:51

SPEAKER_01: throughout the consultation process and had meetings, phone call meetings with

16:58

SPEAKER_01: them.

17:12

Unknown: I'll keep going, and let me, yeah. So we were able to work with Wilton Rancheria

17:21

SPEAKER_01: on the AB 52 tribal consultation process. They did review our tribal culture

17:27

SPEAKER_01: resources section and our mitigation measures. The project site is located in

17:32

SPEAKER_01: a tribal cultural landscape, but we were able to agree on mitigation measures.

17:38

SPEAKER_01: There will be spot check monitoring during parts of construction that are

17:42

SPEAKER_01: deeper in in excavation areas, and we concluded consultation on October 22nd.

17:53

Unknown: And with that, I'd like to request the board consider adopting the CEQA

17:56

SPEAKER_01: document, adopt the mitigation monitoring and reporting program, and

18:00

SPEAKER_01: approve the project. Any comments? Heidi? Just two questions. One with the Wilton

18:11

SPEAKER_07: Rancheria, how are we, are they good? Do we feel consultation? They are very

18:18

SPEAKER_01: comfortable with the consultation process and the mitigation measures we

18:22

SPEAKER_01: have in this document. Excellent. And then you said that the big line would

18:27

SPEAKER_07: either be above ground or underground. This is a 69 kV line, so a sub

18:34

SPEAKER_01: transmission line. We haven't finished the design yet, so we're not sure whether

18:38

SPEAKER_01: portions will be above ground or below ground. If it's trench underground, it

18:45

SPEAKER_01: would just be the portion we think along Glendale Road, which is this

18:53

SPEAKER_01: east-west portion. And is there, I know people feel better and it looks better

19:00

SPEAKER_07: when it's underground, so is there a reason we would pick one or the other? Is it

19:06

SPEAKER_07: cost or? There's an existing line there, so it's already a part of the visual

19:13

SPEAKER_01: landscape. And from what I understand, it's due, it depends on the design

19:20

SPEAKER_01: requirements and I don't have the specific details on those. Okay, I just

19:26

SPEAKER_07: know that people like them underground if we can get them, so just noted. Thank

19:31

SPEAKER_07: you. Emily, a couple of questions real quick. Will we be able to reuse the

19:38

SPEAKER_10: building, the control building? Or is that gonna? We're planning to demolish

19:44

SPEAKER_01: that building. Okay. The section that's outlined in red that's greener than the

19:54

SPEAKER_10: rest of it, that little part that goes east-west, is that part of the

19:58

SPEAKER_10: substation? That is part of the property that we expect to build the substation

20:04

SPEAKER_01: on. We think that's where the detention basin could be located. Again, we're still

20:09

SPEAKER_01: working through the design. This is probably not yet in the purview of this

20:13

SPEAKER_10: project, but do we know what we'll do with the land that we, where the current

20:18

SPEAKER_10: substation is? We're planning to keep that property for now. We know that there

20:24

SPEAKER_01: will be a transmission pole located on that property and then there'll also be

20:29

SPEAKER_01: needed for staging and other resources. So I noticed that this is adjacent to

20:39

SPEAKER_02: the high school there, Luther Burbank. And so was the school district part of

20:45

SPEAKER_02: the notification and did they have any concerns on thinking in particular about

20:49

SPEAKER_02: our quality? They didn't provide a comment letter and they would have been

20:54

SPEAKER_01: notified because they're located within 500 feet of the project. Okay. And what

21:02

SPEAKER_02: are we doing as far as, well, one, before I ask about the air quality aspect, have we

21:09

SPEAKER_02: identified whether this is a clean site or not or is there any reason to suspect

21:16

SPEAKER_02: that there's some activity that might have contaminated the soil in the past?

21:20

SPEAKER_02: There's no reason to expect that the soil is contaminated. We would have had

21:24

SPEAKER_01: mitigation measures in the hazardous resource section if there were. Okay, and

21:28

SPEAKER_02: then also with the air quality, I'm guessing that's usually dust and then

21:36

SPEAKER_02: also construction equipment. What was the nature of that and how are we mitigating

21:41

SPEAKER_02: it so it's less than significant? So our impacts are low enough that we don't

21:48

SPEAKER_01: need to get an air quality permit for construction activities and so we're

21:52

SPEAKER_01: in kind of their standard suite of measures which include things like

21:55

SPEAKER_01: watering the soil a couple times a day. There's an equipment registry

22:01

SPEAKER_01: requirement, those types of things. Okay, thank you. You're welcome.

22:08

SPEAKER_09: So I was just looking at the street on Google Maps, right, and that 69 kV line

22:15

SPEAKER_09: comes right through residential neighborhood down to the main road and

22:19

SPEAKER_09: then tees off and so if it's at all possible to make a lot of since

22:23

SPEAKER_09: underground, I would be curious, not so much the EIR aspect, if we could get a

22:27

SPEAKER_09: memo explaining the potential costs of well how long that stretch of road is.

22:34

SPEAKER_09: I have no idea. Are they planning on trenching it already? If they're not, then

22:39

SPEAKER_09: it would be extremely expensive, wouldn't be realistic, but if there's some synergy

22:43

SPEAKER_09: there with other work, I would certainly be curious to have that thought process

22:46

SPEAKER_09: put in. That's something we could do. We can provide some more information on

22:50

SPEAKER_01: that process. And I don't rip talk, is that okay? Brandon, I think that's perfectly

22:57

SPEAKER_00: fine, thank you. You know, it goes without saying that people want overhead lines

23:04

SPEAKER_00: to be undergrounded and you know I would think that you'll probably hear from the

23:10

SPEAKER_00: neighbors as things get going and I think we do have money in our fund to

23:19

SPEAKER_00: underground lines so I'm thinking this is not the last of this. Thanks.

23:29

Unknown: Okay, thank you. Thank you. Okay, so that was our only discussion item. Do we have any

23:47

SPEAKER_03: cards? We have no public comment on that item. Okay, number two is the modern report

23:52

SPEAKER_03: for SD11, which is the public power business model. Steve Linds, our deputy general

23:57

SPEAKER_03: council will be presenting. Good evening, thank you. Once again, Steve Linds, deputy

24:03

SPEAKER_05: general council and director of affairs. Let's see if I get my keys going here. I'm here

24:09

SPEAKER_05: to discuss the SD11 monitoring report and recommend the board accept it. We are in compliance

24:14

SPEAKER_05: with SD11. And SD11 supports preservation of the public power business model and the local

24:21

SPEAKER_05: decision making that allows us to tailor solutions to meet the needs of our customers and communities.

24:26

SPEAKER_05: And before I touch on a couple of the issues, I'd like to just provide a brief update on the

24:30

SPEAKER_05: California legislative landscape and then I'm going to leave details of the federal update

24:35

SPEAKER_05: to Elizabeth Whitney and our next agenda item. And I know you're all aware we had a blue wave

24:40

SPEAKER_05: that swept the country and also ushered in the Bicetta administration in California. He and

24:46

SPEAKER_05: Democratic lawmakers are likely to enter 2027 feeling empowered to pursue aggressive policies

24:53

SPEAKER_05: and to continue to focus on affordability. The Democrats picked up two state Senate seats

25:00

Unknown: and eight assembly seats. And then locally, Senator Niellows survived a tight race and

25:07

SPEAKER_05: assembly member Hoover did not. Overall, and this is pretty amazing, 68 out of 80 assembly

25:14

SPEAKER_05: seats are Democrat and 32 out of 40 Senate seats are Democrat. And I'm told by my lobbyists

25:21

SPEAKER_05: that we haven't had that few Republican seats since 1876. And I don't even know what a Republican or

25:28

SPEAKER_05: Democrat was in 1876. Could have been completely opposite for all I know. But in your packet,

25:33

SPEAKER_05: we've provided you with a detailed SD11 report for your reference. In the interest of time,

25:38

SPEAKER_05: I'm going to focus on some of the highlights tonight. First couple of slides are legislative

25:43

SPEAKER_05: issue. First one is wildfire liability reform. SMUD was actively engaged along with other public

25:51

SPEAKER_05: owned utilities on the governor's end of session push to reform utility liability for wildfires.

25:57

SPEAKER_05: Governor's proposal included community resilience, utility accountability, insurance market reforms,

26:05

SPEAKER_05: and liability reforms that included capping recovery on non economic damages and barring

26:13

SPEAKER_05: insurers from subrogation recovery against wildfire fund, the wildfire fund or utilities.

26:21

SPEAKER_05: And however, at the end of the party, we had a three party proposal that ultimately came before

26:26

SPEAKER_05: the legislature and it was a far cry from the governor's proposal. It did not have or it did

26:33

SPEAKER_05: limit attorneys fees on only on subrogation claims. It blocked hedge fund hedge funds from

26:39

SPEAKER_05: buying wildfire claims and blocked attorneys from selling or using wildfire claims as collateral.

26:46

SPEAKER_05: It did also create a statewide fast pay system for fire victims. So the deal did not include

26:54

SPEAKER_05: elimination of subrogation claims, caps on attorneys fees, or limits on the types of damages

27:00

SPEAKER_05: recoverable from utilities. So many stakeholders describe the deal as inadequate and not meeting

27:06

SPEAKER_05: the moment. And at the end of the day, the speaker and the assembly decided not to move the bill

27:12

SPEAKER_05: forward. Instead, they organized a series of informational briefings to see if we can come

27:16

SPEAKER_05: up with a better plan. SMUD continues to engage and support a combination of measures that put

27:22

SPEAKER_05: brackets on liability and provide funding for victims through state backed resources. Next

27:32

SPEAKER_05: issue I'd like to talk about SB 868 was a bill by Senator Weiner. This bill exempts portable solar

27:38

SPEAKER_05: generation devices, also known as balcony solar, from all interconnection requirements, including

27:45

SPEAKER_05: publicly owned utility rules like SMUD. It also prohibits us from charging any fee related to

27:52

SPEAKER_05: them connecting the device. Utilities are, however, able to notify, require the customer to notify

28:01

SPEAKER_05: utility that they're using balcony solar through a simple online form. However, the devices must

28:08

SPEAKER_05: meet various requirements. For instance, they must meet the standards of the most recent version of

28:15

SPEAKER_05: the national electric code and the California electric code, which sounds great, but the most

28:21

SPEAKER_05: recent version of those codes doesn't really address balcony solar and isn't going to be

28:26

SPEAKER_05: revisited until 2029. So we're not quite sure how that's going to play out and how it's going to get

28:31

SPEAKER_05: implemented. But due to safety and operational concerns, primarily related to customer usage,

28:37

SPEAKER_05: things like back feeding and fire risk, SMUD and other utilities did have some concerns with the

28:43

SPEAKER_05: legislation and wanted to make sure that it was safe for customers and that they weren't having a

28:48

SPEAKER_05: problem with the installation. So while not addressing all of those concerns, there were some

28:53

SPEAKER_05: amendments that clarified the bill late in the session. Primarily, the biggest clarification was

28:59

SPEAKER_05: just making it clear that no matter how many units you have in your apartment, they can't total more

29:07

SPEAKER_05: than 1200 watts. So that bill was signed. It'll become law January 1st, 2027. Next. Go ahead, Rosanna.

29:16

SPEAKER_05: It's my understanding that SMUD is not happy about this type of equipment because it's not UL

29:28

SPEAKER_00: certified and that it can cause fire and depending on whether or not a circuit is overloaded. So I'm

29:41

SPEAKER_00: just struggling with how is SMUD facing this question and what will we be doing to make sure

29:50

SPEAKER_00: that our customers won't make a safety mistake because they're excited about solar. No, I appreciate

29:59

SPEAKER_05: that. And I wasn't personally directly involved, but I know that our SMUD teams has been meeting

30:05

SPEAKER_05: with folks to talk about balcony solar. I think some of our board members attended an event to talk

30:12

SPEAKER_05: about balcony solar and we're trying to do some outreach to help them figure out how to install

30:17

SPEAKER_05: them safely. But I'm not directly involved with that effort. So I could chime in Laura Lewis,

30:23

SPEAKER_06: Chief Legal and Government Affairs Officer. I believe we'd also talked about having some FAQs

30:27

SPEAKER_06: on our website to really inform customers about these facilities and about ensuring that they

30:34

SPEAKER_06: had the proper certifications and some educational materials on our website for our customers. I

30:40

SPEAKER_06: believe we were looking into doing that. My understanding is that the bill did require that

30:46

SPEAKER_07: these new panels have to be UL certified by a certain like January or next year or something

30:52

SPEAKER_07: or they can't be sold. Is that correct? That is correct. Yeah. But you may have customers

30:56

SPEAKER_06: buying things online on the internet and plugging them in. So we want to make sure they're aware of

31:01

SPEAKER_06: potential safety issues with that. And the other thing the bill did was require a whole separate

31:06

SPEAKER_07: plug. So I don't understand how it's even going to be useful because if you're a renter and you have

31:12

SPEAKER_07: a balcony who is paying for an electrician to come out and put a separate plug in to their rental

31:17

SPEAKER_07: unit, I don't see the, I mean, I was really excited about this bill until I learned that.

31:21

SPEAKER_07: And I know we're doing customer outreach to try to educate. Like I said, we're not clear on how to

31:28

SPEAKER_05: be implemented, but we're trying to reach out and educate and, you know, we want our customers to be

31:31

SPEAKER_05: safe. So we'll continue to do that. And hopefully this next iteration of those codes will clarify

31:36

SPEAKER_05: what they need to do to make them safe. Okay. Next bill I'd like to talk about SB 1425 by Senator

31:45

SPEAKER_05: Cortese. This bill provides the high speed rail authority or HSRA legal authorization to establish

31:54

SPEAKER_05: encroachment permit program for operations in the right of way. And the previous version of the

32:00

SPEAKER_05: bill actually prohibited entering their rights of way at all without a permit. You know, SMUD often

32:05

SPEAKER_05: has emergencies and we've got to go into rights of way to take care of our facilities. We don't have

32:10

SPEAKER_05: time to apply for and wait for approval of a permit before we go in to take care of things. So SMUD,

32:17

SPEAKER_05: LADWP, and CNUA met with several times with the author's staff and staff and relevant committees

32:24

SPEAKER_05: to let them know about our concerns about emergency access. And on August 13th, the bill

32:29

SPEAKER_05: was amended coming out of that committee with changes that pretty much addressed most of our

32:33

SPEAKER_05: concerns. That bill was signed and became will become law January 1st of next year.

32:41

Unknown: So next slide touches on some state regulatory issues and I'm going to

32:44

SPEAKER_05: warn you in advance, it's a little bit weedy, but these three issues were certainly the most

32:50

SPEAKER_05: consequential issues that we faced this year. So first, cap and invest, which previously was cap

32:56

SPEAKER_05: and trade. In January, the California Air Resources Board initiated a rulemaking to implement a new

33:03

SPEAKER_05: legislative direction that reauthorized cap and trade, now cap and invest, through 2045.

33:10

Unknown: CARB's January amendments also though removed a total of 118 million allowances from the program

33:18

SPEAKER_05: cap between 2027 and 2030. This was necessary to align the program with updated admissions data.

33:26

Unknown: At the same time, CARB proposed recalculating utility allowance allocations, which are the

33:33

SPEAKER_05: allowances that they give to the utilities like SMUD, to reflect the changes and the change in

33:37

SPEAKER_05: the data. As a result, SMUD would have lost about 25 percent of its allowance allocation and that

33:46

SPEAKER_05: would have between 2027 and 2030 and that would have cost would have lost between 75 million and

33:53

SPEAKER_05: 175 million dollars. So we obviously got involved with advocacy public with SMUD and public power

34:03

SPEAKER_05: utilities and CARB actually revised their allowance allocation calculation to more accurately fit our

34:10

SPEAKER_05: RPS requirements and what was actually happening on the ground. And while the final allowance

34:15

SPEAKER_05: allocation was still reduced, it was only reduced by five percent. This gave us enough allowances

34:24

SPEAKER_05: to still comply, number one, and also was a huge victory. This is our biggest win of the year

34:31

Unknown: because this went from a potential loss of 75 million to 175 million a year down to a potential

34:38

SPEAKER_05: loss of only 15 to 36 million dollars a year over those three years. So we think we'll have enough

34:44

SPEAKER_05: for compliance and as well we'll be able to use what's left over for greenhouse gas reducing

34:52

SPEAKER_05: projects that benefit our customers. So the rulemaking was approved by the administrative law

34:57

SPEAKER_05: judge on or administrative office of administrative law on august 31st took effect September 1st. Let me

35:04

SPEAKER_05: pause there for a sec. Remember you don't have to be an attorney to be administrative law judge.

35:09

SPEAKER_09: All you need is one year of hearing experience.

35:17

Unknown: Okay next advance clean. Okay go ahead. A real question. Sure. You may not know this is in the weeds

35:23

SPEAKER_09: but you're dangling it under my nose. There's 2.3 we have 2.3 million allowances on the slide there

35:29

SPEAKER_09: but we know our carbon emissions I think we're at 1.3 1.4 last year somewhere to that in 1.8 million.

35:37

SPEAKER_09: Why is our actual metric tons of emissions so much less than our allowances under the program?

35:43

Unknown: The short answer is early action but so the way the program was designed in the very beginning

35:48

SPEAKER_05: was they looked 10 years ahead and they based the cap and reduction of the cap over time based on

35:55

SPEAKER_05: your emissions at that time. Well SMUD took early action and we reduced our emissions faster than

36:00

SPEAKER_05: that glide path right out on the back so that's that's the short answer is early action. Okay

36:08

SPEAKER_05: where was it? Advanced clean fleets. So CARB initiated rulemaking September of 2025 to amend

36:13

SPEAKER_05: the advanced clean fleets regulation. As originally adopted it was supposed to apply to three market

36:20

SPEAKER_05: segments large commercial fleets public agency fleets and drayage trucks to transition medium

36:27

SPEAKER_05: and heavy duty vehicles to zero emission vehicles either through a purchasing requirement

36:32

SPEAKER_05: or fleet averaging. CARB was unable to secure a clean air act waiver from the administration

36:40

Unknown: and so could only enforce the rule against public fleets like SMUD. So they made some amendments

36:49

Unknown: and we're still subject to the regulation but following advocacy from SMUD

36:52

SPEAKER_05: they delayed the start date of full zero emission vehicle truck purchases from January 1,

37:00

SPEAKER_05: 2027 until 2030. Originally they were proposing that we were going to have to start buying 100%

37:08

SPEAKER_05: of our vehicles zero emission vehicles starting January 2027 and after we showed them that

37:16

SPEAKER_05: basically they weren't available and the costs were extremely high they pushed it out to 2030

37:21

Unknown: and as well they lost most of the market. Most of the market was the private fleets which were

37:26

SPEAKER_05: about 97% of the market and we were 7% of the market and so bottom line is we weren't market

37:31

SPEAKER_05: makers and weren't able to move the market in a direction that was going to make them

37:36

SPEAKER_05: cheaper or more available. So up until 2030 now you have a 50% zero emission purchase requirement.

37:44

Unknown: So this delay is a significant improvement but we're still challenged by the slow pace

37:50

Unknown: of development of these vehicles and the high costs and we're continuing to follow it

37:55

Unknown: and monitor it but they're just not moving at the speed that we think will need to

38:01

Unknown: completely turn our fleet to zero emission vehicles. They also proposed some exemptions

38:06

SPEAKER_05: but once again unfortunately the exemptions are not really workable because we would have to prove

38:12

SPEAKER_05: that every purchase we made in a calendar year could not have been a zero emission vehicle

38:18

Unknown: before we qualify for the exemption for one vehicle that we're trying to get. So but the

38:23

SPEAKER_05: bottom line is they put some exemptions in the regulation but they're really for all practical

38:28

SPEAKER_05: purposes something that we can't use because it's too difficult to prove that our entire remaining

38:33

SPEAKER_05: purchases during that year could not have been zero emission. And then at the last minute they

38:39

SPEAKER_05: dropped a little bit of a bomb with the regulation. They put out a set of amendments that would have

38:44

SPEAKER_05: significantly expanded the scope of the regulation. It would have made us responsible for our

38:51

SPEAKER_05: contractors vehicles. So our all of our veg management contractors and all of our other

38:58

SPEAKER_05: contractors we would have been responsible for their vehicles and making sure that they were

39:03

SPEAKER_05: zero emission vehicles. And we have no control over their purchases. So of course there was a

39:08

SPEAKER_05: bit of an outcry from everybody in the industry and I know that many of us participated in meetings

39:14

SPEAKER_05: with the executive director and the commissioners and just said there's no way that that can work.

39:19

SPEAKER_05: Long story short it actually paid off car perverse that position in their final rulemaking package.

39:25

SPEAKER_05: The package was approved by the office of administrative law on September 10th

39:29

Unknown: took immediate effect. So you know in 2030 we're going to face another round of regulation and

39:36

SPEAKER_05: you know we're not sure what that's going to look like. Finally on this slide draft. Just

39:41

SPEAKER_09: yeah and in the close to that in my day job it's an active policy discussion that seems to have

39:47

SPEAKER_09: retraction. So it will be an interesting discussion to see how that discussion plays out.

39:53

Unknown: I'll leave it at that. Yeah and how we move the market to get some vehicles available that can

39:57

SPEAKER_05: actually do what we need them to do for a price that's not four or five times you know the price

40:03

SPEAKER_05: of the ice. Well this this gets to maybe the federal discussion too but it seems like with

40:09

SPEAKER_07: the changes that just happened and new folks in there I know the administration's still there but

40:16

Unknown: maybe we could get some more support for getting things to market because we do want to go to

40:22

SPEAKER_07: zero emission and we've been talking about how we're a little frustrated how slow it's going

40:27

Unknown: but if they're not there to buy at an affordable price then we've got a problem. So I wonder if

40:33

SPEAKER_07: the federal Elizabeth maybe I don't know if there's any opportunity to speak to that when you come

40:39

SPEAKER_07: up but that that to me seems like an opportunity because we were putting a lot of money federally

40:44

SPEAKER_07: into this stuff. Yes. And incentives and grants would certainly help you know get us there.

40:50

SPEAKER_05: Finally wildfire general order under existing regulations SMUD and other utilities are required

40:57

SPEAKER_05: to either get a permit or waste discharge requirements from the state water resource

41:03

SPEAKER_05: control board or SWRCB when performing work that will discharge to a water of the state. In June of

41:12

SPEAKER_05: 2024 the SWRCB proposed a new utility general order to expand their oversight to utility

41:21

SPEAKER_05: maintenance activities including things like pole maintenance and vegetation management and this was

41:28

SPEAKER_05: regardless of whether or not there would actually be a discharge from that activity. Notably the

41:34

SPEAKER_05: definition of waters of the state included some kind of ephemeral water features like a vernal pool

41:41

SPEAKER_05: or even some roadside ditches and don't get me wrong SMUD completely supports SWRCB's focus on

41:47

SPEAKER_05: protecting water quality. So we got involved with an informal coalition to focus the scope on

41:55

SPEAKER_05: activities that would actually pose a tangible risk of water quality to water quality and balance

42:02

SPEAKER_05: the need for oversight with operational impacts. So SMUD and the coalition advocated for deferred

42:07

SPEAKER_05: implementation for a year following advocacy and engagement they made several improvements

42:14

SPEAKER_05: to the regulation. The first was they had started out requiring anything in a hundred foot buffer

42:20

Unknown: they cut that down to a 50 foot buffer. They even eliminated pole replacements in the buffer zone

42:26

SPEAKER_05: which was a help because we didn't think they were going to actually create a discharge to water

42:30

SPEAKER_05: by pulling out a pole and putting in the same size pole. They removed consultation and planning

42:36

SPEAKER_05: requirements for things that had a very low chance of discharge to waters and then finally they've

42:43

Unknown: proposed to defer the implementation for a year but even with all of these improvements and we

42:48

SPEAKER_05: did get several improvements we still estimate there's a thousand additional projects that are

42:56

SPEAKER_05: covered by the by the regulation and staff is estimating that's going to cost us about six

43:02

SPEAKER_05: million dollars a year for those projects. So they approved the order on October 20th,

43:08

SPEAKER_05: 2026 and they've given us a year until they're going to implement which is October 2027.

43:14

Unknown: See I'm sorry who's they again? The state water resource control board. Okay so that could be

43:21

SPEAKER_07: something we could lobby for now with the new administration and the new leadership right?

43:28

Unknown: Absolutely. Okay because I mean the affordability was clearly top of mind.

43:38

Unknown: Okay so this next slide covers just a couple federal updates. The federal energy

43:43

SPEAKER_05: regulatory commission issued an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking titled interconnection

43:50

SPEAKER_05: of large loads to the interstate transmission system. This was in response to a directive from

43:56

SPEAKER_05: the energy secretary Chris Wright to expand FERC authority for large loads connecting directly to

44:03

SPEAKER_05: the transmission system. This was a significant departure from historical jurisdictional boundaries

44:10

SPEAKER_05: and it basically would expand federal oversight into areas that were typically state and local.

44:17

SPEAKER_05: So FERC could end up impacting an interconnection of a large load like say in our service territory.

44:24

Unknown: SMUD contributed to comments with the LPPC the large public power council and the American public

44:29

SPEAKER_05: power authority basically challenging the scope and saying this is overreach these are issues that

44:34

SPEAKER_05: should be determined by local and state authorities. And then luckily on June 18th of

44:42

SPEAKER_05: 2026 FERC issued show cause orders but only to the regional transmission organizations

44:50

Unknown: and the ISOs like the California ISO directing each of them to either justify or reform their

44:58

SPEAKER_05: tariffs related to large load. Bottom line is this took us out of the regulation and so now it's up

45:05

SPEAKER_05: to the ISO to prove to FERC that it's doing what it needs to do to connect large load.

45:12

Unknown: Last I run this page GRIP grant and I know you've heard about the GRIP grant for quite a while now

45:17

SPEAKER_05: but I'd like to start with the good news which is in March of 2026 the Department of Energy

45:22

SPEAKER_05: offered to reinstate the full 50 million dollar grid resilience and innovation partnership grant

45:28

SPEAKER_05: for the connected clean power city project. And we've been talking about this for a while it has

45:33

SPEAKER_05: it has been a long and winding road to get this full reimbursement and I don't know if you recall

45:38

SPEAKER_05: I think I mentioned it last year but in October 2025 we first received notice of termination from

45:44

SPEAKER_05: the DOE of the grant and at that point we had been so quick getting the work done that we were

45:50

SPEAKER_05: already due 33 million of the 50 million dollars in reimbursement because we had completed it up

45:55

SPEAKER_05: to that point. And then in a broad SMUD effort we worked with our team, DC Council and our lobbyists

46:02

SPEAKER_05: to put together an informal dispute resolution that we filed with DOE in November of 2025 seeking

46:08

SPEAKER_05: full reimbursement of that 50 million dollar grant and it contained a really strong legal argument

46:14

Unknown: which I thought was about as strong as it could be concluding you don't have authority to terminate

46:18

SPEAKER_05: the grant you know under the terms of the grant. So there were several other back and forth with

46:23

SPEAKER_05: the DOE I'm not going to go into all the detail here but long story short as I said at the beginning

46:28

Unknown: in March of 26 we got final disposition reinstating the entire grant and now we're just waiting for

46:34

SPEAKER_05: approval of the updated documentation. And while I believe that it was our excellent legal arguments

46:40

Unknown: that led to this outcome I want to call out an unsung hero on the process and that is Trevor Lamb

46:46

SPEAKER_05: the project lead from IT because the lawyers including myself we were like ready to go to

46:51

SPEAKER_05: the next step in the legal process we're like man we got a strong case let's go let's go to the

46:56

SPEAKER_05: you know CFTC or the the court of federal claims and Trevor's like you guys I'm I'm talking to DOE

47:03

SPEAKER_05: staff and I'm making progress here it's like why don't we put off hold off on a big fight for now

47:08

Unknown: and you know long story short after several months of him going back and forth just cajoling staff

47:14

Unknown: we're well on our way to full reimbursement. So I think that Trevor has got a second career as a

47:19

SPEAKER_05: diplomat mediator or negotiator because he really it was and he was good too I mean in the face of

47:26

SPEAKER_05: all the lawyers saying let's go he's like no you like he held all the lawyers back saying wait a

47:31

SPEAKER_05: minute I'm making progress so big shout out to uh Trevor. Finally last slide yeah I think we need

47:39

SPEAKER_10: to play hardball until DOE we're only going to take that money if you make it 60 million.

47:43

SPEAKER_10: I thought um whatever the the DOE designation of that that series of grants is I thought I

47:53

SPEAKER_09: remember maybe like several months ago reading the the court that the government the federal

47:57

SPEAKER_09: government admitted it was the cancellations were strictly on partisan political grounds.

48:02

SPEAKER_09: Yeah that's right and there were several yeah yeah that's correct and there were several court

48:07

SPEAKER_05: cases that the administration lost and I think that also contributed and our our argument was

48:12

SPEAKER_05: along those same lines which is look under the terms of the grant you can't do this and likewise

48:18

SPEAKER_05: those cases we cited actually that what you're talking about in one of our briefs that we put

48:24

SPEAKER_05: together for the court of federal claims it never got filed but yeah they they admitted an open

48:28

SPEAKER_05: court that they terminated all the grants in blue states and none in the red states so.

48:33

Unknown: Okay last slide is just a quick update on western energy markets. The California ISO

48:39

SPEAKER_05: began the extended day head market implementation activities in 2024 and then this year May of 2026

48:46

SPEAKER_05: they launched EDAM with its first participant specific core and like the western EIM market

48:54

SPEAKER_05: EDAM would broaden the access to regional resources across this footprint to integrate

49:01

SPEAKER_05: renewable energy but only on a day ahead market the energy and balance market EIM is a 15 minute

49:08

SPEAKER_05: market with a five minute dispatch. EDAM takes that and stretches it out today ahead and maybe

49:15

SPEAKER_05: just one point on this map here as of right now all the blue shades are the folks that are

49:22

SPEAKER_05: have either stated or are leaning towards joining EDAM the the tan is that the tan do you guys

49:29

SPEAKER_05: tan or green shade on your side are folks that are have been talking about joining SPP plus and

49:37

SPEAKER_05: you know we'll see how that turns out depending on which direction BPA decides to go but SMUD along

49:44

Unknown: with bank participants we plan to join in fall of 2027 with SMUD and bank implementation activities

49:51

SPEAKER_05: well underway and the board might recall that you already approved SMUD's participation EDAM

49:57

SPEAKER_05: way back in August of 2023 so like EIM EDAM is voluntary remains a voluntary market so it gives

50:06

SPEAKER_05: us flexibility to jump in and if we find something better we can pivot and and go a different direction

50:13

SPEAKER_05: if we need to but one of the most important issues for this for stakeholders is independent

50:19

SPEAKER_05: governance across this footprint not California governance the west wide governance pathways

50:27

SPEAKER_05: initiative was created and a stakeholder committee was formed and then in 2024 the ISO gave the EIM

50:35

SPEAKER_05: EDAM governing body primary authority over the markets instead of joint authority as the first

50:41

SPEAKER_05: step and then the second step which is listed on the slide here is creation of an actual independent

50:47

SPEAKER_05: non-profit entity to be the regional organization and govern the market and then you may recall

50:56

SPEAKER_05: last year AB 825 it amended existing law to allow the ISO to participate in a market that was not

51:04

SPEAKER_05: governed by California so that effort is underway the in 2026 the regional organization for western

51:14

SPEAKER_05: energy secured initial funding obtained a certificate of incorporation and seated its

51:21

SPEAKER_05: inaugural board of directors and of note John Dostasio our own John Dostasio one of SMUD's former

51:29

SPEAKER_05: CEOs has been appointed as one of the five board members for that board that board is anticipated

51:36

SPEAKER_05: to take over EDM and EIM in January of 2028 and then final step on this is that services and

51:46

SPEAKER_05: functions will be expanded for that group as we move on you know once again SMUD supports this as

51:52

SPEAKER_05: an evolution of the market and it certainly lines up with our emission reduction goals

51:56

SPEAKER_05: John doesn't want to stay retired

52:03

Unknown: Steve does so does the the ROWE row does that constitute an actual RTO is that does it meet

52:10

SPEAKER_10: that description I don't think it actually is an RTO it's a RO it's a regional organization so it's

52:17

SPEAKER_05: kind of in between and I think you know step three as we continue to add functions and services

52:25

Unknown: we'll see how it goes I think some people think and maybe John Olson can correct me if I'm wrong

52:29

SPEAKER_05: but I think some people think that ultimately at some point it may become an RTO but it's not

52:35

SPEAKER_05: certain at this point John Olson chief integrated planning and market strategy officer yeah that

52:44

SPEAKER_08: RTO is a completely different that's BA consolidation that's transmission planning going all in together

52:51

SPEAKER_08: as Steve said it has a framework that it could potentially develop an RTO from it but I think

53:00

SPEAKER_08: that's a little bit down the road this is a really in my opinion it's a really happy place to

53:06

SPEAKER_08: to get to at the moment purgatory market purgatory all right well that's a lot in 20 minutes happy

53:14

SPEAKER_05: to answer any other questions or go ahead Dave yeah so on the map you you see you know pretty

53:20

SPEAKER_02: significant geography of of the west that's not participating in this so what is the

53:30

SPEAKER_02: downside of that what's what's the risk to us and risk to to row of these non participants

53:38

Unknown: well at a high level the risk is that these folks in the tan do join spp plus and you have a dual

53:45

SPEAKER_05: market instead of one market which is not as efficient and you end up having seams where those

53:51

SPEAKER_05: markets you know connect to each other and that just makes it less efficient so that's really the

53:58

SPEAKER_05: downside is that you don't get as much efficiency out of the markets as you could get if it was one

54:03

SPEAKER_05: big market across the entire western united states and you know right now bpa is reconsidering its

54:10

SPEAKER_05: decision about joining spp plus and depending on the way that goes that will be influential

54:17

SPEAKER_05: as to whether or not the others come over to edm or stay with spp plus

54:24

Unknown: so places like seattle or takoma they're kind of in the other because because of bpa or they're

54:32

SPEAKER_02: just sort of following that because they're in that territory well i think seattle's actually in

54:37

SPEAKER_05: edm right john lson again seattle would love to join edm but because of the electrical

54:45

SPEAKER_08: configuration they have a hard time getting out of the area so they're kind of beholden to bpa's

54:52

SPEAKER_08: decision and as steve said the beige area right now the default is they're in eim and so until

55:01

SPEAKER_08: markets plus goes live and it's not everybody would go live at the same time there's entities

55:08

SPEAKER_08: that will just kind of continue to just be in eim without going into a day ahead market so it's not

55:14

SPEAKER_08: that that entire beige area might flip and and go to markets plus it's just they're kind of in a

55:21

SPEAKER_08: different state as steve pointed out accurately bpa decision by the end of the year here will make

55:27

SPEAKER_08: a big difference in directionality of of entities of where they would go but to go touch back to

55:33

SPEAKER_08: your initial question because i think you're you're spot on you know we've enjoyed a lot of benefit

55:38

SPEAKER_08: smud ratepayers have enjoyed a lot of benefit economically reliability wise and and also for

55:44

SPEAKER_08: renewable integration over being involved in eim that footprint that is eim is about 80 percent of

55:51

SPEAKER_08: the load in the western interconnect so it's not a small number and so as you split that up

55:58

Unknown: there's going to be less benefits to for everybody so it does make the as steve said some of those

56:04

SPEAKER_08: benefits go down so i think there is a risk that we could see some of those benefits erode if

56:10

SPEAKER_08: enough if if enough people join a different market um not all but some okay and do you think that

56:21

SPEAKER_02: the the sort of underlying reason is they're just waiting to see how it goes or is it just

56:30

SPEAKER_02: they're just early in their process of deciding or who is they in this case the ones that have not

56:37

SPEAKER_02: committed to eim um or am i misreading what what this might be well no i don't know if they're

56:47

SPEAKER_08: necessarily waiting there are some that are waiting bpa is is trying to decide what they do

56:51

SPEAKER_08: but there are entities that are struggling with that did did the row that steve talked about did

56:58

SPEAKER_08: it go far enough to sever that governance uh away from the kaizo because the kaizo is still going

57:04

SPEAKER_08: to administer the market on a contract basis so some people probably for some real and some that

57:11

SPEAKER_08: under things i don't understand of in their argument um

57:16

SPEAKER_08: could be a little bit of anything but california things like that

57:24

Unknown: okay anything else all right thank you

57:30

Unknown: okay do we have any cards on this item i do not see any public comment no okay item number three is to

57:46

SPEAKER_03: provide the board with an informational briefing on federal legislative activities Elizabeth Whitney

57:52

SPEAKER_03: from McGuire Whitney will be here to present hello thank you so much i am Elizabeth Whitney

58:01

SPEAKER_04: managing principal at McGuire Whitney and it's my distinct privilege to represent SMUD in Washington

58:08

SPEAKER_04: DC um just on a personal note uh we're celebrating 10 years as McGuire Whitney this year and um i

58:16

SPEAKER_04: would be remiss not to recognize the role that my colleague Larry Long played in encouraging me to

58:22

SPEAKER_04: start my own company about 10 years ago um it meant a great deal to me as does our continued

58:28

SPEAKER_04: partnership so really excited to be here today and to be celebrating that milestone um and we

58:34

SPEAKER_04: have exciting things to report on this year um it's an election year as you may have heard i

58:39

SPEAKER_04: i heard some of the candidates were sending out texts for money can you believe that um but uh

58:45

SPEAKER_04: you know in in case you didn't know uh what an election year means for us in Washington DC

58:50

SPEAKER_04: is that we have a lot of conversations about stuff and then do everything in the lame duck

58:55

SPEAKER_04: session which is happening right now um so i have a number of things to update you on some of which

59:01

SPEAKER_04: Steve touched on uh some of which i'll go into more or less detail on uh happy to answer any

59:06

SPEAKER_04: questions about any of those but we'll talk a little bit about what all this means for the

59:12

SPEAKER_04: future which is the the interesting part for me um so uh with that i'll uh let's get to it um so

59:20

SPEAKER_04: the the thing that we've been spending most of our time talking about this year is permitting reform

59:26

SPEAKER_04: you might recall that at the end of last year the house passed a bill that would reform the way the

59:31

SPEAKER_04: federal government addresses uh projects and approves projects under the national environmental

59:37

SPEAKER_04: policy act NEPA um towards the end of that debate there started to be a lot more conversation about

59:44

SPEAKER_04: whether or not the administration would faithfully execute permitting reform with respect to all

59:49

SPEAKER_04: resource types because they had started withholding permits for wind and solar projects canceling

59:55

SPEAKER_04: permits for particularly offshore wind projects that were very close to completion and basically

1:00:02

SPEAKER_04: kind of making life very difficult for the type of resources and projects that they did not want to

1:00:07

SPEAKER_04: permit um and so that conversation started to come about at the end of last year and really

1:00:14

SPEAKER_04: colored a lot of the conversations that the senate had about permitting reform this year so we

1:00:20

SPEAKER_04: expected that the senate would address more than just NEPA when they took up permitting reform

1:00:26

SPEAKER_04: unfortunately there were a lot of fits and starts with those negotiations because of the ongoing

1:00:33

SPEAKER_04: sort of mistrust and conflict with what the administration was actually doing with respect to

1:00:39

SPEAKER_04: the permits that it was issuing or not issuing or canceling and we didn't see the legislative text

1:00:46

SPEAKER_04: of this bill the senate proposal until September 30th which is very late in the process to try and

1:00:52

SPEAKER_04: polish up all the rough edges of a big piece of legislation so that it's ready and good policy to

1:00:58

SPEAKER_04: drop in at the end of the year in the lame duck session which is where we're at now so we spent a

1:01:05

SPEAKER_04: lot of the last month taking a look at what the senate had put together and what they did uh based

1:01:12

SPEAKER_04: on how the jurisdiction over energy and environment issues is handled in the senate is they had a

1:01:18

SPEAKER_04: division a that looked a lot like a great version of the house bill so it had a lot of streamlining

1:01:26

SPEAKER_04: NEPA basically getting the the structural and and ornamental provisions out of the way of NEPA

1:01:38

SPEAKER_04: so that a decision could be reached faster and could be relied upon by applicants so narrowing

1:01:45

SPEAKER_04: the scope reducing duplicative reviews and and and narrowing what agencies are actually looking

1:01:54

SPEAKER_04: at so that it's not the entire universe of possibilities it's a measurable predictable

1:02:00

SPEAKER_04: amount of paperwork so that they can move through these processes faster and more efficiently to get

1:02:07

SPEAKER_04: to an end decision it also included similar changes conforming some other statutes like

1:02:14

SPEAKER_04: the clean water act and endangered species act and sort of harmonizing those with what they have done

1:02:19

SPEAKER_04: underneath but also streamlining some of the stickier wickets in those resource statutes trying

1:02:26

SPEAKER_04: not to remove any of the environmental protections but getting some of the of the underbrush out of

1:02:33

SPEAKER_04: the way so that they could function as they were originally intended it also included a permit

1:02:38

SPEAKER_04: certainty provision that creates new rights of action for applicants to sue the federal government

1:02:44

SPEAKER_04: if they think a permit has been revoked or withheld based on a pattern of disparate

1:02:50

SPEAKER_04: treatment for a particular type of resource so division a looked pretty familiar division b is

1:02:57

SPEAKER_04: a pretty significant departure from that focus on internal governmental processes and reaches very

1:03:03

SPEAKER_04: much into utility operations and how we address transmission in this country so we had seen this

1:03:14

SPEAKER_04: type of policy before we didn't know that it would be included in permitting reform but it looks a

1:03:19

SPEAKER_04: lot like the energy permitting reform act of last congress something that chairman mansion and

1:03:24

SPEAKER_04: ranking member barasso negotiated that didn't quite get across the finish line you might remember

1:03:29

SPEAKER_04: that we had some concerns with those transmission provisions there's really two planks one is

1:03:36

SPEAKER_04: transmission permitting the idea here is to strengthen firk's backstop citing authority

1:03:44

SPEAKER_04: so that for certain types of lines it has the ability to go around states that either delay

1:03:50

SPEAKER_04: or deny permitting requests in corridors that have a national interest in building transmission

1:03:57

SPEAKER_04: allowing for to either go around those states and not having to previously get that corridor

1:04:07

SPEAKER_04: designated by the department of energy as a national interest theoretically would allow

1:04:12

SPEAKER_04: transmission to be permitted faster and more efficiently the second plank is transmission

1:04:18

SPEAKER_04: planning which would require regions to get together and figure out which transmission lines

1:04:25

SPEAKER_04: actually need to be built and how they're they're going to go about doing that the problem with both

1:04:30

SPEAKER_04: of these planks is while they might get transmission built faster they would also have the inconvenient

1:04:36

SPEAKER_04: side effect of bringing public power systems under firk jurisdiction and submitting us to

1:04:41

SPEAKER_04: cost allocation for transmission lines that we neither approved nor benefit from in a pretty

1:04:49

SPEAKER_04: substantial win appa and lppc and smud and all of the public power systems working together

1:05:00

SPEAKER_04: successfully secured an exemption within the bill for public power and co-ops so a huge win

1:05:07

SPEAKER_04: to be exempted from those provisions and the transmission planning provisions really only

1:05:11

SPEAKER_04: applying to rto regions so pretty substantial wins for us really knocking down two of the biggest

1:05:17

SPEAKER_04: objections we would have had to this bill now there are still some other smaller provisions

1:05:23

SPEAKER_04: that ended up getting dropped into this bill that had never gotten a hearing we had never seen before

1:05:29

SPEAKER_04: that may or may not be good policy related to large loads and advanced transmission technologies

1:05:35

SPEAKER_04: folks have been working to kind of refine these around the edges but i do anticipate that there

1:05:40

SPEAKER_04: could be some unintended consequences with some of these provisions just by virtue of the fact

1:05:45

SPEAKER_04: that this bill has been written rather hastily and did not really have the the full vetting

1:05:52

SPEAKER_04: that we would expect from a piece of legislation of this magnitude so i won't go into that fully

1:05:58

SPEAKER_04: here today but i'm happy to answer questions about this if folks really want to go into the details

1:06:05

Unknown: the senate is voting on this bill right now i expect it to narrowly pass in the senate the

1:06:13

SPEAKER_04: house is a bit of a different story as i've just laid out they passed something that looks like

1:06:17

SPEAKER_04: division a the senate added a lot in division b that the house has had so much as one hearing on

1:06:26

SPEAKER_04: and hadn't seen this language or been involved in negotiating it so i think that this bill will

1:06:31

SPEAKER_04: face a steeper climb in the house i think it could probably only pass on a bipartisan basis

1:06:39

SPEAKER_04: i don't think a lot of democrats have much incentive to pass anything like this

1:06:47

SPEAKER_04: but a lot of folks are taking the case that hey this is a pretty good bill on balance

1:06:52

Unknown: don't really think you're going to want to start over from scratch in the new congress and and put

1:06:57

SPEAKER_04: something together let's take the deal that's in front of us we'll see within the next couple of

1:07:02

SPEAKER_04: weeks whether those arguments find purchase so everybody's favorite issue here do you want

1:07:09

Unknown: to ask any questions about that yeah let's dive into that one a tiny bit more sure we go on um

1:07:15

SPEAKER_09: because i've heard a little bit of concern expressed from environmentalists more than a

1:07:20

SPEAKER_09: little yeah about the status of i had no idea what division a or division b but i know

1:07:26

Unknown: and especially our experience right you see like how to say it like delicately with the endangered

1:07:33

SPEAKER_09: species act yeah there's rooms for reform where needed right species are reintroduced

1:07:39

SPEAKER_09: and the populations are at points where they need to be managed but then you also see abuses

1:07:44

SPEAKER_09: i.e like somebody um i won't say it but um how do we balance that as as you know as we're right

1:07:53

SPEAKER_09: uh we represent a different viewpoint than say maybe a pou in a different part of the country

1:08:00

Unknown: yeah so one of the things that raises some consternation about this bill among environmental

1:08:06

SPEAKER_04: groups is that it really dramatically reduces the ability of outside groups to sue the federal

1:08:14

SPEAKER_04: government over nipa and to get a project stalled or or canceled that way and there are a number of

1:08:20

SPEAKER_04: groups that have built a business model basically around preventing bad projects from going through

1:08:28

SPEAKER_04: based on the procedural statutes that underpin nipa so i think some of them are concerned that

1:08:36

SPEAKER_04: without that pathway to stop uh projects that will will pollute they won't have as much of an

1:08:45

SPEAKER_04: ability to interact with the projects that way i've also heard a lot of concern about tribal

1:08:52

SPEAKER_04: consultations with this bill and i know there have been some changes in the manager's amendment to

1:08:58

SPEAKER_04: try and address that incredibly important to a lot of of senators that that tribal authorities don't

1:09:06

SPEAKER_04: lose ground in the in the process of going through this so each senator has to make their

1:09:12

SPEAKER_04: own decision as to whether or not it strikes the right balance and we see senators on both sides

1:09:19

SPEAKER_04: of the aisle coming to different conclusions not necessarily along party lines but based on whether

1:09:26

SPEAKER_04: they think that balance is correctly struck in this bill i think from smud's perspective and

1:09:32

SPEAKER_04: most folks that are building projects on balance this bill is a step in the right direction for

1:09:38

SPEAKER_04: making sure that things can get built while still retaining some authority for folks to raise their

1:09:44

SPEAKER_04: hand and say hey this is going to have some pretty significant environmental impacts while not allowing

1:09:49

SPEAKER_04: them to raise their hand on every project every time or multiple times in ways that simply delay

1:09:56

SPEAKER_04: a project or drive up the cost through litigation do we have um is there a position that smud has

1:10:06

SPEAKER_09: expressed at this point and and is there a general appa position that that's that's being brought

1:10:12

SPEAKER_09: forth so smud has supported permitting reform broadly when the original text came out we took

1:10:21

SPEAKER_04: a look and suggested to our senate delegation that on balance we think this is a positive bill

1:10:27

SPEAKER_04: we did request two um small changes one was to ensure that the public power exemption from the

1:10:35

SPEAKER_04: transmission provisions was pretty iron clad so as it was originally written it would have

1:10:41

SPEAKER_04: most likely included smud but not bank um so we wanted the definition of who's a public power

1:10:48

SPEAKER_04: entity to be as inclusive as possible and we also wanted to make sure that if we were going to be

1:10:56

SPEAKER_04: pulled into a transmission planning regime that it was clear if we opted out of that that we were

1:11:01

SPEAKER_04: opting out of cost allocation as well there would be no point to opt out of planning um except to

1:11:08

SPEAKER_04: escape the cost allocation provisions so ultimately both of those issues were resolved um so appa

1:11:15

SPEAKER_04: really focused in on the public power exemption that was their only ask and both appa and uh the

1:11:22

SPEAKER_04: rural electric co-ops have endorsed the bill okay thank you for that i know like especially with

1:11:27

SPEAKER_09: our wind plan right it took seven years seven years of permitting in like six months to build

1:11:33

SPEAKER_09: yeah things like that so yeah those are the kind of challenges and stories that we've been telling

1:11:38

SPEAKER_04: for several years um and you know a lot of projects spend even more time in that just in litigation

1:11:48

SPEAKER_04: over the procedural statutes because they create so many opportunities for a challenge and back and

1:11:56

SPEAKER_04: forth that really aren't about the substantive merits of the bill so much or the the project

1:12:01

SPEAKER_04: so much as whether or not the agency followed the correct procedure

1:12:07

Unknown: yeah um i'm not sure if this is a question for you or maybe from our local environmental folks

1:12:15

Unknown: it's sort of been my understanding that because sequa is so much more restrictive in so many

1:12:20

SPEAKER_10: ways than nipa that nipa reforms while you know maybe providing some benefit don't really do us

1:12:27

SPEAKER_10: they don't really impact us that much is is that still the case or was that ever the case is that

1:12:33

SPEAKER_10: is that i've heard things to that effect as well um there is a provision in the bill that clarifies

1:12:40

SPEAKER_04: that if you go through a more restrictive state process then you don't also have to go through

1:12:44

SPEAKER_04: nipa that's helpful um nipa uh with so many different statutes and so many different layers

1:12:54

SPEAKER_04: um this is a step in the right direction it's not a panacea so you still have to comply with

1:13:01

SPEAKER_04: individual you know permitting processes nipa is this sort of big umbrella that because it's so

1:13:08

SPEAKER_04: procedural and so difficult to get right almost impossible to get right on the first pass if

1:13:13

SPEAKER_04: anybody wants to challenge it um that i think this is certainly a step in the right direction but

1:13:18

SPEAKER_04: it's by no means like a free pass to develop whatever you want and and just assume that your

1:13:23

SPEAKER_04: permits are going to fall into line unfortunately so anything else on permitting reform

1:13:31

Unknown: so steve talked a little bit about the large load policies that took place at firk this year

1:13:37

SPEAKER_04: another huge win for public power um considering that the initial proposal was to adopt a nationwide

1:13:45

SPEAKER_04: one size fits all direct large load interconnection to the transmission system would have caused

1:13:52

SPEAKER_04: serious problems jurisdictionally but also operationally um the show cause orders in my

1:13:59

SPEAKER_04: opinion were a particularly elegant way for firk to dispense with what the energy secretary had

1:14:04

SPEAKER_04: sent over um while still hewing closely to what their actual jurisdiction was so they set forth

1:14:12

SPEAKER_04: these show cause orders that focus on the rto's where they do have jurisdiction set forth a lot

1:14:18

SPEAKER_04: of compelling principles and really pointed to the large load uh framework that spp had put

1:14:25

SPEAKER_04: together what they call hills or hillga or sometimes chills based on the type of large

1:14:31

SPEAKER_04: load policy uh uh interconnection that they're working on that really addressed a number of the

1:14:38

SPEAKER_04: particular issues that are common to a lot of these large loads trying to internet interconnect

1:14:44

SPEAKER_04: to the transmission system that deals with the transmission side of the house what still isn't

1:14:52

SPEAKER_04: fully addressed is what happens when a large load seeks to connect into a system that simply

1:14:58

SPEAKER_04: doesn't have enough generation to serve it so as firk was grappling with the transmission piece of

1:15:05

SPEAKER_04: this question the public sentiment really shifted and the administration policy shifted from speed

1:15:12

SPEAKER_04: to power how can we connect these facilities as quickly and cheaply as possible to whoa how can

1:15:19

SPEAKER_04: we protect consumers from some of the impacts that these large loads have on the on the underlying

1:15:24

SPEAKER_04: system so we saw that play out in real time um at at the national policy level this year and the

1:15:32

SPEAKER_04: administration solution the rate pair protection pledge um is in some ways a a stroke of genius

1:15:40

SPEAKER_04: and in other ways far short of what is needed to actually protect rate payers so the pledge

1:15:47

Unknown: is a voluntary commitment that hyperscalers will bring by or build their own new or additive

1:15:53

SPEAKER_04: generation to serve the load that they cause it's a incomplete solution it is non-binding in nature

1:16:01

SPEAKER_04: but it also uses the bully pulpit to put hyperscalers on notice that they're not going to be

1:16:07

SPEAKER_04: able to simply plug into a grid that can't support them and because they largely had been

1:16:14

SPEAKER_04: doing that in markets like pjm which have a capacity market that allows folks to plug into

1:16:22

SPEAKER_04: a grid that may or may not be able to serve them and just by some magic of the economist's wand

1:16:29

Unknown: that demand will translate into supply that system that underlying system was really um

1:16:37

SPEAKER_04: exposed as completely inadequate so what happens instead is that folks need to think about how

1:16:44

SPEAKER_04: they deal with these new types of customers in ways that are more protective of the underlying

1:16:51

SPEAKER_04: customer base i know this is something that smud is working on right now um i'll talk a little bit

1:16:57

SPEAKER_04: more about that but please know that you're not alone that every utility in the country is trying

1:17:02

SPEAKER_04: to figure out what is the secret sauce for dealing with these very very different type of customers

1:17:09

Unknown: that present novel challenges and and up end a lot of the underlying policy frameworks that we've

1:17:17

SPEAKER_04: used for decades in the energy industry um that worked relatively well under a different regime

1:17:24

SPEAKER_04: now don't work at all um the capacity market being you know a prime example of that

1:17:32

SPEAKER_04: so congress is still trying to find its footing as well um what it has put forward and a bill

1:17:40

SPEAKER_04: that passed the house uh nearly unanimously is the ratepayer protection act and continuing the

1:17:47

SPEAKER_04: theme of an incomplete solution the ratepayer protection act uh sounds great it's got a great

1:17:54

SPEAKER_04: title the problem is that the policy behind that act is simply a perpa must consider resolution

1:18:02

SPEAKER_04: that asks states to consider charging the full network costs of of data centers to that individual

1:18:08

SPEAKER_04: customer um non-binding not complete does nothing for the generation side of the house so

1:18:16

SPEAKER_04: congress knows it needs to do something or needed to do something with the election looming

1:18:23

SPEAKER_04: to address public sentiment around data centers the ratepayer protection act was the nearest

1:18:28

Unknown: easiest policy to grab but i do think that this is going to continue to be something that congress

1:18:33

SPEAKER_04: needs to wrestle with because there are issues that are more appropriate for congress to resolve

1:18:40

Unknown: bigger issues outside the four corners of a rate case that large loads present

1:18:45

Unknown: like the shifting of capital and the shifting of markets um to serve a different kind of

1:18:52

SPEAKER_04: competitor in the energy space than we've ever had to deal with before so i mentioned there are a

1:18:58

SPEAKER_04: number of provisions in the in what's being called baja that's the permitting reform bill

1:19:04

SPEAKER_04: um they seek to have a cost recovery of not only the embedded but also the incremental costs of

1:19:15

SPEAKER_04: transmission service they put a thumb on the scale for retail rate making to recover upfront costs

1:19:24

SPEAKER_04: and and to serve these uh computational loads as a different customer class make another uh some

1:19:31

SPEAKER_04: other changes like suggesting that states could perhaps auction off interconnection requests in

1:19:37

SPEAKER_04: an open season um it just maybe somehow adding tools to the toolbox but it's not really clear

1:19:44

SPEAKER_04: how these would play out these are things that i think we're going to see resurface in the

1:19:48

SPEAKER_04: implementation phase of this if uh baja the permitting reform bill does pass into law

1:19:55

Unknown: any questions on that before i move on i don't have one um a little bit unrelated to exactly

1:20:01

SPEAKER_09: this but no we the interconnection queue was a hot talking point a couple of years ago yeah what

1:20:08

Unknown: i guess the basic version is what has happened with that right so there's not just one queue

1:20:16

SPEAKER_04: obviously each market has there is each utility and really this became a huge problem um again

1:20:25

SPEAKER_04: in places like pjm where the queue is interminable and you would wait there for years um and a lot of

1:20:35

SPEAKER_04: the problems in that market caused firk to really dig into their governance model where they had

1:20:43

SPEAKER_04: they're basically governed by the market participants themselves so they can't really move

1:20:49

SPEAKER_04: forward on policies unless everyone agrees um and they won't move forward on policies unless the

1:20:55

SPEAKER_04: incumbent you know market participants benefit from that policy and they need to all benefit

1:21:03

SPEAKER_04: because they all need to agree so firk is really encouraging pjm to go down to the studs on its

1:21:08

SPEAKER_04: governance model to address things like that so it's not just the interconnection queue that

1:21:13

SPEAKER_04: became a huge hot button because it's so backwards in that market that so desperately

1:21:18

SPEAKER_04: needs generation and cannot bring it online while they still had these outrageous capacity market

1:21:25

SPEAKER_04: costs and we're saying where is all the generation well it's sitting in a queue so deeply dysfunctional

1:21:33

SPEAKER_04: um but it's not as if it's not a problem anywhere else you know the the um interconnection queue was

1:21:41

SPEAKER_04: one of the issues that firk asked rto's to address in its show cause orders and pointed to the way spp

1:21:49

SPEAKER_04: has handled it saying well maybe cluster studies or batches as texas has done uh rather than looking

1:21:56

SPEAKER_04: at these things sequentially um so they're figuring out ways to speed up this process um

1:22:06

Unknown: out of necessity um but certainly it remains an unsolved problem as the different rto's and

1:22:15

SPEAKER_04: utilities kind of work through well what does it look like to actually improve this process

1:22:19

SPEAKER_04: sometimes using ai sometimes streamlining um sometimes just reforming the underlying process

1:22:26

SPEAKER_04: have we um have we seen um any fundamental change in those in the generation queue because of this

1:22:36

SPEAKER_09: ai demand igniting like our projects moving forward because all of a sudden there's a need

1:22:42

SPEAKER_09: there's a desire for that generation so it's really challenging to kind of get a picture of

1:22:50

SPEAKER_04: what exactly is happening so after the rate payer protection pledge there was a lot of conversation

1:22:56

SPEAKER_04: in the data center community about let's just go off grid let's build our own power let's have on

1:23:01

SPEAKER_04: site generation but they don't actually even have a common lexicon for the difference between an

1:23:09

SPEAKER_04: islanded facility a behind the meter facility they use those terms interchangeably um the sense

1:23:16

SPEAKER_04: that maybe you could build on on site generation and interconnect later so you're bringing not only

1:23:25

SPEAKER_04: your load but some kind of generation resource into a utility service territory um my personal view

1:23:34

SPEAKER_04: is that the utility needs to be involved in the development of these facilities early on

1:23:40

SPEAKER_04: not just as a gatekeeper but as a resource for how energy markets and energy power flows actually

1:23:49

SPEAKER_04: and what that facility might need not just to serve its its own needs and have generation and

1:23:55

SPEAKER_04: backup power but how it can be a positive player for the grid system overall

1:24:03

Unknown: anything else on large loads

1:24:09

Unknown: speak to the baja because i've heard a lot of people very upset with that

1:24:14

SPEAKER_07: yes um there are a number of large load provisions um

1:24:21

SPEAKER_04: because this bill was negotiated with four or five people as opposed to you know really

1:24:30

SPEAKER_04: resourcing what you know what's the best policy or or having hearings on this and kind of determining

1:24:36

SPEAKER_04: what what congress wants to do um some of these provisions i think raise serious questions as to

1:24:44

SPEAKER_04: like is that even a good idea um so i have a particular heartburn with a provision that says

1:24:54

Unknown: you know here's a bunch of things that retail rate makers should consider but nothing in this

1:24:58

SPEAKER_04: provision interferes with local rate making authority well obviously what is this provision

1:25:06

SPEAKER_04: even even doing then um an open season for data center interconnection i'm not sure anybody has

1:25:15

SPEAKER_04: the authority to auction that resource off or what that would look like in practice um and

1:25:22

SPEAKER_04: i think requiring firk to change long-standing policy to recover embedded in incremental costs

1:25:29

SPEAKER_04: is a huge paperwork burden for everybody involved and still doesn't address the underlying issue of

1:25:35

SPEAKER_04: how are we going to get generation built so we kind of wrapped around the axle on some of the

1:25:40

SPEAKER_04: transmission pieces and i still haven't seen anything that really kind of takes on how can

1:25:47

SPEAKER_04: we make sure that we have enough power for these facilities and that they're not just building

1:25:53

Unknown: a secondary grid or a bunch of islanded facilities that we have to deal with a couple years from now

1:26:00

SPEAKER_04: when suddenly space i've heard i mean all kinds of crazy stuff yep data centers in space totally

1:26:07

SPEAKER_07: mobilizing to stop this and i guess there were hearings today and i watched a clip of one of the

1:26:11

SPEAKER_07: senators talking strongly against it yeah this is happening in real time right now is that they're

1:26:17

SPEAKER_04: voting on amendments to this bill probably late into the night um i expected to pass but my

1:26:26

SPEAKER_04: jaw would not hit the floor if it narrowly was defeated i i think the house is has been a complete

1:26:36

SPEAKER_04: afterthought in this entire process and i don't think that house leadership has a well articulated

1:26:43

SPEAKER_04: plan for how they're going to pass this nor do i think it's a top priority for them and everything

1:26:47

SPEAKER_04: else they have to do so it's a little my personal opinion another theme of this year has been the

1:26:57

SPEAKER_04: various things that could go wrong uh wildfire natural disasters cyber security we've seen some

1:27:03

SPEAKER_04: examples of the latter uh just this week um but i kind of want to point out that this isn't an

1:27:10

SPEAKER_04: a a broad subject area where we're kind of seeing some divisions between the approach that the

1:27:16

SPEAKER_04: administration would like to take and the approach that congress would like to take not always down

1:27:21

SPEAKER_04: the same lines um but in general the administration when it comes to wildfire and fema would really

1:27:29

SPEAKER_04: like to see states take a larger role where there's large costs they want to shift that to the states

1:27:37

SPEAKER_04: um when it comes to cyber security however it's a very top-down approach so we saw a executive

1:27:44

SPEAKER_04: order this year that prohibits anyone from importing or installing equipment manufactured

1:27:51

SPEAKER_04: from a foreign entity of concern and attaching it to the bulk power system and in some cases

1:27:57

Unknown: uh the department of energy may ask utilities to rip out existing components of the grid

1:28:04

Unknown: if they are going to pose a threat to the bulk power system so we are actively working with the

1:28:12

SPEAKER_04: department of energy on workable solutions to this certainly the biggest concern is chinese

1:28:19

SPEAKER_04: manufactured inverters that there's a sort of concern that that could be used as a remote

1:28:27

SPEAKER_04: control switch embedded in the u.s grid some kind of surveillance i think those are reasonable

1:28:36

SPEAKER_04: concerns what we do to address those concerns without you know hugely causing the same

1:28:44

SPEAKER_04: reliability problems we're trying to avoid is the question that we're working out with department of

1:28:50

SPEAKER_04: energy right now in contrast congress is taking a much more incremental approach when it comes to

1:28:58

SPEAKER_04: wildfire they are diligently working on the fix our forests act a bill that smud has supported

1:29:05

SPEAKER_04: for the past couple of congresses it's an omnibus of wildfire mitigation prevention

1:29:14

Unknown: um and and streamlining of governmental processes they've been working on it for quite some time

1:29:20

Unknown: i know our senator pidea has been very involved in trying to perfect this bill my understanding

1:29:26

SPEAKER_04: is that the issues that are holding it up at this point are not anything about the utility

1:29:31

Unknown: components of the bill um that's that said if they're not able to work those issues out this

1:29:38

SPEAKER_04: might not be ready to drop in uh to a larger bill during this lame duck session so we're really

1:29:45

SPEAKER_04: hoping that they can focus on and address those issues so that this would be ready for inclusion

1:29:50

SPEAKER_04: and pass into law at the end of the year um further behind that is the fema act in contrast

1:29:57

SPEAKER_04: to the administration who would like states to take a larger role congress would like the federal

1:30:02

SPEAKER_04: government to get better at processing and administering those claims so the fema act makes

1:30:09

SPEAKER_04: a number of changes to streamline those approvals they've also been working on reauthorizing uh the

1:30:15

SPEAKER_04: cyber security information sharing act uh that reauthorization has appeared in multiple pieces

1:30:21

SPEAKER_04: of legislation just looking for a vehicle and a home to get it done i do expect that to pass

1:30:27

SPEAKER_04: somehow some way by uh by the end of the year um but there's a large laundry list of stuff that's

1:30:35

SPEAKER_04: piling up that needs to get done on a must-pass basis including annual appropriations defense

1:30:41

SPEAKER_04: authorization extension of the highway bill extension of the farm bill i think extension of

1:30:48

SPEAKER_04: cissa fits in that category of things that really need to get done before the end of the year

1:30:53

Unknown: um i want to touch on poll attachments some people's favorite issue some people's least favorite issue

1:30:58

SPEAKER_04: um this is a local control issue that congress specifically delegated that locally owned polls

1:31:04

SPEAKER_04: should be governed in the local interest by the utility that owns them but broadband providers

1:31:10

SPEAKER_04: uh have a pretty nice sweetheart deal with investor-owned utility poles and they've forgotten what it

1:31:17

SPEAKER_04: actually costs uh to make these polls ready so we had a legislative victory this year because

1:31:23

SPEAKER_04: there was a proposal to institute statutory shot clocks that would deem a proposal granted if the

1:31:32

SPEAKER_04: utility didn't act in time that was then included in the larger broadband bill public power mobilized

1:31:38

Unknown: to correct the record on this issue and do some counter education to what telecom companies had

1:31:45

SPEAKER_04: circulated and that was then removed from the larger bill which then itself stalled out

1:31:53

SPEAKER_04: meanwhile however the same playbook is at work at the federal communications commission

1:32:01

Unknown: where they have proposed to allow all sorts of facilities to attach with those similar

1:32:10

SPEAKER_04: provisions saying that any municipal utility regulation is a municipal ordinance that they

1:32:18

SPEAKER_04: can use a different provision of the communications act to overrule even though there is a section

1:32:25

Unknown: specifically allowing municipally owned poles to be governed by the municipal utility they had some

1:32:32

SPEAKER_04: success uh with the small cell order back in 2018 a ppa took this up to the ninth circuit was

1:32:39

SPEAKER_04: unfortunately unsuccessful so they do have a playbook for claiming that these regulations

1:32:46

SPEAKER_04: are really municipal ordinances that inhibit broadband we're expecting the same sort of

1:32:52

SPEAKER_04: rollout um i'm hopeful that there may be some opportunities to push back on this legislatively

1:32:58

SPEAKER_04: when we take our case to congress and policymakers they suddenly realize that they've perhaps been

1:33:04

SPEAKER_04: misled by telecom companies they really are seeking to get broadband deployed when we talk

1:33:13

SPEAKER_04: about the safety implications and how we don't really want our customers to subsidize those

1:33:19

SPEAKER_04: broadband customers they change their tune they recant they understand our perspective we just

1:33:24

SPEAKER_04: need to get to them before they um you know develop a position too closely based in what they're

1:33:30

SPEAKER_04: hearing from telecom companies to that point with the new legislators do we have a plan to

1:33:37

SPEAKER_07: get to them first it's actually a strategy i use my day job is to make sure i get in the room first

1:33:43

Unknown: that's a huge part of our strategy too um i always like to present an issue of first impression

1:33:50

Unknown: because it's so much easier to educate and lay the groundwork for how somebody thinks about an issue

1:33:57

Unknown: one of the challenges with this issue in particular for us is that it's a top top priority for

1:34:03

SPEAKER_04: broadband companies who spend lavishly to educate policymakers who hire every lobbying firm in town

1:34:13

SPEAKER_04: and then we come in and we're almost always doing cleanup so i do think it's incumbent on us to

1:34:19

SPEAKER_04: continue telling this story and to prioritize it we're not necessarily the constituents of

1:34:28

SPEAKER_04: greatest urgency when it comes to the fcc but we have made i think really good strides

1:34:34

Unknown: in particularly on the democratic side of the aisle with getting folks to understand our

1:34:40

SPEAKER_04: perspective and that it's not as cut and dried as as they have been led to believe but this has been

1:34:47

SPEAKER_04: an issue that's that's ongoing for quite some time now that we've mostly successfully been able to be

1:34:53

SPEAKER_04: to be back at least at the legislative level

1:35:00

SPEAKER_04: i wanted to talk a little bit about the changing role of clean energy and climate in the national

1:35:06

SPEAKER_04: conversation last year it was abundantly clear that the administration was outright hostile

1:35:14

SPEAKER_04: to climate initiatives and to clean energy as a solution to the climate crisis we saw this in

1:35:21

SPEAKER_04: regulatory rollbacks in the attempted gutting of the endangerment finding a legal finding that

1:35:28

SPEAKER_04: underpins a lot of greenhouse gas regulations in hostile maneuvers toward offshore wind and

1:35:36

SPEAKER_04: settlements to make sure that more offshore wind isn't developed but really as this hostility has

1:35:44

SPEAKER_04: been playing out we've seen even among democratic lawmakers a shift in how they're thinking about

1:35:52

SPEAKER_04: the urgency of the climate crisis compared to the urgency of the affordability crisis

1:35:57

Unknown: so we're now living in an environment where decarbonization isn't the only imperative that's

1:36:03

SPEAKER_04: driving energy policy so we have multiple challenges you know multiple crises that are

1:36:11

SPEAKER_04: sort of right in front of policy makers so decarbonization sort of becomes table stakes

1:36:18

SPEAKER_04: for folks on the democratic side and for folks on the republican side they haven't had any incentive

1:36:24

SPEAKER_04: or support from the administration to do even what they might think is right on clean energy

1:36:30

SPEAKER_04: solutions so as we see the rise of the new democratic majority i think it's likely that

1:36:37

SPEAKER_04: we'll start seeing decarbonization go hand in hand with affordability measures and to continue

1:36:44

SPEAKER_04: to to couch these solutions in in those kind of terms rather than putting forth solutions to the

1:36:53

SPEAKER_04: climate crisis that increase energy costs for consumers we have to be able to do both and to

1:36:58

SPEAKER_04: credibly say we're doing both of these things and i think smud's voice in this regard will be

1:37:03

SPEAKER_04: particularly compelling as policy makers are looking for ways to achieve both those policy

1:37:09

SPEAKER_04: goals so with that we can talk a little bit about the midterm elections i could say so much about

1:37:19

SPEAKER_04: about what happened earlier this month in in fact these numbers are already outdated we will have a

1:37:28

SPEAKER_04: 56 seat majority in uh in the senate for democrats will have perhaps upwards of 260 seats in the

1:37:37

SPEAKER_04: house this is a huge freshman class there could be as many as 20 new senators more than 150

1:37:46

SPEAKER_04: new members of congress so perfect time to be doing education on energy issues

1:37:51

SPEAKER_04: um but this is certainly a historic sweep a historic rebuke of the administration's policies

1:37:58

Unknown: particularly the war in iran and the posture on data centers um voters have spoken loud and clear

1:38:07

SPEAKER_04: this is a shift on par with the republican revolution of 1994 not quite as big a shift as

1:38:16

SPEAKER_04: the tea party revolution of 2010 but certainly voters going to the polls in a shift of sometimes

1:38:23

SPEAKER_04: as many as 17 percentage points a shift of 14 points even in rural areas as voters completely

1:38:30

SPEAKER_04: soured on the administration policies and so it remains to be seen how this new congress will

1:38:39

SPEAKER_04: engage with the administration um i think one thing that's interesting is as you see this sort

1:38:48

SPEAKER_04: of jubilant photograph of the incoming democratic senators you now have probably one of the most

1:38:54

SPEAKER_04: progressive democrats abdullah al-sayed from michigan and ostensibly who will likely be one

1:39:01

SPEAKER_04: of the most conservative new democrats james talarico from texas and they're both talking about

1:39:07

SPEAKER_04: billionaires they're both talking about how we treat our neighbor they're both talking about

1:39:13

SPEAKER_04: working with the president to get things accomplished so i think we're still in this

1:39:22

SPEAKER_04: sort of chrysalis goo of figuring out how we want to um engage as a larger community how

1:39:33

SPEAKER_04: policymakers will want to engage i think we got a strong message that voters are very tired of the

1:39:40

Unknown: you know winner take all pugilistic um you know retreat to our camps and disagree on everything

1:39:47

SPEAKER_04: style of government um but it it takes everyone cooperating to overcome that so i was encouraged

1:39:57

SPEAKER_04: by the president's comments on election night that he accepts the results that he you know will

1:40:03

SPEAKER_04: look to work with democrats to get things done that being followed by the elevation of uh steven

1:40:11

SPEAKER_04: miller to chief of staff seems to me to be a step in the opposite direction he has a particularly

1:40:15

SPEAKER_04: pugilistic style um and uh i think democrats have a choice as to whether or not they're going to focus

1:40:25

SPEAKER_04: on oversight and um you know hauling in trump administration officials or whether they're going

1:40:32

SPEAKER_04: to spend their time putting together policies that can be signed into law either in the next two years

1:40:39

Unknown: or moving more slowly on policies that maybe need to wait for a future administration but it it's

1:40:45

SPEAKER_04: it's going to take a lot of agreement for things to get done in the next congress i don't have

1:40:53

Unknown: a ton of confidence that we're going to get tax credits back for electric vehicles to answer your

1:40:59

SPEAKER_04: question from earlier director sanborn um but i do think that there are places where perhaps

1:41:07

SPEAKER_04: the president could work with the democratic congress um the president is rather unpredictable

1:41:12

SPEAKER_04: he may have noticed but one of those um you know sort of unusual qualities is he really does want

1:41:20

SPEAKER_04: to be responsive to public opinion he wants to be popular and so if democrats put forward popular

1:41:25

SPEAKER_04: ideas that he thinks he can sign he might just sign them so there'll be some you know sparring

1:41:32

SPEAKER_04: perhaps and some dancing around to see what the relationship is going to be um but i think uh

1:41:41

Unknown: you know democrats have an interesting two years in front of them particularly because the

1:41:47

SPEAKER_04: presidential nominating contest has already begun the day after the election we're already

1:41:51

SPEAKER_04: talking about the next one but for for democrats they're going to have this interim period where

1:41:58

SPEAKER_04: they have solid majorities but they don't have a standard bearer they don't have someone at the top

1:42:03

SPEAKER_04: of the ticket sort of directing the strategy for the party or how it's going to be defined

1:42:09

Unknown: um going into the future on the republican side what was a fight to be the successor

1:42:18

Unknown: for president trump is quickly turning into everybody distancing themselves from the

1:42:25

SPEAKER_04: president so you'll see that even within his inner circle very likely that you'll see a lot of

1:42:30

SPEAKER_04: turnover um in the cabinet and and in political um appointee positions and it'll be very interesting

1:42:37

SPEAKER_04: to see who emerges from this conversation um and whether or not the president's endorsement

1:42:44

Unknown: as as his sort of hand-picked successor what kind of value that has in the republican primary but

1:42:50

SPEAKER_04: both of these parties are more fluid today than they have ever been in my experience working in

1:42:57

SPEAKER_04: politics so i think a lot of voters are up for grabs when you see 17 percentage point swing from

1:43:04

SPEAKER_04: 2024 to 2026 everyone needs to be thinking about what message they're taking to those voters

1:43:12

SPEAKER_04: whether they can govern and what voters want to see in the future from the parties that we thought

1:43:18

SPEAKER_04: we knew very well so with that i'm happy to take any further questions

1:43:28

Unknown: when i heard somewhere that there might potentially be another reconciliation bill

1:43:33

SPEAKER_09: before the end of the year was that if that is true would that impact in any way like our areas

1:43:40

Unknown: so i have heard from credible sources that reconciliation is in play i don't think that

1:43:48

SPEAKER_04: it would be the reconciliation we've come to know as like big policy omnibus bills that affect a lot

1:43:56

SPEAKER_04: of tax policy it would probably look if they if they do this and i don't know if they have time

1:44:04

Unknown: but they would probably do that to pass defense funding over the objections of democrats and it

1:44:09

SPEAKER_04: would it would have to be incredibly narrow at this point in the year so it would have to be

1:44:14

SPEAKER_04: exclusive it would not be you know everybody throw your thing in the bag um you know let's make

1:44:22

SPEAKER_04: sweeping changes it would be we have this defense bill and we don't have the democratic votes to pass

1:44:27

SPEAKER_04: it so we're going to use reconciliation as the tool in order to get that done

1:44:39

Unknown: are any of the new members of congress talking about energy with respect to

1:44:46

SPEAKER_02: energy independence as as a component of of affordability because these wars have exposed

1:44:55

SPEAKER_02: how depending on foreign oil makes us very vulnerable yes um i don't know that i've heard

1:45:06

SPEAKER_04: a whole lot about solutions for energy independence incredible public uh

1:45:16

Unknown: disgust and dismay at this war of choice um in iran that has driven consumer prices up

1:45:27

Unknown: i haven't heard a whole lot of the solutions type of commentary around that especially on the

1:45:33

SPEAKER_04: campaign trail because if you're campaigning you don't have to offer solutions you just have to

1:45:38

SPEAKER_04: point out what isn't working so there may be individual candidates who have put forward

1:45:46

Unknown: policy proposals i haven't really heard as much about the price of gas and solutions for that so

1:45:53

SPEAKER_04: much as the price of power and there have been some really interesting bills that i think you know

1:46:01

SPEAKER_04: are worth paying attention to that democrats have put forward in this congress that start to look

1:46:06

SPEAKER_04: like maybe hr one two or three in the next congress including bills taking direct aim at utility

1:46:12

SPEAKER_04: profits so it's a very good time to be community-owned almost always a good time to be community-owned

1:46:19

Unknown: um but certainly i think there's some serious scrutiny of the utility model um that we could

1:46:27

SPEAKER_04: have to grapple with when policymakers come in with big ideas about what to do on energy but

1:46:32

SPEAKER_04: less understanding of how things currently work and how different business models currently

1:46:37

SPEAKER_04: function um but i i've heard less about um solutions for for the price of gas other than just

1:46:46

Unknown: getting out of war in iran and ending that conflict just to build on that i mean when the

1:46:53

SPEAKER_07: administration came in they were talking all about that but they were talking about digging up

1:46:57

SPEAKER_07: and using our own natural fossil fuel resources nobody heard anything about a war at that time

1:47:04

SPEAKER_07: when the campaign had happened and all of that but it feels like now there's an opportunity to go

1:47:11

SPEAKER_07: in with our new representatives and remind them that we have projects we can't get permitted

1:47:17

SPEAKER_07: right now for windmills and there's a bunch of stuff that's turnkey and shovel ready if we can

1:47:23

SPEAKER_07: get approvals that could make us more energy independent and that's the way to frame it

1:47:28

Unknown: absolutely absolutely

1:47:31

Unknown: it was about the first um thanks for you know risking life and limb in a week when systems all

1:47:36

SPEAKER_10: over the country seems to be falling apart to fly out here and be here in person we've

1:47:39

SPEAKER_10: magically had really easy travel getting here so we're not going to get that thank thank you for

1:47:44

SPEAKER_10: that um you know there hasn't been too much change in our local delegation obviously uh dr pan won

1:47:52

SPEAKER_10: over kevin kiley um you know everything we sort of understanding is his focus is going to be on

1:47:57

SPEAKER_10: health care he's a he's a physician is there any among the new people are there any champions for

1:48:03

SPEAKER_10: energy that and specifically for for public public energy that i mean somebody with some

1:48:09

SPEAKER_10: experience or background in in what we do that that we might want to focus on that's a really

1:48:16

SPEAKER_04: good question um i mean you you're supposed to have all of their personal dusseas memorize you

1:48:25

SPEAKER_10: know the 75 new members by now um nobody's bringing to mind um you know i think folks

1:48:37

SPEAKER_04: who run for congress are you know on day one they're generalists you know they come with their

1:48:43

SPEAKER_04: background um and they're asked to take positions on policy issues that they have no prior knowledge

1:48:53

SPEAKER_04: of um i enjoy that aspect of it i always want to be the person who is you know spending an hour

1:49:02

SPEAKER_04: with a new energy policy staffer doing energy 101 like here's what you need to know here's all the

1:49:08

SPEAKER_04: acronyms um i can't i can't say that i have identified a specific incoming member that has

1:49:19

SPEAKER_04: particular energy expertise i'm sure there are but one of the side effects of a freshman class

1:49:29

SPEAKER_04: this big and a wave this big is there are all kinds of incoming freshman members of congress

1:49:35

Unknown: who no one has heard of before federal you know party dollars were not spent on these races

1:49:43

SPEAKER_04: we have a democrat coming to congress from tennessee and nebraska and and kentucky um you know

1:49:50

SPEAKER_04: parts of the country that were reliably republican iowa um so you know the these are not candidates

1:50:01

SPEAKER_04: that received help or attention from the national party that we're going to be getting to know

1:50:06

SPEAKER_04: brand new um some of them might be pretty interesting um with the wave this big um you

1:50:13

SPEAKER_04: know but i i think certainly energy affordability is something that they all understood to be on

1:50:22

SPEAKER_04: the minds of voters and are going to be interested in quick action to address thank you

1:50:31

Unknown: okay well thank you thank you do we have any cards or comments i do not see any public comment

1:50:39

SPEAKER_06: no okay so the next item is for uh public comment on items not on the agenda do we have any

1:50:46

SPEAKER_03: not on the agenda i don't believe we have any no no public comment i'm not hiding either

1:50:52

SPEAKER_03: written comments received and i was not agenda will be included in the record if received within

1:50:57

SPEAKER_03: two hours then of the meeting and then was there any um committee director just have one thing staff

1:51:04

SPEAKER_06: will provide information to the board about the cost and feasibility of undergrounding the portion

1:51:09

SPEAKER_06: of the line that runs through the residential neighborhood related to our pocket substation

1:51:19

Unknown: thank you

1:51:21

Unknown: thank you